Irish Shut Down MAC Attack

Notre Dame stumbled through the first twenty minutes of the game but ultimately took control and ground out a 28-3 victory over Miami of Ohio. Riley Leonard ran for 143 yards and two scores while completing his first touchdown pass of the season. His 38-yard strike to Beaux Collins before halftime was the team’s best pass play of the season. Once again, the Fighting Irish defense shut down the opposition. They allowed only 229 total yards, forced two turnovers, and recorded four sacks. The win moves Notre Dame to 3-1 on the season and 1-1 in the Mid-American Conference.

The began in ominous fashion for the hosts. After stopping the opening Redhawk drive, the Irish gave the ball right back when Jordan Faison failed to catch Alec Bevelhimer’s punt. Miami moved quickly into scoring territory before cornerback Christian Gray knocked away a slant pass near the goal line. End Junior Tuihalamaka grabbed the ball before it hit the ground for the interception. Gray continues to show excellent instincts for the ball and does not hesitate to make a play on it.

Junior Tuihalamaka celebrates after an interception

Notre Dame’s offense failed to capitalize. Penalties, errant passes, missed blocks, and a special teams snafu plagued the Irish attack during their first three possessions. Meanwhile, the Redhawks were able to get on the scoreboard with a short field goal after a productive drive stalled in the red zone.

Leonard began to establish a rhythm on his short passes midway through the second period. A pair of 15-yard penalties helped sustain a long drive that Leonard closed with an eight yard scoring run. Notre Dame finally had its first lead (7-3) with just 3:33 remaining in the half.

This touchdown seemed to wake up the hosts. The defense quickly got the ball back and the Irish faithful awaited the upcoming two minute drill with an equal measure of excitement and trepidation. Leonard responded with a 21-yard run, a 14-yard pass to Kris Mitchell, and a beautiful 38-yard bomb to Collins for a 14-3 advantage. Collins had beaten his defender by two steps down the right sideline as the ball hit him in stride.

Notre Dame took the second half kickoff and began to march. Leonard broke off a long run into Redhawk territory before being stripped of the ball. Miami recovered after the ensuing scramble after two Irish players somehow managed to let the pigskin slip away.

After a subsequent exchange of punts, Gray delivered a big play for the Irish defense. He made a leaping interception on a deep sideline throw by Brett Gabbert to put Notre Dame back on the attack. Leonard threw another accurate bomb to Mitchell, who drew a pass interference penalty on what would have been a touchdown.

The Irish kept plugging away through the air before Jeremiah Love took an inside handoff from 15 yards out and scored to make it 21-3 late in the third quarter. Replay apparently missed that a Miami defender dislodged the ball from Love before he crossed the goal line. Tackle Aamil Wagner fell on the ball in the end zone and should have been credited with his first career touchdown.

Notre Dame blocked a Redhawk field goal attempt in the final stanza before embarking on its final scoring march. Leonard broke through the line on a fourth down plunge and did not stop until he reached the end zone. Coach Marcus Freeman cleared his bench in the final minutes as the 28-3 margin held firm.

Beaux Collins hauled in Leonard’s first 2024 touchdown pass

After four weeks of play, the inconsistency of Notre Dame’s offense remains a concern. Leonard’s 16 of 25 passing effort contained the highlight play to Collins but was offset by a number of late and off-target short range throws. He stepped up in the pocket more frequently and found open receivers but misfired more often than not. Defensively, the Irish front seven often surrenders chunks of yardage on the ground but usually manages to tighten up when it matters most. The secondary remains solid.

Let’s review the answers to our pregame questions:

