Kyren Williams’ 91-yard scoring run early in the fourth quarter gave Notre Dame some breathing room and the Fighting Irish held on for a 44-34 victory on Saturday night over a potent North Carolina squad. Both offenses stormed up and down the field most of the night. Carolina used explosive plays to score while Notre Dame was more methodical. That is, until Williams decided enough was enough.
Nursing a slim 31-27 lead, the Irish were pinned deep in their own territory as the final period began. Williams took a first down handoff to the right, saw it was closed off, reversed his field, and stiff-armed 265-pound linebacker Tomon Fox as he turned the corner and streaked down the sideline. A key downfield block by Michael Mayer cleared the final obstacle as Williams breezed into the end zone.
An interception by D.J. Brown on the next Carolina play from scrimmage set up a Jonathan Doerer field goal. Notre Dame’s lead had suddenly expanded to 41-27 but there were still 12 minutes left. Quarterback Sam Howell, who would throw for 341 yards and run for 102 more, ran out of time and magic despite pulling his team to within 41-34 with a 31-yard scoring run. The Irish burned the clock after that score with a long march that ended with a final three-pointer from Doerer.
The first half had plenty of action as well. Tyler Buchner opened the scoring with a short touchdown pass to Avery Davis. The Tar Heels answered on the first play of the second period with a scoring run by Ty Chandler. The drive was aided by a 41-yard strike from Howell to Josh Downs where offensive pass interference was ignored by the officials. The teams then exchanged field goals before Jack Coan hit Kevin Austin with a back shoulder throw for a score and a 17-10 Irish advantage with 1:23 left in the half.
Carolina took advantage of Notre Dame’s prevent defense to move into field goal position as the clock ticked down. Kicker Grayson Atkins had just enough time to close the gap to 17-13 before the teams retreated to their respective locker rooms.
Chandler gave the Heels their first and only lead of the night less than two minutes into the third quarter. Trailing now by 20-17, Coan needed only three plays to jump back in front. He completed a pass to impressive freshman Lorenzo Styles before rumbling into the end zone untouched from 21 yards on a scramble. The Irish defense finally held on the next series. The offense responded with an 81 yard touchdown march to build a 31-20 cushion.
The Tar Heels caught the Irish secondary in disarray two minutes later. Howell hit a wide open Antoine Green for a 33-yard score to pull Carolina within 31-27 as the game officially became a shootout. A rare exchange of punts set the stage for Williams’ highlight reel run, which may have been the best Irish run from scrimmage since Erik Penick’s 85-yarder in 1973. Of course, that one occurred against USC in a national championship season. Still, Williams worked harder for his score and his stiff-arm of Fox to the turf will never be topped.
Williams finished with 202 yards on 22 carries. The team gained 293 yards on the ground and 523 overall. Carolina shredded the Notre Dame defense for 554 total yards.
Let’s review the answers to our pregame questions for more analysis.
- Will the Irish secondary be successful in limiting explosive plays without Hamilton? Not at all. Brown’s interception was a rare bright spot in an otherwise forgettable performance.
- Which team will make crucial mistakes or turnovers? The lone mistake by Howell occurred in the fourth quarter and put Carolina down by 14 points.
- Will Notre Dame’s front four be able to force Howell out of his comfort zone? The Irish front played fairly well, but Howell masterfully sidestepped the rush and made positive yards.
- Which team will have success running the ball? Both teams ran well. The Irish left points on the field with two failed series inside the five yard line.
- Can the Irish wide receivers get open against the Carolina corners? Austin was inconsistent and Braden Lenzy was not a factor. He was injured in the second half and it now looks like Styles has earned the job anyway.
- Will the quarterback tandem of Coan and Buchner work well once again? The two-quarterback system worked well on the first scoring drive with Buchner’s pass to Davis. After that, it seemed disjointed and failed to produce the desired results.
- Which special teams will make a significant contribution? Doerer’s three field goals were perect and Williams had a long punt return to set up the first touchdown of the game.
- Can the Spartans take out the Evil Empire? Yes, and it was indescribably delicious.
Notre Dame moves to 7-1 on the season with a home game against Navy next. The offense has made strides toward run/pass balance and did not turn over the ball. Some red zone refinement is still needed. Defensively, it was a poor showing by the back seven. Tackling was once again sloppy and players were repeatedly out of position. This was easily the worst performance by linebackers J.D. Bertrand and Drew White this season. It’s one thing to miss tackles against a tough running back or a quick receiver, but you know things are bad when a quarterback runs over and through you all night long. As much as the offense has improved in eight games, the defense has steadily gotten worse.
Tell John what you think in the Comments section below
John Amberg says:
John, I agree with your assessment of the defense. I don’t know what they have to do to improve. Yes, Kyle Hamilton’s injury has hurt them. And not having Maris or Moalo all season has been tough on them, too. What is worse, though is the lack of recruiting at the linebacker position the past few seasons. The secondary is struggling, too. Even the defensive line, which has been solid all year, missed their share of tackles and failed to wrap up Howell on many plays. Do we need to be worried about Navy?
ccb says:
Is Freeman a real DC or simply a fantastic recruiter.
