No argument at all.
by potatohouse (2022-11-30 12:25:47)
Edited on 2022-11-30 12:34:28

In reply to: Stetson yes, McCarron no.  posted by rockmcd

Stetson was the clean comparison I wanted to highlight.

With McCarron, very much agree that they had vastly different recruiting profiles. I only included him for the parallel that despite Book's beginnings, his body of work at ND indicated to me that he could have very likely served as AJ McCarron during Alabama's running offense days. And both college careers resulted in mid/late draft profiles, although as it stands, McCarron looks like he will have ended up with the more (relatively) meaningful pro career.