NYC or NY? If the latter, Melissa D'Amico ...

..was from Suffolk County in eastern Long Island, out by Danielle Cosgrove.

Can't think of any city natives outside of Ms. Gaither. Remember the contest we ran a year or two ago on who should be next in the Ring of Honor? She won handily.

BTW, TMLA was not anywhere close to top of the standings in the Catholic league this year...Christ the King, with Ms. Marshall, was one major reason why.

If ND wants to try another part of the metropolitan New York area, I suggest:
- First going slightly north to Westchester County to watch Sonia Citron (a lot) at the Ursuline School;
- Then, cross the Hudson River into New Jersey and drive west to watch Point Guard Olivia Miles from Phillipsburg; and,
- Lastly, head to the Jersey Shore to see the sublime 6'3" Destiny Adams in Manchester Township. The Shore gave ND the Mabreys and that turned out just fine...*

* I've refrained from bringing up the name of the youngest of those daughters, although I'm mashing my mental teeth as I type.