Audric Estime capped his stellar collegiate career with a dominant performance as Notre Dame shook off its early miscues to crush Stanford by 56-23 on Saturday. Estime scored four touchdowns and ran for 238 of the 381 rushing yards the Irish hung on the physically overmatched Cardinal. Notre Dame actually trailed by 16-14 after 20 minutes of play due to three turnovers and inspired play by the hosts. Then the roof simply caved in on them.
Stanford took a quick 3-0 lead by taking the opening kickoff and reaching the red zone. Backup quarterback Justin Lamson broke through a scrum and ran for 49 yards to set up a Josh Karty field goal. The Irish attempted to respond but Sam Hartman was stripped of the ball at the end of a 25-yard run. Later, Notre Dame got the ball back and let Estime do what he does best. His 39-yard scoring run gave the visitors a 7-3 edge.
On the next series, Cardinal starter Ashton Daniels scrambled to his right before finding EJ Smith for a 53-yard gain. The Irish defense stiffened thanks to strong pass coverage by linebacker Jack Kiser, and Karty came on to make it 7-6.
Notre Dame continued its error-prone ways on the ensuing kickoff. Jadarian Price had a nice return going until he lost the ball at the Irish 30. Stanford needed only two plays to retake the lead as Tiger Bachmeier took a reverse toss and ran by a group of overpursuing Irish defenders for a 14-yard score.
Hartman seemed to settle down as the game moved into the second period. He hit Chris Tyree for a first down, watched as Estime ran downhill for large chunks of real estate, and then connected with Jaden Greathouse in the end zone for a 14-13 Irish advantage.
A sack of Daniels by JD Bertrand seemed to signal that Stanford’s fun was about to end. Hartman could not capitalize, though. Instead, he threw a poor pass off his back foot that was picked off by the Cardinal. Notre Dame’s defense found its footing and forced a fourth down, but Karty nailed a 56-yard field goal to give his team its last lead of the night.
The Irish redialed 1-800-Estime to restore order, and his 25-yard scoring run reclaimed the lead by 21-16. Stanford kept fighting, however, and two major penalties by the Irish defense on third down plays allowed the Cardinal to move into scoring territory. Notre Dame finally recorded a turnover of its own as Kiser ended the threat with an interception of Daniels.
As the final seconds of the half ticked down, the Irish rumbled into the red zone. Gi’Bran Payne finished the drive from three yards out with 19 seconds remaining to give Notre Dame a 28-16 cushion.
The visitors dominated the third quarter as Estime bulldozed the Cards for two more touchdowns and Hartman hit Jordan Faison with a 48-yard strike on play-action to blow the game open. Notre Dame led 49-16 as the game mercifully moved into the fourth quarter.
In the mean time, Stanford’s offense was reduced to desperate attempts to convert on fourth down. After failing to do so on consecutive possessions, the Cardinal elected to bring out Karty to attempt a field goal from 60 yards. Unsurprisingly, the Irish blocked the kick. Javontae Jean-Baptiste scooped up the ball near the sideline and managed to stay in bounds as he toe-danced 60 yards to his first career touchdown.
Coach Marcus Freeman cleared the bench with a 56-16 lead and nearly 13 minutes remaining. Stanford added a touchdown against the Irish reserves to account for the final margin of 56-23 but there were precious few Cardinal fans left to cheer.
Notre Dame finished the regular season at 9-3 and must now wait until after the conference championship games next weekend before the postseason bowl picture is clarified. Estime certainly has nothing left to prove and will likely elect to sit it out. We’ll watch him next fall on Sunday afternoons.
Let’s review the answers to our pregame questions:
- Can Stanford’s patchwork offensive line stand up to the Irish defensive front? The Polish Army performed better against Hitler’s Panzers in 1939.
- Will Notre Dame’s cornerbacks be able to handle Ayomanor and Bachmeier? Ayomanor had several short receptions but he could not find the end zone. Bachmeier didn’t catch a pass, but scored on a reverse when Ben Morrison ran right past him in pursuit of a well-executed fake. Smith was actually the most productive receiver for the Cards. He turned several catches in the flat into longer gains.
- Which team will score touchdowns inside the red zone? The Irish limited the early damage caused by turnovers when they were able to force several field goal attempts by Karty. Meanwhile, Notre Dame scored touchdowns in each of its four red zone appearances.
- Will Irish OL Craig and Schrauth continue to get the job done up front? Both played very well. Craig was hurt for a spell but returned to the game with no apparent ill-effects.
- Can Notre Dame rush for over 200 yards while holding the Cardinal under 100? It was 381-31, so I guess you can say they exceeded my expectations.
- Which young Irish reserves will make a case for playing time next season? The fourth quarter was hard to watch but linebackers Jaylen Sneed and Drayk Bowen looked good on defense. On offense, Craig, Schrauth and Faison stood out.
