Notre Dame stuck to a familiar script by turning a comfortable 16-3 halftime advantage into a narrow 22-17 victory that came down to the final minute of play. Vanderbilt scratched back from a 22-10 deficit in the fourth quarter to pull within five points, and had a chance to win at the end when Kalija Lipscomb could not come down with a fourth down pass deep in Irish territory. The Commodores were aided in their comeback by a sputtering Notre Dame offense and a pair of fortuitous pass interference calls on fourth down plays. Even more frustrating was the absolute refusal of the referees to notice even one of several blatant holds by Vandy offensive linemen against the Irish pass rushers, but apparently that was a bridge too far for this ACC crew. Notre Dame ascends to 3-0 on the season, although improvement along several fronts will be necessary if the Irish expect to keep it going.
The pattern for the Irish offense developed early in the contest as an impressive opening drive stalled in the red zone. Justin Yoon came on to kick his first of three field goals for a 3-0 lead just four minutes into the action. Notre Dame’s defensive line dominated play throughout the first half and the Commodores punted on their first four possessions. The Irish added a touchdown at the end of the first quarter when Brandon Wimbush scrambled home from 12 yards out on a broken play.
Kyle Shurmur finally got his offense moving late in the second period with a 75-yard drive, but Notre Dame was able to keep them from scoring. A Shurmur pass to Donaven Tennyson at the one yard line became a turnover when Irish safety Alohi Gilman stripped the ball and Julian Love fell on it in the end zone for a touchback.
The Irish offense had chances to build an insurmountable lead in the second quarter, but two promising drives fizzled in scoring territory. Yoon made field goals of 33 and 46 yards during this stretch and Notre Dame led by 16-0 with 1:15 remaining in the half. Shurmur hit a few quick passes and brought the Commodores to the Irish three yard line with eight seconds remaining. His next attempt was dropped, however, and Coach Derek Mason elected to kick a field goal as the half ended.
Vanderbilt started to have more offensive success in the third quarter, but they continued to commit miscues to keep them from scoring. A missed field goal ended their first drive and an interception by Troy Pride stopped the next one. A 20-yard punt return set up another Commodore possession in Irish territory, and this time Ke’Shawn Vaughn capped a 47-yard scoring march with a two-yard touchdown as the period drew to a close.
Leading by only 16-10, Notre Dame opened the fourth stanza with its best drive of the day. Reserves Ian Book and Nick Weishar teamed up for a short touchdown pass at the 11:04 mark, and the Irish stretched their lead to 22-10. A subsequent two-point conversion pass was unsuccessful.
Shurmur responded by moving his team across midfield, where the drive appeared to stall. The Commodores were bailed out of a fourth down incompletion by a pass interference call, and Shurmur took advantage moments later when he hit tight end Jared Pinkney with a scoring strike with over seven minutes remaining.
The Irish special teams came through on the subsequent kickoff as freshman Michael Young ran one back to the Notre Dame 49. The offense ran the ball into the red zone, but had to settle for another Yoon field goal that would afford them the relative safety of an eight point lead. The timing of the snap and hold was a bit off, however, and Yoon missed from 32 yards.
Vanderbilt therefore had one more shot to win with 3:39 to go and behind by only 22-17. Two quick plays advanced them to midfield, but the effort seemed to fail as another fourth down pass fell incomplete. Once again, a flag was thrown and the Irish were penalized for interference. The next series finally went Notre Dame’s way. Pride broke up a third down slant pass, and Pinkney could not come down with a leaping catch on fourth down as the ball rolled harmlessly away when his body hit the ground.
With 1:07 left, Notre Dame ran the clock down to twelve seconds before Tyler Newsome blasted a 63-yard punt to effectively crush Vanderbilt’s hopes for a final Hail Mary pass. Once again, the post game emotions were more a matter of relief rather than exultation, but the Irish avoided the upset and live to fight another day.
Let’s review the pregame questions for addition insight.
Will the Notre Dame defensive front knock Shurmur out of his rhythm? They did a great job in the first half before the heat of the day caused some fatigue later on. As I mentioned, the pressure would have been more effective if Vandy’s linemen didn’t repeatedly get away with holding them all afternoon.
Can either team establish a respectable running game? Notre Dame outgained the Commodores on the ground by 245-94, and this factor more than anything was the difference in the outcome.
Will Wimbush avoid drive-killing sacks and interceptions? Wimbush was 13 for 23 and 122 yards, with no touchdowns or interceptions. The red zone failures were more the result of poor play selection, and he did bail out his coach with one heroic touchdown scramble in the first half.
