Notre Dame’s defense dominated the line of scrimmage and took away Purdue’s best weapons on the way to a 27-13 home victory on Saturday. Kyren Williams scored early on a 39-yard reception and late on a gritty 51-yard run to ice the game. Avery Davis chipped in with a 66-yard scoring reception. He finished with five catches on the day to lead the team. Quarterback Jack Coan was somewhat inconsistent from the pocket. He and the Irish missed several big play opportunities, including a drop in the end zone by a wide open Braden Lenzy. Coan finished 15 of 30 for 223 yards.
The Irish started slowly with a negative yardage opening series before Purdue scored on a field goal by Mitchell Fineran for a 3-0 lead. The game turned into a defensive battle with the hosts in poor field position. Kyle Hamilton provided the spark Notre Dame needed late in the first quarter when he stuff the Boilermakers on a fourth down run. The Irish faced a fourth down of their own moments later. Coan drilled a short slant over the middle to Williams, who blew past the Purdue secondary for a 7-3 lead.
Consecutive pass interference penalties fueled Notre Dame on its next possession, resulting in a short field goal by Jonathan Doerer for a 10-3 advantage. The senior kicker missed a chance to extend the lead moments later with an ugly miss from 45 yards. As the defense continued to force punts from the Boilers, Coan tried and failed once again to get the offense to click. Three straight poor throws to open receivers ended the final Irish drive of the half.
Purdue came out of the locker room with renewed energy. Their opening drive stalled in the red zone, but another Fineran field goal cut the deficit to 10-6. Notre Dame quickly responded with Coan’s best pass of the day, a long strike that Davis caught in stride for a touchdown. The Irish now led by 17-6 with ten minutes remaining in the third quarter.
Purdue’s attack got the Boilers offense going on the next series. King Doerue ripped off a 31-yard run before quarterback Jack Plummer hit David Bell inside the Irish five yard line. Plummer found Milton Wright a few plays later in the corner of the end zone for a score. The Boilers were well within striking distance as Notre Dame’s lead shrunk to 17-13.
The game remained tight into the final period before a nice catch by Davis set up a another field goal by Doerer to make it 20-13. The Irish defense regained its footing and upped the pressure on a beleaguered Plummer. When Hamilton down an Irish punt at the Purdue one yard line, Coach Jeff Brohm responded by inserting backup signal-caller Aidan O’Connell into the game.
Meanwhile, Coan missed a chance to ice the game when Lenzy appeared to lose a perfect pass in the sun as it fell into and out of his hands. When the defense got the ball back, Notre Dame turned to Williams and he delivered. After returning a punt to his own 49 yard line, he broke numerous tackles on the next play from scrimmage for a 51-yard score.
Trailing 27-13, O’Connell tried to rally the visitors. He guided them downfield but lost Bell on a clean, hard hit by Hamilton in the process. Bell was carted off the field. Still O’Connell kept the Boilers moving to the red zone until disaster struck. A would-be touchdown pass bounced off the hands of tight end Payne Durham and into Hamilton’s in the end zone. The Irish managed to cover the last 2:32 after that play essentially ended Purdue’s hopes.
It was hardly an artistic win, however. The improvement on defense continues and provides hope that the offense will break out sooner rather than later. Marcus Freeman’s crew held the Boilers to 57 rushing yards, recorded three sacks, eight quarterback hurries and a pair of interceptions. On the other side of the ball, Notre Dame did not turn the ball over and finished with 120 yards on the ground. I asked for 125 in my pregame article, but it was close enough.
Despite the win, it’s still fair to criticize the Irish offensive line. They turned in another poor performance with four sacks and seven tackles for loss allowed. A couple of them were little better than turnstiles in pass protection as Coan felt heat all afternoon. The rushing yards by Williams and Chris Tyree were mostly of their own making, although there was good effort downfield on the scoring run by Williams.
Let’s take a look at the answers to the pregame questions. for further analysis:
Will the Irish pass rush (ten sacks in two games) continue to dominate? Absolutely. This gave the offense time to find the few plays it needed to win.
Can Notre Dame find an effective offensive line combination? No, but the left to right lineup of Baker, Correll, Patterson, Madden and Lugg may be the best we’re going to see this year. I know, it’s a very scary thought and we’re still several weeks away from Halloween.
Who will win the marquee matchup between Austin and Trice? Trice didn’t play due to injury, but backup Jamari Brown shut down Austin, who had an uncharacteristically poor performance.