- Can Notre Dame’s special teams continue to have a positive impact? It didn’t look good when Price fumbled away a kickoff, but Jean-Baptiste lit up social media with his crowd-pleasing touchdown return.
- Will Ohio State put Michigan out of everyone’s misery? Oof. Georgia looks like our last hope. The Buckeye’s are the only common opponent of Notre Dame and the Wolverines this season. Michigan caught an interception on Ohio State’s final drive, while the Irish dropped one. That pretty much sums up the season, doesn’t it?
Tell John what you think in the Comments section below.
South Cook Irish says:
Hard to fathom that Estime was left off the list of 10 semifinalists for the Doak Walker Award.
mike says:
Not so hard to fathom, given how little he was used in critical losses to Louisville and Clemson.
Richard P. Conklin says:
Your last bullet really hit home on the differing outcomes against OSU from ND and Michigan boiling down to one play. Ouch.
Bill Haines says:
John, As always, thanks for being Notre Dame’s most articulate, rational source. Respectfully, Bill Haines.
goirish1988 says:
While I no longer have any emotions tied up in this season, the one remaining development that could feel like a dagger in my heart is a loss to Brian Kelly in a bowl game. Please no.
mike says:
Seems highly unlikely that the presumptive HEISMAN winning QB and what many feel might be an even better WR than Harrison of tOSU, will play in a meaningless bowl game for LSU. That would even the odds dramatically, assuming most/all of ND’s first team plays, which admittedly is a stretch. Still, one final chance for Hartman to put improved play on tape against a quality opponent, and for ND to show actual season record improvement over the 2022 season, would possible be convincing points for them to play.
Drasail2 says:
JV,
Just a disappointing year. As things have played out, a one loss ND would not have reached the top four. The Irish just dropped one indeed.
Thank you for the excellent coverage this season despite your loss.
Go Irish!
IndyIrish says:
Thanks for all your hard work and insights, John. I enjoyed reading your analysis of this season far more than I liked watching it. I hope the Irish are committed to building an offense around Angeli rather than going to the portal again, as it would be amazing to see sustained excellence and continuity with the program. The Cubs won a championship in my lifetime, so surely the Irish could win another title with the right offensive coordinator. Until then, T. Rice will run the option with Reggie Brooks in my dreams. Have a great Christmas!
Kevin McNamara says:
Agreed.
One Historian says:
Indy;
Word is that ND is going after Miami QB Tyler Van Dyke, and I think this is a big mistake. MF is reputed to want 4 QBs on the roster and if Van Dyke comes to ND we’ll probably lose AT LEAST ONE of the 2 we have now, and maybe even Carr. If Van Dyke does come to ND it would be a reasonable assumption that he has been told that he’ll get preferential treatment in re starting, but Angeli has looked good in his brief times on the field and he deserves a real chance.
I’ve said numerous times that I think the transfer portal is a bad idea, but that’s the way things are now,
John Vannie says:
I’ve been hearing a lot of noise about Riley Leonard of Duke. This is the first I’ve heard about Van Dyke.
Bengal Bouts Champ says:
I like Marcus Freeman, but I just don’t think he’s ready for Prime Time/Game Time coaching at this time, maybe later. This team had a chance to go undefeated, but for the coaching….
Luperad says:
Luperad (class of 1972)
There are few things in life that I anticipate more than your prediction/summary articles on ND football. I think you should have a statue erected on campus (next to one for Tony Roberts!)
Excluding the players and great coaches i.e Lou and Ara, you two should be forever remembered as the torch bearers for ND fandom.
Thank you from the bottom of my heart!
#♥️🍀50 says:
🍀 should have been 11-1 this year. Although, I didn’t expect the 🍀 to make the playoffs (for obvious reasons). I did expect the 🍀to make a January 1st Day Bowl game. With the coaching and lack of team focus debacles we are now playing in some crappy bowl with the other minions. I didn’t think it could have gotten worse by playing in the World Campers Bowl but a possibility of playing in the Pop Tart Bowl Is out right EMBARRASSMENT for THIS program!!!! If we do play in a bowl like that, then my how have the 🍀have fallen. I guess mediocracy is now the norm🤦🤷.
Mike151 says:
I wish that Coach Freeman gave Eatime a chance to break the single game rushing record. He only needed 25 more yards, he could have picked them up in 3 carries.
Jeff says:
I wish Coach Freeman would have given Estime the ball three more times when it was first-and-10 at the ND 35 with less than three minutes to go against Ohio State! May not have gotten a first down, but the Buckeyes would have had to burn all of their timeouts and would have gotten the ball back with less than a minute on the clock. Wasted chances this season.
