Notre Dame struggled at times on Saturday but ultimately wore down North Carolina State on the way to a 45-24 victory. The 3-0 Fighting Irish blew open a tight contest with 21 straight points in the fourth quarter to lead by 45-17. A late score by the Wolfpack added a small measure of respectability to the final margin. The marathon afternoon featured a two hour weather delay that commenced at the end of the first quarter. Both teams adjusted to the conditions but play was often sloppy and undisciplined. In the end, however, Notre Dame’s talent and offensive weaponry beat the scrappy hosts into submission.
The defenses dominated in the opening minutes. Sam Hartman ran for Notre Dame’s initial first down on its third possession of the game. A penalty quickly stalled a promising march, and Coach Marcus Freeman called upon kicker Spenser Schrader to attempt a 54-yard field goal. Schrader delivered with a no-doubt blast for a 3-0 lead. NC State stalled on the ensuing possession and punted the ball back to the Irish on the first snap of the second period. At that moment, the officials cleared the field and the stands due to imminent adverse weather.
Notre Dame’s offense took the field after the long break. Audric Estime ran a well-conceived counter play and shot through the stunned Wolfpack for an 80-yard score. The Irish could not sustain the momentum and the contest settled into a punting contest until the final minutes of the half.
A 45-yard reception by Tobias Merriweather put Notre Dame in scoring position but a subsequent third down sack of Hartman forced Freeman’s hand. He again asked Schrader to kick a three pointer from long range. The 56-yard attempt had plenty of distance but clanged off the left upright.
North Carolina State took over with 2:19 left and got untracked with the help of three major penalties against the Irish defense. Quarterback Brennan Armstrong capped the drive with a scoring strike to Bradley Rozner to cut Notre Dame’s lead to 10-7.
Freeman had used a pair of timeouts in that sequence to give his offense a chance to respond before intermission. The strategy worked as Hartman found a wide open Chris Tyree for 65 yards to the State 13. Hartman threw his best pass of the day on the next play with a laser to Jaden Greathouse in the back of the end zone for a 17-7 halftime margin.
Another defensive penalty provided an assist to North Carolina State in the third quarter. The result was a 49-yard field goal by Brayden Narveson to bring the Wolves within 17-10. The crowd woke up but were quickly quieted as Hartman needed only three plays to get the Irish back into the end zone. Tight end Holden Staes caught passes of 29 and 40 yards, with the latter resulting in a touchdown.
The hosts refused to quit, however, as Armstrong led his team right back down the field. A long completion to Keyon Lesane set up a one yard keeper to make it a seven point margin again at 24-17. There were 18 minutes left in the game, and the roller coaster ride was just beginning.
The Wolfpack sacked Hartman on the next series and knocked the ball loose. NC State recovered on the Irish 17-yard line with a chance to tie it up. Despite the fever pitch of the partisan crowd, Notre Dame’s defense rose to the occasion and came up with a much-needed stop. Narveson was forced to try a 34-yard field, which he pulled wide to the left.
The blown scoring chance seemed to energize the Irish defense and depress the hosts as the final period commenced. Safety Xavier Watts knocked down an Armstrong pass on a second down play and intercepted his next one on third down. Hartman took over and found another tight end, Davis Sherwood, from ten yards out for a wide open touchdown.
Now trailing 31-17, Armstrong went back to the air. This time it was veteran safety DJ Brown’s turn to make a play. His diving interception deep in NC State territory was a thing of beauty. Estime quickly cashed in from seven yards for a 38-17 lead. The two interceptions and scores took less than a minute off the clock.
The Wolfpack still had ten minutes to fight back. They were not about to quit but they again came up short. A fourth down pass did not clear the line to gain and Notre Dame took over on what was effectively another turnover. Hartman again linked up with Staes for a 35-yard strike on play-action pass to push the score to 45-17. Armstrong threw a late touchdown pass against the Irish reserves to account for the final margin.
Hartman finished 15 of 24 for 286 yards and four touchdowns. Staes led the receivers with 115 yards while Estime had 134 rush yards on 14 carries with two scores. Armstrong was 22 of 47 for 260 yards and two touchdowns. He suffered three interceptions, including a beautiful grab by Benjamin Morrison in the first half. The Wolfpack did not throw the ball in Morrison’s direction after that play.