  • Will Notre Dame suffer another emotional letdown after a lopsided win? Once again, the Irish started poorly. It is difficult to tell if they were lethargic today or this team is simply not as good as we expected them to be. I lean toward the latter.
  • Can the Irish stuff Miami’s running game and make them one-dimensional? As has been the usual pattern, Notre Dame gave up a few productive runs early but settled in to shut down the visitors.
  • Which team will have the fewest penalties and turnovers? Both teams were sloppy. Each had two turnovers. Miami had ten penalties to eight for Notre Dame.
  • Will the Irish special teams win the battle of field position? Punter James Rendell had a good game at the right time. He punted the Irish out of deep holes in the first half and allowed the coverage to limit any significant returns. A botched snap on a Mitch Jeter field goal attempt and the fumbled punt were unacceptable lowlights.
  • Can Notre Dame’s secondary limit yards after catch by the Redhawk receivers? Cade McDonald had a couple of healthy catch and run receptions but there were no game breaking plays by the Redhawks.
  • Will Love and Price continue to break off big chunk runs? No. Miami employed a proven defensive strategy against the Irish. They stacked the box and dared Leonard to beat them with the pass. The Irish took some advantage of this with a couple of successful throws but would have scored at least 42 points with a more polished aerial attack. Ultimately, Leonard ended up beating the Redhawks with his legs.
  • Can Notre Dame pressure Gabbert into a subpar performance? Yes, Gabbert was 14 for 35 and was under pressure on almost every throw.
  • Will Leonard get the Irish passing game off the ground? Yes, although they are going to need much more of this next week and beyond to make opponents respect this part of their attack.

A home engagement ndefeated Louisville is the next opportunity for Notre Dame. Anyone who believes last seaon’s spanking was a fluke had better think again. The Irish need to be better next week than they were today if they expect to win.

60 thoughts on “Irish Shut Down MAC Attack

  1. They won but they didn’t impress me at all. This is a good team, but that seems to be about it.

    “This team is simply not as good as we expected them to be” – that about sums it up.

        • Another first half like that against Louisville and/USC and ND will have to rely on Leonard’s arm in 2nd half because they will be behind big time. Oh my. How can he be so bad on the short throws?

          I see 10-2 as final record against a soft schedule. Maybe.

      • Correct me if you have the ability to check the game film in slow motion, but at the time (and with each replay immediately thereafter) it appeared very clear that our #7 moved directly into the space that Faison was moving up toward in an effort to field that punt, thereby preventing Faison from getting his body under the descending ball, and so he was forced to reach out awkwardly into the space immediately between him and #7, doing so while focusing on the descending ball and only able to judge the rapidly diminishing space between himself and #7 by “feel” (not direct eyesight).

  2. This was a sloppy and unimpressive win. Even though it was 28-3 the game felt closer and ND let Miami hang around through three quarters. For awhile it looked like it would be Deja vu NIU all over again.

    I’m not saying this as a spoiled fan but the CFP pollsters will not be impressed with this win and ND is unlikely to move up in the polls or if they do only one spot at most.

    Riley Leonard’s errant passes when receivers were open killed drives and this will eventually cost some games if this doesn’t change. Right now ND is not a playoff caliber team and I don’t think that’s going to change. Also, a different ND team shows up every week and a lack of identity isn’t acceptable in year 3 of Freeman’s tenure.

  3. JVAN,

    ND is a poorly coached team..Period. They continue to play down to the level of competition.

    MF is a nice guy and a great recruiter but is unable to prepare the team on a weekly basis to dominate inferior opponents..

    And the loss to NIU looks even worse after they lost at home yesterday to Buffalo..Are you kidding me!!!!

    It’s no longer fun to watch the Irish stumble through these games.. Heck, even Navy has a shot at beating the Irish this season in a few weeks.

    This is not a playoff team.. They would barely win the MAC Conference this year.

    Jeff Brohm is a great coach and Louisville will be fully prepared… So the Irish better get it together soon.

    • “They continue to play down to the level of competition.” Mostly true, the exception being Purdue, but in that one they were embarrassed by the week before and they were pissed, and they took it out on Purdue, which they should have.

      But yesterday – nothing special.

      Next week – who’s gonna show up?

  4. Thank you John for the recap.

    Part of it said, in essence, ‘the Irish faithful awaited with an equal measure of excitement and trepidation.’ That should be on the sign the players slap as they head out of the locker room.

    We will continue to see the load-the-box-and-make-Leonard-pass strategy unless and until he can complete very short passes (or any passes) with accuracy and regularity.

    We’re lead to believe Leonard is a good fellow, and that he’s a hard worker. Those are good attributes but that’s not the whole checklist to play QB at ND. This upcoming Louisville game should be one that the Irish look toward as a chance to redeem themselves from that awful showing last year at Louisville…..do they even get that? I’m feeling a lot trepidation all of a sudden.

