I actually prefer the college rules
by jt (2019-01-21 00:57:41)

In reply to: AP sports writer: "By my count, since NFL changed OT rules  posted by G.K.Chesterton


but I would start with the ball on the 50.


I am not a fan of either
by pmoose  (2019-01-23 14:37:37)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

I would have changed the NFL rule to make sure that each team has at least 1 possession in OT, regardless of whether the first team with the ball gets a TD on that possession. After that 1st possession, if the score is still tied, sudden death from there.

It just seems arbitrary and taking out a phase of the game (kickoff special teams) by starting the ball at some location on the field.


Why not the offensive team's 25, just like a touchback on
by SUJB9  (2019-01-21 14:10:25)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

a kickoff? Seems less arbitrary than the 50 and allows play to more accurately reflect a normal game (less reliance on kickers).


The 17 would actually be a good solution.
by tdiddy07  (2019-01-22 12:25:31)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

That's the break-even point where each team is just as likely to score next.


I favor this. *
by Father Nieuwland  (2019-01-21 16:02:02)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post


Play a quarter (not sudden death) and then call it a tie *
by DakotaDomer  (2019-01-21 13:54:29)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post


Need to have a winner in the playoffs
by jbrown_9999  (2019-01-21 23:42:49)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

so ties are not an option


Replay the game!
by DakotaDomer  (2019-01-22 10:39:06)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

(Kidding, kidding, I didn’t get that much out of Irish sport)


Or then let it go to Sudden Death after the extra Quarter. *
by 3rdSt  (2019-01-21 14:17:44)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post


College 54.9% vs NFL 54%
by jbrown_9999  (2019-01-21 11:41:09)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

Based on numbers, NFL OT games were won by team receiving opening kickoff in OT 54.0% of the time vs. college teams playing defense first in OT winning 54.9% of the time.

So while there is not really much difference in the numbers, the new NFL OT rules actually are closer to having 50/50 results than the current college rules.


This may be the result of college FG kickers vs NFL kickers. *
by frosh  (2019-01-21 22:10:17)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post


Or the team going second on offense knowing exactly what
by jbrown_9999  (2019-01-21 23:36:24)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

they need be it a FG to win, TD to tie, etc.


I do too
by irishrock  (2019-01-21 09:57:13)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

The loser cannot have a legitimate gripe


Agree completely. It's much more objective and fair.
by Duke Camaro  (2019-01-21 09:44:00)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

If the college OT rules (starting at the 50) weren't an option, then they should just play an extra quarter.


5 years ago I would have disagreed. But I've come
by 84david  (2019-01-21 08:58:47)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

around 180 and like college OT better as well.