Will special teams have an impact on the outcome? Yes, but where do I start? The Irish had two punt returns, but one was called back on a penalty. Doerer made two short field goals but missed a longer one by about 20 miles. Hamilton downed a Jay Bramblett punt on the Purdue one yard line, but Bramblett punted poorly in the early going.
Purdue was nearly as inconsistent. They caught another punt inside their own five instead of letting it go into the end zone. The Boilers used two punters because starter Jack Ansell lost the job midway through the game.
Which Irish quarterback will have the most success? Coan had more positive plays because Tyler Buchner did not see much action. The freshman did contribute a 20-yard run in the second quarter, but Coan replaced him in almost every passing situation.
Will Notre Dame’s consecutive non-sellout streak continue? The stands were mostly full, but many of them fell asleep in the boring, sloppy first half.
How many times will Drew Brees slip and refer to Purdue as “We”? Have you canceled your Peacock subscription yet? Once that I recall, at the outset of the third quarter. Brees noticed the Irish cornerbacks were playing soft coverage and said, “We’ll take that all day” when the Boilers completed a couple of consecutive passes.
The game felt like a good win for the defense and a disappointment for the offense in that at least two more touchdowns should have been scored. It was good to see the excellent performances by Davis. Williams and Hamilton have become constants, while the rest of the defense played hard. Myron Tagovailoa-Amosa and NaNa Osafo-Mensah had highlight moments to snuff out Purdue drives. Michael Mayer was clocked early after reaching for an errant Coan pass and was not a factor the rest of the way. The Boilers went after Irish cornerback Cam Hart all day, but Hart battled back after a couple of ugly pass interference penalties.
Time has run out on the exhibition portion of the season as prime time kicks in next week. The next five opponents have bye weeks before playing the Irish and could win any or all of those games unless the offensive line can right the ship. Barring that, Coan cannot be a consistent passer, Williams and Tyree will continue to take a pounding and Buchner will not be able to work any miracles. That will put too much pressure on a very good defense to be perfect.
Marty says:
Overall, I thought it was a better performance. Coan missed some big play passes which would have put the game out of reach. I still don’t get why we don’t defer the kickoff, when our defense is unquestionably better and more consistent than the offense.
Mike says:
Couldn’t agree more on Kelly taking the ball first every game, dumb. We either come out, march down the field, score quickly (but often lose that momentum) or come out and lay an egg, go 3 and out. Always comes back to haunt us starting the 2nd half. Lou always went on defense first. Our D is clearly playing better than the offense currently, no reason to take ball first unless we have to!!
irishhawk50 says:
There was some improvement but still a long way to go if the Irish are going to get through the rough part of the schedule ahead. Defense looked better especially tackling. Coan is a passable (no pun) but really not a game breaker. I suspect most of the upcoming games will be nail biters, but the team plays with grit,
The Obvious says:
What? No mention of Brian Kelly’s historic victory? Like him or not.
John Vannie says:
Notre Dame vacated 21 of those wins. They don’t belong in any official record.
jbarrett says:
The NCAA vacated 21 of those wins, not Notre Dame!! John, it’s so obvious that you do not like Coach Kelly and therefore you can’t be objective enough that he has won 105 games on the field!! Who gives a crap about what the NCAA thinks. I know deep down you feel it was wrong for the NCAA to do that to ND and the fact that other teams have done wrong and they get a slap on the wrist!
In Notre Dame’s media guide they have Coach Kelly down for 104 wins, now it’s 105 after today’s win over Purdue. John you have to admit that Coach Kelly deserves credit for accomplishing 105 victories!!
Please don’t allow your dislike of Coach Kelly to cloud your objectivity. Go Irish beat Badgers!!!!!!
John Vannie says:
Joe, Notre Dame turned itself in to the NCAA. The Administration initially stated they would accept any punishment levied by the NCAA. Later, they decided they didn’t like the punishment, but they cannot choose to ignore it.
Regarding Coach Kelly, I can think of only two wins in his career at Notre Dame that were actually worthwhile. One of them (Oklahoma) was vacated. Objectively speaking, he should never be mentioned in the same sentence as Knute Rockne.
Don’t ever try to lecture me again regarding Notre Dame football and its history.
jbarrett says:
John, I was not trying to say that Coach Kelly belongs in the same sentence as Coach Rockne. I was simply saying that you have to acknowledge the fact that he still manged to get 105 wins. In no way was I comparing Coach Kelly to Coach Rockne. It’s obvious that Knute is and will always be the best coach in ND history!!!
Also, you don’t have to get so defensive and I was not lecturing you about your knowledge of ND football. Remember, you are not the only one who knows about ND football and its history!