  5. Fellas, let’s face the facts, Freeman has to go. Much as I like him, the football team cannot choose the head coach, which the previous AD allowed. And, here’s the inconvenient truth: for this to transpire the Irish must lose, beginning next Saturday.

  6. John – you are right on about the Irish – not nearly as good as advertised. Uninspired play and careless mistakes as well as lack of discipline with penalties. Coach Freeman continues to speak of Leonard in glowing terms. Most of us who have followed ND for years see it much different. Not even close to QB’s that were ND men – the transfer portal route with QB’s will be costly for the Coach. Angeli much more of a threat with the pass – teams will load up to stop the run game and the short 5 yard passing game will not lead to TD’s . Leonard continues to have a look of non confidence. Was it Coach Freeman’s comments at half time about that ? Would agree that the secondary and linebackers have been a positive but defensive front will get worn out with too many 3 and outs from Offense.Analytics rep on sideline is in ear of Freeman – can’t ever see that happen with Ara or Lou !

  7. Been reading you for years and appreciate your healthy, but respectful skepticism. I haven’t figured out Leonard either Vannie. At this point I say we crush Louisville and USC, but I fear Army and Virginia. Strange vibe. Could disappoint also capable of elevating. I tend to be in the latter camp because they got Denbrock and their offensive shortcomings can be corrected.

  8. Stating to think Freeman is a good coordinator but not a very good head coach. Four games into the season and we have one touchdown pass.and struggle against MAC teams. Do not have a lot of confidence in him moving forward.

  9. Fellas, lets face it, Freeman has to go. We’ve seen the enough of what happens when you panic and let the football team choose the next HC. Unfortunately, for this the to happen the Irish must lose. Beginning Saturday.

    • CHRISTOPHER SEGUIN says:

      Dude, reposting the same thing under two different names just makes you look like a stupid bot. Try harder next time.

        • AlGolden Domer says:

          The problem is Riley Leonard.
          His passing rating from DUKE and this season are terrible.

          Please show the data from his 2023 DUKE and this year’s stats.

          Angeli was much better and would have liked to see how he did with Minchey as a wildcat who can throw.

  10. I remember going to the USC game at the dump of Coliseum with my uncle Billy in 2000 after they took control of the game to win it..my uncle told me that ND plays “stupid football” .. I was happy to win until it sunk in over the years.. he was right. I am 51 so I was lucky enough to be able to watch the great Lou Holtz teams and that was the last time ND teams were tough and played smart (yes the had their head scratching losses Tennessee 91 blown lead, Stanford 1992 blown lead 16-0, etc) but we were tough. My point that I’m trying to make is that these ND teams have not played smart decent football for over 30 years.. they look incompetent often times and have not developed a great quarterback in forever.. defense has been decent but not elite. The defense isn’t the issue despite the fact that the line has been underwhelming thus far..when will we be able to sit down and see a program that performs consistently on the field and doesn’t look scared on offense? Lastly Freeman was allegedly quoted as saying “ we will do what Miami of Ohio allows us to do on offense” This ain’t 2002 Ohio State with Craig Krenzel..If we don’t take shots vertically and use the best quarterback available and use the talent we that possess on offense, we will surely lose 3 more games playing like this! My older brother was a freshman there in 88 and told me that they all thought it would always be like this.. winning and winning big games.. I sure miss those teams and that vibe.

    • To your point, I remember standing on the step outside the south dining hall as a student sometime around 1989 and, after ND had (again?) recruited the #1 class, reading an article in The Observer with a quote from a third party suggesting that “Notre Dame will win the national championship for the next five years.” I remember thinking how lucky I was to be there at that time. If you had told me in that moment that I would be 55 years old and not have ever seen another national championship (or, if we’re honest, even come close), I would have laughed you off the campus. Thanks to several athletic directors for a string of incredibly bad head coaching hires, for moving ND from its place atop college football to an annual embarrassment, and for making a fool of me.

  11. The team will not make the playoffs unless the QB is changed. Not only is our quarterback a terrible passer (which will not improve at this late stage of his career) but I think he is a negative influence on team chemistry. And that always impacts both sides of the ball. My sense is that players are playing for themselves more than the team. Just like pro teams. We need students playing for ND, not transfers playing for a chance to make the NFL. That is an environment engineered by the coaches. Stop blaming the players for results created by coaching mistakes in the game plan and depth chart. 9-3 season at best. No 3rd Year coaching magic. Ugh.