His defense will cause the team to unravel at some point w/ multiple losses.
BK is getting paid enough to figure this out.
You can’t even rule out an upset my Navy given the vulnerability of the D
Let’s have a tackling clinic and a lesson in how not to play prevent defense and
throw in a new rule: We don’t ever rush 3 at ND!!!
Bocceman2 says:
Look at Cincys defenses when he was there. Terrible. Never understood why he was hired.
Topgome says:
Here’s another rule. Play Botelho more. As DCs go, Freeman is better than BVG but only because BVG didn’t think recruiting was part of his job description. This defense is just plain awful.
TimmyIrish says:
Excellent breakdown of the game. Very happy with the win, but wow…the defense needs to improve its tackling.
Mike d says:
Since it’s almost Halloween, I thought the Irish might surprise us and finally put the dagger in the heart of an unranked team. Ya know, put more points on the board to put the game out of reach, when we have every opportunity to do so! But not so fast, we allowed yet another foe to climb back into the game when it should have been over. Go back to tackling 101, d looked awful. Do we really have to make every game a nail biter? Very happy with another win, but very frustrated to see us let off the gas in too many games!
Dennis says:
Thank you for noting William’s outstanding play and the comparison to Penick’s 1973 run.
Mark says:
Last night’s 91 yarder by Kyren reminded me more of Reggie Brooks’ 20 yard TD run versus Michigan when six tacklers had shots at him and he ended up unconscious from the last hit as he fell into the end zone. Penick, Adams and Dexter all had great runs which were also blocked to perfection. Kyren (and Reggie) did most of the work themselves. Kyren definitely is in the pantheon of great ND backs.
PC says:
Totally agree on your final point that the defense has gotten worse. Hamilton surely would’ve helped but the LBs were absolutely awful and the Bertrand Roughing the passer was such a bonehead play. Gave NC life and they shortly capitalized with a TD.
Offense was solid and the team does keep winning. 11-1 is very possible and with some November chaos, we could see our Irish on the edge of a playoff berth.
Irish in the South says:
Happy for the win. Not happy to see our defense playing so poorly, giving up over 500 yards, missing tackles, allowing the QB to roam freely. This doesn’t bode well against the remaining teams on our schedule.
Fred A Karam Jr says:
Good job on the win, terrible job by the defense, the tackling was terrible, when you are inside the five on two occasions, you need touchdowns. I like Coan running for a touchdown, would love to see him run more. Please, please stop playing Navy, the BS cut blocks they are allowed to use is bad for college football. I know this is tradition, but it’s time to get away from this tradition, it can’t help this team only hurt it. We better figure out a better defensive scheme because Virginia is a North Carolina team with a dangerous quarterback., and they are at home.
TavianCainBass says:
ND will never stop playing Navy. Move on.
Bocceman2 says:
it is more than tradition to play Navy it is a promise that was made when the Department of Navy used ND as a training site for officers that kept the doors open during WWII. A true fan knows that.. Won’t happen so move on.
The Obvious says:
Navy will give it their all, as always. And if the ball bounces their way …
Irish in the South says:
If it wasn’t for the US Navy, ND would have closed during WWII. We will never stop playing Navy. Forget the “cut blocks”, the pageantry and patriotism that Navy brings to this rivalry surpasses anything that any other rivalry can bring.
Bob Birge says:
Agree one thousand percent and I expect the Mids, despite their 2-6 record, to play hard.
Mike says:
I wouldn’t say surpasses but it’s an honorable, colorful, and historical rivalry. Old timer here thinks the rivalries with USC, Michigan State, and Purdue are pretty wonderful, too, even if they are variously in abeyance.
Brian Mullen says:
This defensive under Freeman is terrible. He makes no adjustments at halftime and puts his players in prevent defense mode and pays the price for it. As much as ND forked out for this guy he has not impressed me at all!
Irish in the South says:
I think we had to play prevent D against Sam Howell who some say is the best long pass QB in college football. By the way, UNC only completed one long bomb to No. 15. Granted, without Hamilton in there, the shorter passes were effective.
Louis Ciferno says:
What I saw last night, it’s the first time all season that the offensive line looked like a Notre Dame offensive line. The pass protection was the best all year and the run blocking was very good. They actually moved the defense back off the line of scrimmage. So kudos to the offensive line.
Defense was terrible. They need 2 weeks of practice just to learn how to tackle. It’s the poorest tackling defense Notre Dame has had in years. It’s also the slowest when comes to the linebackers and secondary. One thing I noticed is almost every defensive player wants to go above the waste to tackle and know one goes waist down. Bad coaching and slow defensive speed.
Mike Hoots says:
Kyle always tackles below the waist but he seems to be the only one. D is getting sloppy as the season progresses and there appears to be no accountability from captains or coaches.
Irish in the South says:
Agree. This high tackling and not wrapping up by the defense seems to be something that can and should be corrected going forward. Let’s see what happens.
Marty says:
Your final paragraph summation is spot on. For me, the linebacker play was the most glaring troublespot. Diggs is the short yardage smash up the middle go to guy, rather than Kyren.