Steve says:
Absolutely agree. That was a huge coaching blunder. And while we’re at it, I wish Coach Freeman would have played the last two downs v. Ohio St. with 11 players on defense.
Mike says:
Maybe the assistant coach and the captain on the field should get the lion’s share of the blame for that. Sometimes “The buck stops . . .” blaming is just too pat.
mike says:
ABSOLUTELY, and the choices they made instead left far too much time; but then the killer snafus were the “prevent the win” 3-man rush on the 3rd and 17-to-go play (right after a 4-man rush led to a 7-10 yard losing sack for tOSU), compounded by 10 men on the field for the last two plays at the 2 yard line. Terrible coaching, seen later in the season in different form with the horrible O-line play against Louisville and Clemson, leaving Hartman zero time in a clean pocket to do anything.
irishhawk50 says:
John,
I agree with all of the praise you receive from bloggers. You are the go to person for me for all things Notre Dame football. I have thoroughly appreciated your site for many year. Thank you.
On the football side of the year, things sort of panned out as expected. The Irish lost the big games and won the games against the lesser foes. I agree with the poster who thought a better coaching staff had a chance to win out.
Hopefully, the Irish will not play LSU in a bowl game as that would probably lead to a defeat and a bitter taste in the mouth into the coming year,
David says:
Thank You John.
Joe says:
This was the best of all of the excellent post-game columns you provide to us die-hards. I loved the “1 800 Estime” line. John, I am 84 years old. Will I see another ND football national championship before the last quarter time clock expires?
Thanks
John Vannie says:
I hope you make it to the next championship, Joe. Remember to look both ways before you cross the street, don’t take a cruise with Carnival, sell your motorcycle, no skydiving, and whatever you do, stay out of the hospital.
Mike says:
And persuade Arch Manning to transfer to Notre Dame. He went to a Catholic high school, after all. Unless Angeli is better. Maybe he is. The announcers on the Catholic Channel surely thought highly of him a few games ago.
GOND88 says:
Good win against an undermanned Stanford team but in my view 2023 wasn’t really a success. ND went 1-2 against tOSU, USC and Clemson. I didn’t expect 12-0 but 10-2 and 2-1 against those teams would have signaled an upward trajectory. But 9-3 and 1-2 against the aforementioned teams is just kind of meh. I guess this is what happens when the HC and OC are learning on the job.
Best of luck to all the Irish players who are declaring for the draft or who may opt to transfer. Also thanks for the memories.
James Kress says:
Thanks John. I enjoyed your insightful commentary. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.
Will says:
John, I couldn’t stay away for long. My son is a Stanford grad and now that I’ve retired to the East Bay, it’s been our annual tradition to go to the ND/Stanford game when it is in Palo Alto. When Harbaugh and Shaw were coaching this was an excellent series, better than the ND/USC series during that time period. But yesterday I saw the worst Stanford team possibly in their history. They had two players who could play for ND – the kicker Karty and the wide-out Ayomano. Other than that forget it…they are small and slow and not particularly skilled at basic football techniques. Troy Thompson, who did great work at Sac State, has an immense re-building project in front of him which is made more difficult because of several factors: 1) fan support is pathetic and yesterday was a good example as the ND contingent was bigger and noisier than the home team crowd, 2) the move to the ACC cannot be attractive to west coast athletes, 3) their facilities are subpar with a rinky dink new stadium with a terrible grass field, and 4) the Stanford Admin does not seem to want to engage with the new NIL and portal realities. As far as ND was concerned there were things I liked: 1) Freeman seems to be shedding his nice guy demeanor as he really chewed out some assistants and players very publicly, 2) the young receivers are fast, run disciplined routes, and block very well, 3) the O Line was dominant and the freshman tight end, Flanagan, is an excellent blocker. On the negative side our quarterback play was not good. Hartman did not look particularly focused ,and Angeli threw a really, really terrible pick. After the interception, Parker did not call any more pass plays for Angeli which seems to indicate a lack of confidence in him. This means Freeman will be going with another portal qb for 2024. My question for you, John, is who do you think they will target in the portal?
John Vannie says:
Most players have to wait until December 4 to enter the portal, so it’s a little premature to guess whom ND may be targeting. A couple of names to watch are Riley Leonard (Duke), Michael Pratt (Tulane) and Tyler Shough (Texas Tech). Only Shough has declared to date. Will Rogers from Mississippi State is rumored to be headed to Kentucky.
Will says:
John, Will Howard just announced he’s entering the portal. Thoughts?
John Vannie says:
Certainly a possibility but I’m not sure who the coaches have in mind yet or if they’ve even established a pecking order to pursue.
Will says:
Xmas wish: Will Howard signs with Irish and brings Collin Klein, his offensive coordinator, with him!!!