  12. You can’t rush if you can’t pass. ND uses almost every second of play clock on offense. Never any hurry up or any misdirection. Special teams still needs work though punting improve. Mental mistakes need to stop

  13. This game went exactly as I expected: good defense, spotty offense. It’s so frustrating to see Denbrock and Freeman trying to force a square peg into a round hole. If you insist on playing a spread offense you need a pinpoint passer. Riley Leonard is not that guy. He has a weak, erratic arm with absolutely no touch, and he doesn’t seem to be able to see the whole field. He does not see wide open receivers, does not effectively read defenses, does not go through his progressions, and he panics under pressure in the pocket. He has happy feet, and his throwing motion is fundamentally unsound. Every ND commentator, analyst, reporter, podcaster, message board commenter, and fan sees how bad a passer Riley Leonard is. Do Denbrock and Freeman not see what is obvious to everyone else? John, help us out here. You have your sources close to the program. Why for heaven’s sake are Freeman and Denbrock playing the worst passer of the 4 qbs that ND has on the roster (5 if you count Buchner)? This whole mystery is painful to those of us who love ND football. I wouldn’t feel this bad if Freeman had stuck to his original plan and implemented a ground and pound attack with the use of multiple tight ends. Then Leonard would make some sense. Look what Michigan has been able to accomplish with a power /run heavy offense. But it is insanity to change to a spread offense and choose Leonard as the guy to run it. Please make some sense of this, John. Thanks.

    • A few reasons.

      They are not paying him $1.5 million to sit on the bench.

      Also, Angeli is not a great practice player although he seems to elevate his performance in games. He hasn’t earned the complete trust of the coaches.

      CJ Carr is the future but they don’t want to put him in games before he is ready and risk destroying his confidence.

      There is pressure at ND to win now rather than to develop talent and suffer through the growing pains. I’m reminded of the NY Yankees and their endless annual pursuit of washed up free agents to plug holes in the lineup. Most times it just does not work out.

      • John, thanks for this. Your Yankees analogy is quite insightful. For me the frustration is that I think Freeman can be a great head coach. He has the resources and the will to recruit effectively. I absolutely love the young talent he has amassed. In the long run I think he will be very successful. Right now, in the short term, he is learning some valuable lessons. I don’t know if you are good at reading body language and “coach speak” but to me Freeman seems as angry and dejected as the fan base. I think he knows he has put himself in a corner by hiring Leonard as this year’s mercenary qb. I think he has learned his lesson about renting players at a premium price. His problem, however, is what to do now. It seems like he feels boxed in with no way out. The irony is that as an inexperienced head coach Freeman is learning valuable lessons while taking his lumps. He should allow his young quarterbacks to also learn valuable lessons by getting them off the bench and on to the field. Leonard is of no help to him in the short term or long term. God…this is frustrating.

        • One more loss and Freeman should pull the plug on Leonard. I’m somewhat skeptical that he will do it but the team will be better off if he does.

          • John, I agree. Louisville will be the knife that lances the boil that is ND football. They will get the lead, load the box, and force Leonard to pass. The results will not be pretty. Then, I think Freeman will be finally free to give the young guys a chance (don’t sleep on Minchey who might be the best fit for Denbrock’s offense). In the long run this is an ideal scenario. The Irish are going nowhere with Leonard…so let’s play the long game by developing our young talent. Louisville will be a turning point in Freeman’s career.

      • Appreciate your insights on this burning question, Vannie. I suspect we will see more of Angeli soon enough as an injury to Riley seems inevitable. Hate to see our RB talent wasted in a scheme that can’t work with such inconsistent passing. On one of his few good throws, you didn’t even have to see the receiver to know it was going to be a good one (i.e. the live camera angle). Riley planted his foot and let it rip. Beautiful pass; all too infrequent. Sigh.

      • So instead they’re paying him $1.5 million to throw behind the receivers or over their heads which our other QBs could easily do for free. And lose games. Boy do they look stupid!