GOND88 says:
This is the most pitiful defensive performance since the Van Gorder era or 2017 against Wake Forest under Elko. N. Carolina moved the ball almost at will most of the night and kept racking up big chunk plays. The confusion, lack of adjustments and poor tackling brings us back to the Van Gorder era. I lost track of how many times ND defenders bounced off of Howell thus allowing him to scramble or compete a pass.
Clark Lea made effective adjustments and shut down Sam Howell in the second half of last year’s contest at Chapel Hill. It’s a good thing NC’s defense is subpar or this game would have turned out differently.
On the bright side the offensive line is playing better and the offense is improving but NC’s defense gives up lots of yards and points so ND should have put up pretty impressive numbers such as they did.
Irish Rifle says:
Happy to get the win, but the game was extremely frustrating nonetheless. UNC was gifted two TDs – one by the officials on the missed call on the illegal block which sprung Downs for a long gain and the other courtesy of Bertrand, for a stupid roughing the passer penalty, which was also a momentum changer just when it appeared that the Irish were about to blow UNC out of the Stadium. Speaking of the linebackers, I have come to the conclusion that the current group is just not very good. Injuries have certainly contributed to that situation. The tackling overall by the defense was terrible. There was one play in the second half which could be used as a highlight reel for poor tackling where two of the linebackers whiffed completely and there were several other missed tackles. Downright embarrassing. The defense also made Howell look like the second coming of Bo Jackson. Can’t wait until the 2022 linebacker class arrives, which will be the best in many decades. Those two missed TD opportunities inside the 5-yard line were the result of terrible play-calling by Rees. The Williams TD run was one of the best I have ever seen from an ND back. That guy is simply awesome. Excellent passing by Coan, except for one poor pass to Mayer in the 4th quarter. Styles is going to be a great player and terrific that he is getting meaningful snaps. Hope we are able to sign his brother Sonny.
Marty says:
Watched Penn State line up in a tee formation from the OSU 2 yard line. The running back virtually walked into the end zone. Creativity is non existent for Rees. From inside the 5 with Coan at QB and one running back doesn’t take a genius to figure the play call.
Flirish says:
Thanks for your analysis. It seems like there’s a lot of criticism of the defense and that is certainly warranted.
However T Reis deserves a ton of criticism as well. The red zone offense is inconsistent and disjointed. Settling for field goals three times kept the game close as opposed to having the game be a blowout. When we get inside the 20 it’s really a crapshoot. Additionally, all great comments made about the improvement in the running game may be partially true but the reality is the running game clicked because one running back is doing everything on his own including breaking every tackle he can. That long run has nothing to do with the offense of line. The offense of line was pathetic on that play. It actually was going to be a two or 3 yard loss until nothing but individual effort change that. Many of Williams runs last night or 100% on his own. Almost hit in the backfield and then twisting out of trouble for five or 6 yards is how he earns his living. And yes we did have a good part return but we set them up for an easy touchdown by allowing a bouncing ball in the end zone to be run out to the 45 yard line. Just inconsistent play allows us to let other teams stay in the game. This game should’ve been a blowout. We will take the win but it didn’t have to be this tough. One other quick note, as far as great rhymes, Williams from last year against Clemson Should not be overlooked nor the efforts of Dexter Williams and Josh Adams with their long runs from scrimmage in big games. You don’t have to go that far retro to find some really phenomenal great Notre Dame runs in big games
jbarrett says:
Delighted for the win and a 7-1 record!! What a display by Williams and the ND offense!! Special teams played well going 3 for 3 on field goals and a big punt return for 47 yards! Defense will get things fixed! However, I would not play Hamilton against Navy since they do a lot of cut blocking. Get him ready for Virginia!!
Gooooo Irish sink Navy!!!!!
irishhawk50 says:
I hate to sound like a broken record but I have been posting all season about the defensive problems and it seems everybody here agrees. Remember preseason all the hype about the defense being the strong point of this team? ND offense shouldn’t need 30 or 40 points to win every game. UNC is a middle of the road team with a good quarterback. I would hate to see ND’s defense against a team like Georgia,speaking of Halloween nightmares!
Wfsindc says:
Excellent summary of the game, as usual. I would add the Howell is very tough to bring down, even with Jordan Bothelo hanging on him. The tackling must improve but Howell is BBC a special case.
John Vannie says:
ND’s defenders have poor tackling technique. They stay too high and do not wrap up. Howell is not anything special as a runner, but the Irish made him look like it.
VegasPoker74 says:
ND rushers were too aggressive and out of their lanes. All Howell had to do was make a passing motion and they would leap up to block it giving Howell all the leverage he needed to scramble for one gain after another. Expect to see more of this from future opponents with running QBs.
Kevin Byrnes says:
Well said. I was in the soph section for Penick’s run in ’73 and in the west end of section 136 last night, so I got to see Penick coming and Williams going.
Unfortunately, along with many fine offensive plays by ND, I will have a hard time putting out of my mind plays like a UNC receiver so wide open for a TD that it looked like they were out in a back yard just chucking the ball around; and the 31-yard run by Howell where it seemed like no defender could take a proper angle.
Richard J Derr says:
Eric