Mike says:
The decision about Stanford’s football stadium was realistic based on fan support for college football in the S F Bay Area. The 50,000 capacity insures good viewing throughout. The old stadium insured mostly bad viewing throughout with the Olympics-standard track around it. The new one got built in less than a year from the final game in the old stadium, saying something great about Stanford’s ability to get things done. Fan interest doesn’t warrant a football palace with all the bells and whistles like the Dallas Cowboys or the Notre Dame Fighting Irish have. It was no surprise to anyone football enthusiast who lives in the Bay Area that the Notre Dame fans at Saturday’s game fare exceeded the home fans. Troy Taylor, by the way.
Manager47 says:
John – thanks a million for the excellent coverage in 2023. Going forward i have to wonder if the “higher ups” are seriously committed to winninng. It would appear that all is good having gone 9-3 ! Let’s just keep losing to inferior teams and beat up on the bottom feeders. If what you and others are saying another QB by way of the transfer portal is in the works for 2024. A huge mistake as how much of a difference did Hartman make especially in the games that were lost? ND should develop their own recruits – open up the offense with a better offensive scheme and build on the offensive and defensive guys up front. Once again it needs to be said ND isn’t a place to learn on the job – results matter – expectations this year not met.
Domer262 says:
John,
Thank you for your excellent analysis of ND football week in and week out. I look forward to your columns and can’t believe another regular season is in the books. Do you think the people in charge of the bowls will try to create a Brian Kelly vs. Marcus Freeman story line for ratings? If that match up were to come to fruition, what is your take on it especially with so many on both teams probably opting out because it is a second tier bowl?
It would be a dagger to the heart if BK beat ND in the bowl game and it would be BLISS if ND beat BK and LSU. Thank you again for your great coverage of ND football. God bless you and Merry Christmas and Happy New Year. GO IRISH!
John Vannie says:
I believe ESPN will throw its weight behind a matchup between LSU and ND. Without knowing which players on either side will opt out, it’s hard to predict the outcome. The quarterbacks in particular will sway the odds significantly depending on whether or not they play.
joe says:
Hello John,
Hope you had a nice and relaxing Thanksgiving! Great write-up as usual! Really happy for the win and a chance to get to 10 wins this season!! It was awesome to see the running game kicked into a high gear!!
John, who do you feel will opt out of the Bowl game and who would you like to see ND play?
Thanks!!
John Vannie says:
Thanks, Joe. I would like to see ND play a team that would represent a real accomplishment if we beat them. We’ve had a few easy matchups in the recent past that were designed to get ND an extra win. LSU might be the choice of ESPN but any Top 25 team will be fine with me.
Jake in Cali says:
JVAN,
THANK YOU for another great year of your weekly column..
God bless! Merry Christmas..
And I will look forward to your ND vs LSU write up late next month….I’m quite sure it will happen..
Chrisnd1993 says:
A semi-disappointing season that looked like (on paper) it should have been an 11-1 campaign. But alas, a heart-breaker in late September set the stage for what would eventually become a 9-3 “Bucket of Sadness”. At least we beat all (but one) of the teams were were supposed to beat by significant margins (other than the Duke squeaker, but we won’t talk about that…)
However, it was nice to see Estime end on a very, very positive note, and I look forward to seeing him run roughshod over the NFL linebackers on Sundays. I am also hoping that perhaps, maybe, if we are lucky, the Cleveland Browns find someway to trade up to get Alt.. It’s sad that both Estime and Alt are most likely going to sit out the bowl game, because I would really like to see them in Fightin’ Irish Blue and Gold one more time.
Thanks for your great write-ups, both pre and post game. The “Questions” are always the best, and I look forward to your pre-bowl write up next month.
Go Irish!
Kevin says:
Regarding your last question of the game: Watching the end of the OSU-Michigan game I could not help but shake my head when I saw the Michigan rush force the OSU interception vs ND rushing three and giving OSU all day to throw. When will DC’s learn?
chrisnd1993 says:
Apparently, they never will. Auburn rushed three on Saturday, and we all see how that ended as well. 4th and Goal from the 32 and you lose – that’s just not a good look for a DC that called that play.
Wasn’t it Holtz that said “The only thing the prevent defense does is prevent you from winning.”
joe says:
John,
I am so frustrated with all these ND players transferring!! Especially the WR’s! Do you think it was the firing of the WR’s coach that led to the receivers leaving the program and why do you think the other players are leaving! NIL? Playing time? Avoiding the tough academics? Want to be closer to home?………Thanks John!
John Vannie says:
The WR coach was a big part of the problem. The kids who just left had decided to do so a while ago. Freeman was not fully aware of the depth of the player discontent. There’s no way to put a positive spin on this situation.
Joe says:
Thanks for the response John! I appreciate it. Go Irish beat Beavers!!!!