  14. Thanks for your continued effort and insight, John. I had to listen to the RedHawk radio call on my way home to see the game, and their announcers were delighted by but critical of Leonard’s play. I felt less enthused. How far behind will the Irish fall against a ranked opponent before another quarterback gets a chance? The A&M game felt fun and exciting, but those emotions have been replaced for me with anxiety and frustration, deepened by the realization that a string of key injuries make this team far less dangerous than the one that took the field in College Station. Maybe it’s time for a preview of the hockey season.

    • Ready for what? The problem is we never know what kind of game this team will play. They are all over the place.

      For my Louisville game preview and prediction, I’m going to use either a Ouija board or just randomly throw some darts.

      • My prediction, FWIW, is that having been successful last year with a particular defensive approach against a proven, highly experienced and moderately-to-occasionally-very accomplished ND passing QB, he will employ the same strategy this year, especially since our )-line is even power this year than it was in 2023 (and yes, I recall all the positive press that line had received pre-season, and that the tackles were 1st and 2nd round picks, but the performance was horrid, with Hartman running for his life all game long, shutting down the passing game, and giving him a severe case of happy feet). This version of ND offense is evermore subject to that kind of defensive attack. We can only hope that Denbrock reviews that game’s film long and hard, and comes up with a counter-attack. THAT is what he was hired for and he needs to earn that salary this week.

      • Hahahahah,,,,,good one John, however, ND tends to be ready for the big games under Coach Freeman and his record is respectable vs top 25 teams. We shall see…..

  15. Totally agree with NBND75. If the coaching staff can’t s figure out that Leonard can’t and will never be a consistent passer, then they need replaced. When Angelli is chased from the pocket, his head is always up looking downfield and he can throw on the run. Riley possesses none of those traits.

  16. Another good article as usual, JVannie. I think the main problem has to be Freeman. These kids are talented and they work hard. The talent isn’t elite, but it’s better than the level of play we usually see. Sure, there are a lot of new faces on offense, but by week three a good HC should sort that out and establish an identity. This offense just looks completely lost for extended periods, even against inferior talent. Golden and Denbrock are proven coordinators, so that leaves one major factor, the head coach. Freeman is starting to remind me of Gerry Faust – a good person with some coaching ability who is just in over his head. If Marcus can’t get this team into the top 12 by the end of the year then his seat should be getting very warm.

    • ♥️#501988🍀🏈💪 says:

      1.) The team won’t make the playoffs you heard it here!!!!!
      2.) Offense is dismal and after yesterday’s game convo MARCUS sticking with Leonard mindboggling.
      3.) The offensive mind set on run first then pass is ludicrous!!!!! This isn’t the Holtz years is anyway shape or form!
      4.) Can we have a year where SPECIAL TEAMS are NOT hurting us!!!!!!!????????
      5.) Mental mistakes and lack of mental preparation is on the coaches!!!!!!!!
      6.) You better get LOTS of rest!!!!! yesterday was an appetizer for the rest of the season!!!!!

      • Yes, Marcus being married to Leonard is a huge mistake, the worst he’s made as HC imo. Screw the NIL money, let Leonard collect his checks from the bench. And if Freeman can’t see how badly Leonard is hurting the team, then Freeman ain’t the guy for ND.

  17. I enjoy the articles and posters comments. Well expressed and insightful. You all could have been my dorm mates. This may be Gerry Faust 2.0. I am always amused by coaches who take the position that someone is not playing because they are not good in practice. So you play the good practice player who stinks in the real game over the poor practice player who shines in games? There is no pressure in practice so some people do well but get “happy feet” when the lights are on. That is what I’m seeing now. We don’t have a title in 1977 if the poor practice player doesn’t save the day when the two better practice players get injured (nor does that coach have a statue outside our stadium). I agree that money is the issue but we waisted more money on Weis so this should not be a reason to tank the season or the program on a failed rent-a-QB program with a player we beat last year.

  18. Alas, with his unwavering commitment to yet another million dollar qb rental from the ACC, who like his predecessor Hartman isn’t that good, and his inability to properly motivate his team against inferior talent, MF is proving to be in over his head…and Denbrock doesn’t appear to be his savior……ND looks like a high school team, and unlikely to be a 12 team play-off contender.

  19. I’ve been an Irish fan for 75 years . So over that time until Holtz left as bad as the Irish were they were still capable of pulling upsets now we r the team being upset. My comment for the Louisville game is we better change the Quarterback quick if we’re not able to move the ball .