The Irish looked befuddled at times in the early going before settling down. The blocking schemes did not handle the blitzing NC State defense very well and Hartman’s receivers were unable to separate against the Wolfpack secondary. Several of Gerad Parker’s play calls were head-scratchers as well. Notre Dame suffered ten penalties for 82 yards. Most of these calls were against the defense but even All-American left tackle Joe Alt was deemed guilty of holding.
Despite this adversity, the Irish proved to be resilient. They dominated the game from the point of greatest concern at the end of the third quarter and won going away. Freeman and his staff have several issues to address but the team will have another dress rehearsal next week before its first major test.
Let’s review the answers to our pregame questions:
- Can the Irish offensive tackles neutralize ends Vann and Jackson? Vann was active in the early going with a pair of sacks but he and his mates wore down and were rarely heard from thereafter.
- Will Hartman recognize and counter NC State’s multiple defensive looks? Not at first as he and OC Parker searched for something that would work. They found it with the throws to the tight ends that burned the blitzers.
- Can the Irish ground game allow Hartman to throw fewer than 25 passes? He threw exactly 24 passes. The Irish backs gained 197 yards on 32 carries. Hartman’s rush total was -27 yards given the multiple sacks by NC State.
- Will Marty Biagi’s return and coverage teams rebound from last week? Schrader’s howitzer-like kicks were the best feature of Biagi’s teams. The only notable moment for the return and cover teams was Jack Kiser’s offside gaffe. These units don’t seem very special this season.
- Can the Irish defense limit Armstrong’s rushing yardage to <50? Armstrong managed only 26 of his team’s 84 yards on the ground. Notre Dame’s plan to keep him bottled up behind the line was mostly well-executed.
- Which team will win the turnover battle? Hartman’s fumble was the only blemish for Notre Dame while Armstrong’s trio of interceptions proved costly.
- Can Notre Dame’s wide receivers get open against the Wolfpack corners? Not at first. Parker’s second half adjustment to the scheme freed up the tight ends and broke open the game.
- Will Freeman insist on throwing the ball from the shotgun if there is a monsoon? Freeman was smart enough to send himself and his team into the locker room during the monsoon.
Notre Dame’s defense allowed three touchdowns, which is three more than their first two opponents managed. In reality, the first score was a gift based on uncharacteristic penalties where the unit momentarily lost its composure. The final touchdown was a garbage time concession. There are plenty of mistakes to clean up but I was impressed with the unrestrained aggression by the Irish secondary. I would still like to see a better pass rush, though. The front four rarely applied pressure and Al Golden’s too-frequent blitzes usually fell flat.
Offensively, Hartman showed he is human. He held the ball too long on several occasions and his accuracy suffered under pressure. The offensive line raised concerns by failing to pick up blitzes and missing blocks entirely. Center Zeke Correll had a rough outing and guard Rocco Spindler also struggled in pass protection.
As expected, this game was a much better test than the two prior exhibitions. My main takeaways are that Notre Dame is talented and fun to watch but also youthful and inconsistent. The coaches will have their hands full in an effort to get them to play their best football when it matters most. The good news is this group appears to be highly motivated and united.
Will says:
This game was more of a dogfight than the final score would indicate. The bad weather and the subsequent long delay played a factor in some of the game’s sloppiness. The Hartman/Armstrong duel was fun to watch. ND’s ground game really was the deciding factor. In the big picture, it was good to get this game out of the way because the coaching staff now knows a lot more about ND’s areas of improvement. My question for you, Vannie, is after watching this game what kind of a game plan do you think that Ryan Day will implement against ND?
John Vannie says:
Defensively, Ohio State will pressure Hartman up the middle like they did last year. Michael Hall abused Zeke Correll and the guards in that game, and linebacker Tommy Eichenberg single-handedly shut down the Irish ground game. They will do it again in my opinion because ND is not much better in those spots this year.
On offense, OSU will throw the ball to their stud receivers, Harrison and Egbuka. ND’s four man pass rush is not good enough to pressure McCord. His receivers will get open if given sufficient time. If ND tries to blitz OSU will take full advantage.
OSU simply has more talent on both sides of the ball.
AustinIrish says:
John, great analysis as always. I’m afraid you’re right about the Buckeyes and their talent superiority. We will have to outcoach them.
