Halladay didn’t need that to stand apart.
by tdiddy07 (2022-01-15 13:18:43)

In reply to: I think GK’s point was if 90% of one’s “similar players”  posted by Father Nieuwland

He has nine seasons with an ERA+ of 140, 6 seasons with a sub-3 ERA and 2 Cy Youngs. He is not in the same discussion as Lester or Hudson or David Cone. He was actually one of the most dominant pitchers of his era. He was a likely Hall of Famer anyway. The no hitter at most made him a lock.