  20. It won’t matter what color uniforms the Irish wear against Louisville (unless they make the players invisible). The Irish are an 8-4 team, especially with Leonard at quarterback. I remember a clip with Joe Montana saying he was like 6th string quarterback before he worked his way up. Give Angeli a chance as I have been saying for weeks. His potential ceiling is higher than Leonard.

    This rent-a-player team approach will never make ND a national contender nor will the hire of Freeman. At my age, I would take odds against me ever living to see another Irish national title. Sad, but true.

  21. This was not a pretty win, but I’ll take it. It was very encouraging to see Leonard’s progress over the course of the game in his passing, particularly on deep throws, after getting off to a terrible start. Hopefully, this upward trend will continue. As usual, Leonard’s running was terrific, but he needs to secure the ball and be a little smarter about sliding or getting out of bounds to avoid unnecessary hits and potential injuries. It was also encouraging to see another solid performance from the O line, marred only by the three penalties by Pendleton. The defense, as usual, played very well, and is clearly one of the best in the country, and, of course, our secondary is the best in the country. I anticipate that we will play very well against Louisville next week, and hand them their first loss of the season next week.

  22. -Three-star quarterback and three-star head coach. Tough to win national championships or even meaningful playoff games with that.
    -Speaking of threes, I think the three skills necessary in a college football head coach to win a natty are recruiting, motivation, and talent development. Since Holtz, we’ve selected head coaches who have had at most 2 out of the 3. The NIU, Miami (Ohio), Marshall, and Stanford games tell me Freeman doesn’t know how to motivate when his players are susceptible to going through the motions. I will hold out the smallest amount of hope (because I am not bright) until one more embarrassment that he has learned or will learn.
    -JV, do you have any sense whether Bevacqua has the guts and skills to put an end to the first-time head coach mistake if it continues to go as it has? I saw a little from him in the offseason but not enough to be able to tell. Swarbrick was obviously thrilled with a kingdom preservation approach (10-2 will keep people in the seats).

    • The Administration loves Freeman, so he will get his five years barring a complete collapse. We’ll see in December 2026 whether Notre Dame still wants to compete at the highest level despite potentially having to recognize players as employees and compensate them accordingly. If championship football remains the goal and ND has not made significant progress under Freeman, I believe Bevacqua would be able and willing to replace him. I doubt Bevacqua would hire a first time head coach, though. He would conduct more thorough due diligence than Swarbrick did when Kelly left. Clearly, Jack panicked.

  23. The defense deserves some credit for bailing out the offense. The offense and special teams make so many mistakes it keeps weaker teams in games by keeping the score down and not forcing them to make mistakes. The difference between this and NIU was NIU made no major mistakes and ripped off a few big played when given a chance. Leonard is not very good. If the team will have any success going forward they will have to remain a run first team and do just enough passing to keep defenses honest. This also means playing mistake free football where a muffed punt doesn’t set tone for 20 minutes.

  24. Jim (the other one) says:

    I only caught some of the late action — saw Leonard’s touchdown run, but not much else. Sports Illustrared ran a story during the game saying fans were chanting to take Leonard out during the first half. Just curious if anyone could hear that on NBC?

    I’m afraid it’s quite likely true that many of ND’s players care less about playing for the Irish than their prospects for making the NFL. It’s the nature of the game, unfortunately. Teams like Colorado are more likely to draw players these days. I remember Bill Walton saying that when he was in high school, he knew he would play in the NBA, but his real goal and his dream was to have a chance to play for UCLA. ND used to have players like that; maybe they still have some, but they are becoming more rare.

  25. OK I am officially worried because I thought we were going to actually be a solid contender this year. My problem is trying to understand how we could be this bad. Freeman looks confused most of the time. Changes to the offensive plays to counter the opponents are not being made. It honestly looks like CW is back on the sidelines. Develop a game plan on Friday and stick with it Saturday. There have been several play situations they could have inserted Angeli if just to confuse the defense. Leonard is making the opponents defense totally disregard the pass and our win was more about having better players than the plays called. I cannot see how Freeman won’t move to a rotating QB system to beat Louisville. We can count on every team to load the box and dare us to pass. As far as Leonard’s running I have not figured out how he is able to make defenders miss. He looks slow, uncoordinated but manages somehow elusive.