Can Mason push the right buttons to keep his defense from getting steamrolled? Mason kept his team in the game and gave them a chance to win at the end, but the close score is arguably more a result of Irish offensive stumbles as opposed to great defensive acumen by Vanderbilt.
Will the Irish demonstrate increased intensity after last week’s uninspired effort? Kelly gave fiery, TV-friendly speeches during pregame and at halftime, but his charges remain inconsistent. The first two drives and the opening drive of the final period were the best of the day, so there were positives. The defense remains the strength of the team and will have to hold up every week if Notre Dame is going to keep winning.
Can the Notre Dame special teams have a positive impact on the outcome? Yes!! Young’s long kickoff return was a welcome event. Newsome finally punted the ball like we knew he could, and Jonathan Doerer’s kickoffs sailed into the end zone. Yoon was probably not at fault for his one miss, and his contributions were a vital part of the outcome.
Will the Irish be able to avoid another costly injury? A few players were dinged up during the afternoon and went to the sidelines, but all returned to action later.
Next up is the first road trip of the season to Wake Forest, and Hurricane Florence should be long gone by then. The people in that region have a lot more important things to worry about this week, and we wish them well.
Marty says:
I’ll repeat my comments from last week. Zero progress by Wimbush. Can’t make the plays when they are needed most. Continues to throw into double coverage. Kelly, by sticking with Wimbush, is turning a good team into mediocre.
irishhawk50 says:
Great victory over Georgia…oh… I mean Vanderbilt. Irish appear to be a top 25 team (maybe). They are not going to be a playoff team with Wimbush at the helm (or it appears with Kelly as a coach). I guess we just have to get used it (remember that Kellyism?). That said, as a kid I suffered through the Kuharich years so I have the antibodies to deal with this (i think).
irishhawk50 says:
Speaking of coaching, I would like someone to explain to me why with 12 seconds left you would potentially over kick your coverage and allow a possible return (maybe for a touchdown) rather than angle a punt out of bounds and thus not allow any return. I think I would rather sacrifice the additional yardage for a guaranteed no return with just 5 seconds remaining on the clock. I’ve always wondered about these types of situations and today’s game was a perfect example.
TimCamel says:
You seriously find a reason to complain with a great play? An angled punt carries more risk of a shank than a 63 yard punt in safe coverage being returned for a TD.
I think you are the one that has out kicked your coverage of second guessing and complaining.
irishhawk50 says:
Just wondering, no more likely to get a great punt than a shank. Easy to say after the fact of a 63 yard punt, but that was not a foregone situation when the play was called. Again, I was just wondering because I rarely see a situation where a punt out of bounds might make sense.
Jake in Cali says:
JVAN,
Another “average” performance by ND….Kelly in way over his head with getting this
team to dominate below average football teams.
The O should be flowing by now,,,, but it remains the same every week…
Trust me, Wake Forest will give us a huge battle next weekend..
Still wasting all of the WR Talent (especially Boykin)…
John Vannie says:
Receivers are getting open but no one can see them or get them the ball. The best plays in this offense result from pure improvisation by Wimbush. It makes me wonder what practice looks like, because it would seem to be hard to practice what we see on Saturdays.
Jake in Cali says:
Kelly’s scheme is an “exercise in futility”!!!
Stanford, VTECH, are almost a certainty to beat us unless something drastic
happens soon…
bocceman2 says:
9 years in I keep repeating Kelly fails to coach up talent.
Second half adjustments if any fail to produce
Is Tommy Reese a QB coach?
Blow out loss like Miami last year coming
Drasail2 says:
Shurmer was 26/43. The defence broke up a lot of these. When you play a team imbalanced toward the run or pass the result can get crazy. That was quite a test for the defense and they handled it well. I have no issues with Wimbush. We know who he is, I just want the offense adjusted to his strengths. Keep winning.
Scott B says:
I used to come here to get ND news. Now I come for entertainment – watch a group of “fans” who for the last ten years can’t enjoy a single victory. Sorry, but this message board is comical. It isn’t that you are wrong exactly – BW is not a great quarterback and this team probably isn’t doing much this year – but why bother watching when no possible outcome would satisfy.
“Except if they fired Brian Kelly and hired X”
Nah. It’d be complaints about the next thing because it always is here.
Not a great looking game – not a great looking team. But they won. Why not enjoy watching, smile when they win then move about your day?
Mike Coffey says:
Actually, a 21-point win or better probably would have satisfied.
You said it yourself — not a great looking game or team. That satisfies you in year nine of a coach’s tenure? We have different standards.
Terry MCMANUS says:
I would say that “satisfy” is the wrong word here. “SSDD” might fit.
TimCamel says:
So you were one of the people trying to run off Holtz in 1996 when he beat Vandy by 7 and lost to Air Force in his 11th year? Two years removed from 6-5-1?