Mike Coffey says:
He remains the only coach in ND history to have wins vacated by the NCAA. If he had been less focused on a potential NFL career, he would have realized his players were violating NCAA rules.
If following the rules isn’t important to you, you may as well root for USC or North Carolina or Michigan.
John Vannie says:
No one is getting defensive except you, Joe. I do not believe Kelly’s record is particularly noteworthy, and it did not cross my mind as I wrote my postgame summary. Actually, Kelly’s tenure has been rather pedestrian whenever decent teams happen to pop up on his dumbed-down schedules. Certainly it’s well below the standards set by many of his more honorable and talented predecessors who set the bar much higher. Feel free to mention Kelly’s “achievement” in your comments if it makes you happy. When I think of Rockne and Ara Parseghian (my personal favorite ND icon) I think it’s rather sad.
jbarrett says:
John, what makes me happy is winning and they are doing it consistently now a days. Of course we all want to see championships and I feel we are getting closer and closer. When ND wins it makes my weekend much more enjoyable and if they lose, I am one cranky guy.
John Vannie says:
Joe, If you’ve watched this year’s team and believe ND is moving closer to a championship, I’d like to have whatever you are drinking.
Irish in the South says:
John, you are clearly biased in your views of BK and stubborn in your responses to Joe. All wins at ND are “worthwhile”.
John Vannie says:
What compels me to have a positive view of Brian Kelly? His failure to take any responsibility over the death of Declan Sullivan? His pursuit of an NFL job offer the minute he achieved some level of success at ND? His continued practice of throwing the players under the bus when he is outcoached in a loss? Telling the fan base to “Get used to it” when he tried and failed to outsmart Tulsa? That he oversaw a program that was forced to vacate 21 wins due to academic fraud, then denied any accountability? (read this: https://www.inc.com/scott-mautz/what-not-to-do-in-adversity-a-lesson-from-the-notre-dame-football-scandal.html ) That he insisted on throwing the ball in a hurricane as the Irish lost to North Carolina State? That he lazily sat around for years and did next to nothing on the recruiting front as his peers outworked him? That he whined to Fr. Jenkins and Jack Swarbrick that he needed field turf, a screaming Jumbotron and a severely dumbed down schedule to get a sniff of success? That he is marginally better than the three stooges who preceded him? That he is the losingest coach in ND Football history?
No thanks. I’m not going to lower my personal standards to accommodate this prick of a guy, even if that’s exactly what the current leadership at Notre Dame has done for the sake of the Almighty dollar. Maybe you and he deserve each other, Dick. But you’ll never be champions on the field or in life.
Jim Kress says:
Number of career games won is an interesting, but mediocre measure of a coach. A better measure is the percentage of games won. Looking at that measure, Kelly is 8th on the list of ND football coaches who coached for 5 or more seasons.
Here is the list of coaches and percentage wins:
Years Coached Coach Seasons Record Pct.
1918–30 Knute Rockne 13 105–12–5 0.881
1913–17 Jesse Harper 5 34–5–1 0.863
1941–43, 46–53 Frank Leahy 11 87–11–9 0.855
1964–74 Ara Parseghian 11 95–17–4 0.836
1934–40 Elmer Layden 7 47–13–3 0.770
1986–96 Lou Holtz 11 100–30–2 0.765
1975–80 Dan Devine 6 53–16–1 0.764
2010–present Brian Kelly 11 106-39 0.736
1954–58 Terry Brennan 5 32–18–0 0.640
1997–2001 Bob Davie 5 35–25 0.583
2005–2009 Charlie Weis 5 35–27 0.565
1981–85 Gerry Faust 5 30–26–1 0.535
RowdyIrishman says:
You forgot Willingham as well. He ties Davie at .583 at 21-15.
Jim Kress says:
I did not forget Willingham. The 5 season criteria eliminated him since he was only present for 3 seasons.
Jim Kress says:
Willingham did not meet the 5 season tenure as coach requirement. That is why he is not listed.
tar says:
He “won” 20 games with ineligible players. In other words, he cheated. Just like those players, which is why they were ineligible.
A68domer says:
Notre Dame actually won those games…
Mike Coffey says:
With ineligible players. I was taught ND followed the rules, which made us special.
Westfield Domer says:
I think ND did follow the rules by discovering what happened and presenting it to the NCAA. It was the players who took part in academic cheating who did not follow rules, and since Kelly isn’t with them 24 hours a day, I have a tough time blaming him solely for what happened. I also find it curious that the NCAA did not punish the University of North Carolina at all when their players were taking phony classes. How were those players not declared academically ineligible, and how did UNC not have wins taken away for that?