One Historian says:
Agreed, and to me that makes OSU Freeman’s ‘make your bones’ game. The fact that a Duke team that is much better than anticipated follows that makes the next 3 weeks very interesting.
Phil Calandra says:
Agree with your OSU vs ND overall talent assessment and I’m sure if we played a best of 3,5, or 7 series Buckeyes would prevail. But we don’t. We only play them once, at Home. Them with a rookie QB, us with a 6th starter/ holder of many ACC passing records. I think we outdcore them in a shoot out. Take the over for sure.
Couple questions. Who did we have at LT when Alt lined up at TE? Second, why has Botelho disappeared as an edge rusher?
John Vannie says:
Looking at the play again, Alt swithed over and line up on the right side next to Fisher, as a tight end would.Regular tight end Mitchell Evans lined up as a left tackle. We essentially had a big time power right formation and used it to spring Estime for 80 yards. Pretty creative. Botelho was told not to let Armstrong escape the pocket and scramble for big yardage, so his pass rushes were more restrained. He did draw one offensive holding penalty that I saw.
The OSU game will come down to ND’s pass rush. If they are unable to get pressure, that rookie quarterback will be the one who exits the field as a Heisman candidate instead of Hartman.
Will says:
It’s true that the ND pass rush vs NCS did not result in any sacks, but I counted 7 “hurries.” Golden’s strategy was for the d linemen to maintain gap integrity to keep the mobile Armstrong in the pocket. It was a very effective tactic. I’m sure that will not be the approach against OSU. He’ll want to test the young qb with pressure and more pressure. This week’s opponent CMU also has a running quarterback… so again gap correctness will be the first priority for the ND defense.
ND fan in the South says:
I am always optimistic. We have OSU in our house. It will make a difference.
joe says:
Good win by the Irish!! Like you said John, the defensive backfield played very aggressive and the 3 int were icing on the cake!! Hartman continues to impress me along with the power running game!! However, little frustrated with the penalties and some of the gestures the players displayed when they made a big play. I sure hope Coach Freeman addresses that to the players!! Still mighty happy with the win and a record of 3-0!! Go ND Beat Chippewas!!!!
James Kress says:
Great game. Glad to see this version of the Irish starting to look like a Holtz team.
Estime reminds me of Bettis.
Do we think the Irish Secondary, especially the Safeties, could use a bit of tackling practice?
Dean says:
The whole defense, especially the DBs, need a ton of tackling practice. Hit them low and wrap them up, for crying out loud! Many of ND’s defenders look like they’re afraid of contact.
John Vannie says:
Remember that guys like Henderson, Hart, and Watts are converted wide receivers. Only Watts seems to behave like a natural born hitter. The rest do shy away from contact and just try to grab.
Monty B says:
i agree. Yes, they do. It’s an ongoing problem that will cost them a game(s).
Hiawassee Ga Irish says:
Always love to read your synopsis Vannie because you are spot on and no bs. It would be tough to call the Irish undisciplined with all the penalties because it was a weird game with the starts and stops. You’re right. Hartman showed he is human but he made the plays to pull away. Estime is a stud. So glad he is Irish.
ND fan in the South says:
Good, detailed summary of the game, Mr. Vannie. I was happy to see some great catches by our tight ends and new, young stars showing some promise. Our team’s performance in a very hostile environment was encouraging. That crowd was loud and nasty.
Irish Rifle says:
Excellent effort overall by the Irish which was hurt by excessive penalties, although a number of those were ridiculous calls. This appears to be the the best Notre Dame team in years and is poised to defeat OSU at home in a couple of weeks.
Joe Libby says:
Hartman is getting better each week. His one major adjustment has to be more short West Coast offense passes, where the receiver has to add 10 to 15 yards to the catch. The one very important factor is getting Chris Tyree in the offense
Marty says:
Agree with your pass rush and blitz assessments. Botelho was non factor as a pass rusher. Also seemed predictable on many of the running plays.
#❤️☘️50 says:
RIGHT ON VANNIE!!!!!!!
AS A TEAM Sloppy, inconsistent, and undisciplined.
Our O-Line looks puggie, slow, not on the same page for blovking and do not move their feet!!!!!!!! UNACCEPTABLE!!!!!!
Sam keeps getting hit like that he won’t make it to the bowl game.