Vandy won 2 games in 1996. Do you think they will win more than 2 games this year?
Or were your standards different in 1996?
I’m not comparing Holtz to Kelly.
I am comparing your lack of consistent standards and your website’s tenor of constant whining and complaining even after a win.
irishhawk50 says:
Not sure but I seem to remember starting quarterback was hurt in the Air Force loss and not available. Apples and oranges?
TimCamel says:
Powlus played that game.
But probably doesnt get any more apples and oranges that Powlus and Wimbush.
John Vannie says:
Go to any fan site where the team’s performance consistently falls well below the level of its talent, and tell me what you see.
Larry Rossi says:
Predictable…aside from a “scripted” first drive, not much to see here. I’m sure the opposing coach just tells his guys to be patient and wait for the second half and he’d be right. Not sure what Kelly’s doing…he may not be either…but inserting Ian Book makes a difference.
GOND88 says:
A win is a win, I know, but an unimpressive win over a team that will finish near the bottom of the SEC. We heard all offseason how hard Wimbush was working and how much better he was. I don’t doubt that he worked hard but the passing game still looks like sandlot football most of the time it and it looks like he has trouble spotting open receivers.
Apparently the Vandy O-line coach told his charges to hold the defenders until the refs called it. They never did and this helped Vandy with their air raid of 340 some yards.
But not to worry as Brian Kelly says the team is still evolving. Sadly, evolution is a very slow process. Too bad the season isn’t long enough to see us evolve into Ohio State, Clemson or Alabama.
Ryan Christopher Eddy says:
This team will not win against other top 25 teams with BW at QB. They will not win with Book at QB. Why not go ahead put in Jurkovec and let him get some reps. It’s not going to be worse than the product we have on the field now. The schedule looks a lot easier now with FSU and USC not looking good, but Stanford and VT look like sure losses right now. I’m impressed with the defense and Jones looked good running the ball yesterday, but a change needs to be made at QB.
Byerish says:
Hard to believe any ND fan would cry about officiating. ND is mostly catered to by refs. Amazing how they missed the Vandy receivers forward progress being clearly stopped at the goal line before the strip. It is once again a very average team that will play mostly very average teams – until by name alone they get into a bigger bowl. At which time reality sucks.
Brian says:
I think people are underrating Vandy. I bet they finish 10-2 and second to Georgia in their SEC division. That was a good team we played yesterday.
SCIrish says:
I have been a Notre Dame fan for many years, but it is becoming all too painful to watch this current team. I have defended Brian Kelly, and I applauded the success of last year, and his changes; but I find that I now believe that there is a better coach out there. This team has more talent than it has had in many years, yet that talent is being squandered, and it deserves better leadership.
Kelly’s continued marriage to BW must soon end in divorce, or this team will dramatically underachieve. It will NOT make the playoffs with Wimbush at QB. You say the team is inconsistent. Yes it is, and it begins with the QB. BW cannot hit receivers CONSISTENTLY. They never know what’s coming…a fastball or a wounded duck…in front of them, on target, behind them, over their head, or in the dirt. Where in hell did the sidearm pass come from? And the RPO is no better option than the I formation. We have an offensive line that has the capability to play smash mouth football. Let them. The running game had 240+ yards yesterday. Teams will continue to dare Wimbush to beat them with his arm…he won’t.
Thank God for the assistant coaches, who have done a phenomenal job of training this team. Tommy Rees gets a pass because BW is Kelly’s and Kelly’s alone. Kelly wants him to succeed at the expense of the team. The kid is NOT a college QB. He should be a running back, as that is the only thing he can do CONSISTENTLY.
I love the Irish, and I love to see them win. But that winning will stop with the current leadership. There are good teams coming up on the schedule, and if the Irish play as they have the last two weeks, they will lose. Losing to goods teams, and playing well in the process, is football. It happens. But, losing to good teams, playing crappy, uninspired, sloppy football, is inexcusable. This teams habit is becoming the later, and Karma will get her due.
Robert McReynolds says:
From 2015 to 2018, ND has been in the top 15 with recruiting classes. Now during that same time period ND has finished ranked 11 in 2015, not ranked in 2016, and ranked 11 in 2017. This is a team that has plateaued and is not going to get any better despite the talent that is recruited. This is a coaching problem. It wouldn’t matter who was QB’ing this team and it won’t matter this year. The biggest problem with this team is the head coach not being a type that will bring this team to the elite ranks of college football. Until BK is fired, this team will be a severe disappointment. Wake is going to play us close again and then it will be a loss to Stanford and a blowout loss to VT. Then the team will quit on the season and maybe drop another game either to Navy or USC, or both.