The Obvious says:
So, John, given all the comments, it certainly was an historic victory, however you look at it. That was my point. And all the subsequent opinions and perspectives were appreciated and interesting. Kelly, in my opinion, will never be one of our elite historical coaches, for a number of the reasons stated in those posts. But he may finish his career, by whatever measure, as the winningest.
Note to Jim Kress: I really liked your rank of coaches by winning percentage. Nicely done. My personal opinion: even though Faust ranked last, Charlie Weis was the worst coach in Notre Dame football history.
John Vannie says:
I’ve seen many historic wins by the Irish, and this hardly seemed like one of them.
If I bought a bottle of Dom Perignon when Kelly was named coach, the cork would still be in it.
The Obvious says:
Obviously, you don’t like Kelly. I don’t like him as a head coach, based upon what the Notre Dame football program used to be. But the problem is I believe those days are over. It’s been 33 years, John. Never in our history has there been such a long, miserable time between National Championships then now.
I’m an alum. I’m somewhere in your age group. I grew up living and dying Notre Dame Football. I used to listen to games in bed on my transistor radio, with the covers over my head, when Joe Boland did play-by-play. And I cried like a baby, when we lost. And we lost a lot. (Most people reading this will have to Google Joe Boland.) When Ara became head coach, it was like “a gift from God.” But, really, God doesn’t give a D*mn about Notre Dame football. So, all these years later, the great, historical Notre Dame Football Program is pretty much gone. And, John, you may not agree, but I don’t expect it will ever be back like it used to be. I don’t think that the big money backers care. And certainly the Administration doesn’t care.
I love our football history and all the pomp about it. Great memories. Great moments. Great lore. That’s what we have now. And that’s about it.
I can appreciate your animus toward Kelly, John. I really can. Because it comes from a passionate place in your heart, and a true love of Notre Dame Football, and all that it represented about our university. But I’m not so sure what our university really believes anymore. And Kelly, the football coach: if the guy coaches, say, 5 more years, goes undefeated once or twice, and wins a couple National Championships, I would say that he would be up there with our elite head coaches of years past. But, that’s not going to happen.
The Obvious says:
Thanks for not posting my last note. It was personal and meant for you. Something good about all this: my heart doesn’t beat like crazy, when I watch ND games anymore. And I have genuine laugh-out-loud moments. Happy, healthy life, John!
Jim Kress says:
Obvious,
Thanks. It was a labor of love.
The Obvious says:
Obviously!
Kevin Welsh says:
Even if you concede the vacated wins, Kelly is not Rockne. Rock’s wins came with 3 national championships within a decade and, in doing, basically creating the aura of Notre Dame. I am a Kelly fan and was an equal defender of his alter ego Ian Book. All both of them pretty much do is win games, ugly a lot of it, but I’ve learned to understand that it could be a lot worse for ND football. We should, however, make coaching comparisons between the two.
irishhawk50 says:
By the way watching the Penn State / Auburn game. Now that’s a white out and impressive. The green out was maybe 2/3’s of the stadium and the Irish dressed in blue. Why bother?
Marty says:
The alum and season ticket holders are pompous and above such a thing. No big noise, just the occasional clapping on a great play.
PC says:
My prediction was wrong which made me happy in this case. This team still has a lot of issues. If Coan is as immobile as it appears, he has to be laser accurate and he’s just not. If they’re to beat the better teams Buchner has to play a significant amount. Just read he had a tight hammy- would’ve been nice to know so I could’ve stopped yelling at the tv to put him in.
GOND88 says:
Well it wasn’t coyote ugly but it wasn’t textbook either. But at least they won and the defense looked more like a Clark Lea unit than a dazed and confused Van Gorder unit.
The offensive line is still a weak link and there’s no way they will win 10 games if there isn’t marked improvement up front.
The next several weeks will be a gut check for this team.
William F Murphy says:
Totally agree with the above assessment of our having completed “the exhibition portion of the season as prime time kicks in next week”. So true, and also didn’t realize our next three opponents will have by-weeks before playing us. As Tony Roberts used to say on his radio broadcasts; “get out those beads”. So Cal looked pretty potent without Clay Helton. I was hoping he would at least finish out the year. Stanford looked ALOT better,
and N. Carolina can score points in bunches. I can see a number of different scenarios now, and most of them negative. Hopefully, that was Jack Coan’s worst outing. BTW, did anyone watch the Penn ST / Auburn game? The officiating was, well, notable. That white-out atmosphere at State Park must be intimidating, and not always to their favor. Not all of the botched calls went against the ‘Lions’, but had they lost, there might be another Gettysburg brewing, and that entire SE Conf. officiating crew would be in hiding now.
