Rugby League is of course far different than Rugby Union or
by Dickiebeev (2019-05-26 20:52:17)

In reply to: Data on concussions in rugby and the NFL  posted by plaid_pants


Rugby Sevens. The key difference being that League emphasizes head-on tackling at high speed. Rugby League is a fairly niche sport, so I wouldn’t misconstrue its statistics as being in any way representative of the sport.


The point was not to judge rugby, per se
by JHND  (2019-06-03 12:04:16)     cannot delete  |  Edit  |  Return to Board  |  Ignore Poster   |   Highlight Poster  |   Reply to Post

It was to judge whether concussions would be reduced if football players in the US were to no longer wear helmets, as some have suggested. Rugby League is probably the branch of rugby closest in style of play to American Football, so the comparison is reasonable.

The poster's point was ostensibly to say that reducing the rate of concussions from 0.64 to 0.48 per game would be more or less immaterial. However, that is a 25% reduction. That said, I tend to agree that equipment improvements, rule changes and better enforcement are a better approach to reducing concussions from playing football than removing helmets.