THIS team has A LOT of work to do if they are to make the playoffs (defensively maybe, offensively not much)!
mike says:
The most disturbing thing: all the penalties, which early on threatened to hand the game to NCSU. The most re-assuring: the manner in which the team withstood all the negatives involving the weather, the delay, the penalties, the repetitive opponent comebacks in the midst of a loud and taunting crowd. This is the quintessential beneficial game that combines a great victory against many odds, and provides multiple opportunities for teaching points to guide further improvement. Go Irish!
irishhawk50 says:
My view of Hartman came down to earth, but I think one of his problems, which you don’t see on the TV screen, was the lack of separation early on by the receivers. Take away the “chunk plays” (Estime 80 yard run and Tyree catch and run) and the game would have taken on a different feel. Add in the fact that early on Armstrong was missing a bunch of his throws.
As someone wrote, the game was closer than the final score. A lot of things to clean up quickly if the Irish are going to prevail in the weeks after Central Michigan.
Vairish84 says:
Separation by the receivers has been a problem for years. I am not sure if it is speed, routes, route running, QB play, but it is a continuous problem.
As for speed, I didn’t like that Merriweather was caught from behind by a LB.
Domer262 says:
Great win! The Irish overcame a lot of adversity. Many of the penalties were ridiculous. The announcers on Sunny 101.5 said the only thing lacking was a police escort for North Carolina Staye’s touchdown. They tackled Hartman around his neck which was a horseshoe collar tackle, and that wasn’t even called. The one ND defender puts his hand on a helmet and that was penalized. Not a fan of the ACC officiating crew, and I was happy that ND was able to overcome the weather, the referees, and the crowd. ND was resilient!
Go Irish, beat Chippewas! ☘️.
Domer262 says:
Sorry for the incorrect spelling of North Carolina State. The keyboard is too small when typing on my IPhone.😃
Jim Tooley says:
The talent on this team is far superior to anything we have had in recent memory. When was the last time ND had a Heisman quality quarterback, a bruising running back complimented by 3 other quality backs with a combination of speed and strength, a secondary that blankets the opposing receivers, and receivers like Staes who have size and speed? The defense overall plays with confidence and aggression and we even have a kicker that can blast one from 55 yards. This team can beat Ohio State at home in two weeks. Don’t ever underestimate the the advantage of an experienced quarterback over a first year starter in college football.
VegasPoker74 says:
The biggest factor in the win was the lack of over pursuit by the rushing defenders even when blitzing. We didn’t get many sacks but Armstrong was well contained and rarely had a chance to punish our secondary both running and passing.
Start preparing for OSU this week. The O-line needs some wrinkles in their blocking schemes. Head up won’t cut it. Lots of tackling drills for the secondary. Blocking drills for the running backs to keep SH on his feet.
bocceman2 says:
Agree with everything stated. I was befuddled like you by some of Parker’s play calling. Would like to have seen more misdirection plays. This teem seems to be talented and motivated just need to watch those penalties.
Sky Grey says:
It was a good effort and what I like about this team beyond the improved overall depth and talent level at skilled positions (both offense and defense) is that this staff seems to make in game adjustments far better than Kelly ever did. I liked how Freeman spun the delay as a positive saying we needed the break to make adjustments and then came out after the break and hit them hard with a 80yard counter run and then used the tight ends to seal the deal. The penalties were annoying and honestly we handed them 10pts on those penalties as well as keeping that early drive alive with an offsides on the punt return unit. I like our odds against OSU. They have underwhelmed so far against inferior opponents not really scoring at the level they normally would. As Vannie said we are going to have to get some pressure but it is unfair to say we didn’t get pressure against NC Sate because we actually pressured well all day (just didn’t get sacks) and that was a factor in the low completion percentage and 3 intercepts by a good veteran QB. We also totally stuffed their run, including a dual threat QB so I think the criticism of the front 7 and DL might be a little harsh. We have never beat OSU in my life (53yrs) so this has got to be the year. We are much better in Red Zone O and D this year, have some sold cover guys in the backend and have as good a run gaming as last year with the addition of a top QB who reads defenses and throws downfield really well. Not to mention we have one of the best looking 2 minute offenses. Hartman looked rough early but still threw for 63%, 280yards and 4 touchdowns. We have so many options on O its going to be hard for anyone to hold us down. NCS had the longest streak in the country holding teams under 30pts as well as being 18-2 the last 3 seasons at home and we hung 45 points on them.