Westfield Domer says:
I think ND did follow the rules by discovering what happened and presenting it to the NCAA. It was the players who took part in academic cheating who did not follow rules, and since Kelly isn’t with them 24 hours a day, I have a tough time blaming him solely for what happened. I also find it curious that the NCAA did not punish the University of North Carolina at all when their players were taking phony classes. How were those players not declared academically ineligible, and how did UNC not have wins taken away for that?
Calhoun says:
Classless move by ND (Jenkins and Swarbucks) not letting Purdue bring their big bass drum. College Football has been elevated to its high place in society because of traditions, the color and atmosphere of the game and the college atmosphere. Asses like Jenkins and Swarbucks whose only interest seems to be in maximizing profits dont value this and that is a shame and their actions regrettable.
Jim Kress says:
Tradition is an alien concept to Jenkins and Swarbrick.
PC says:
I love this site and have been enjoying the articles and game day write ups for over a decade. I don’t believe this will be a great season but I do see evidence of the improved recruiting in their skilled players, overall speed and depth. With that said, I’m a little surprised how negative this board has been regarding the state of the program and hatred for Kelly. .
Kelly will never be confused with Rockne, Ara, Leahy or even Lou and that’s not crime. At many times over the last decade, people screamed for various coaches to replace Kelly but I can’t think of one of them that has consistently been great over any meaningful stretch to make me feel we missed out on replacing him. Kelly’s tenure has seen Saban, Dabo, and Urban win 8 of the 11 titles.
Objectively, and purely looking at the on-field results, they are 105-39 overall and 46-8 since the 2016 disaster (only losing season) with 3 championship/playoff appearances. 3 undefeated regular seasons in his 11 full years. The 3 “big” games all resulted in blowouts and I’ve railed on his inability to play more competitively in those games. If we take a step back, 2 of those loses were to the greatest dynasty of the last 50 years and the other to the only team who has been consistently able to play with them.
Everyone is romanticizing about times that date back to between 40-100 years ago while completely dismissing every good thing that has happened since Kelly has gotten here. These last 11 years have fallen short of the ultimate goal, so I won’t say it’s been great, but it certainly stacks right below the very elite teams.
Mike Coffey says:
My attitude about Brian Kelly would be very different if I thought for one nanosecond he really wants to be at ND. It was a stepping stone job for him when he got here, he interviewed with the NFL the minute he got any kind of success (and would do so again in a NY minute, believe you me), and then spent the next couple seasons pouting (and hoping for other interviews) when the Eagles told him to fuck off. Only when he cratered in 2016 did he realize he was going to have to make the best of it at ND to avoid being known as another personification of the Peter Principle.
Brian Kelly has resented what makes ND special from the get-go. He and Swarbrick have turned what used to be a unique place into something that now barely hangs on to its identity, and has single-handedly destroyed most of what I’ve always loved about it.
So yes, I take it very personally when anyone tries to equate him with any of the icons that built this place. it’s a comparison he doesn’t deserve one iota, and I will fight any attempts to make it.
jbarrett says:
Mike, I wonder if you would still have the same attitude towards Coach Kelly if he were to win a national championship with Notre Dame before he retires!!
John Vannie says:
Winning a championship would probably make Kelly an even bigger asshole than he is now, as hard as that would be to imagine. As for Mike Coffey, he has a better chance of dating a supermodel than Kelly has of winning the big one.
Jim Kress says:
Dan Devine won a championship and the fans (and many team members) disliked him. The foul taste of some of the things Kelly has done at ND will not change him image with many of the fans and Alumni.
PC says:
Mike- thanks for sharing. I’m not close enough to know any of that. I know he flirted with the Eagles but genuinely thought after 2016 he made some really good self reflection and made himself into a better overall leader and coach. Barring something totally unforeseen, he’s probably here until he wants to retire which could be several more years. Let’s hope Vannies wrong and he somehow wins one.
Mike Coffey says:
I’m certainly not rooting against him to do it, I’d love to see another title in my lifetime
John Vannie says:
Would you prefer that supermodel to be blonde, brunette, or redhead?
John T Riely, ND 1981 says:
Also, Kelly’s lack of contrition and failure to accept any responsibility during the Declan Sullivan tragedy and his cowardly minimalization of the windy weather conditions on that awful day will forever taint his legacy and is in my mind a far more compelling indictment of his character and legacy than his inability to beat the Alabamas and Clemsons of the world. Ditto for Swarbucks.