Notre Dame hopes to bounce back from a wet, sloppy and ultimately soul-crushing road trip when the Fighting Irish host the Naval Academy on Saturday. The Midshipmen are 4-0 for the first time since 2004, and have won eight straight games dating back to last year’s 49-39 loss to Notre Dame. Navy has played a weak 2015 schedule to date, but the Irish can’t afford to be overconfident based on the recent competitiveness between these teams and the cascade of turnovers and mental lapses they committed against Clemson. Saturday’s game will commence at 3:30 PM Eastern time and NBC will provide national television coverage.
Navy Coach Ken Niumatalolo has posted a career-record of 61-35 in his seven plus seasons at the helm. The 61 wins are the most in school history, and he is 2-5 against Notre Dame with back to back victories in 2009-10. The Irish lead the all-time series by 75-12-1. Both teams celebrate the long standing rivalry and have agreed to play games in Jacksonville, FL in 2016 and in San Diego, CA in 2018.
Irish fans can take heart in the fact that the team performed exceptionally well last month against Georgia Tech, who also runs a version of the triple option offense. On balance, the Mids cannot match Georgia Tech’s athletic ability, but they run multiple formations and are very adept at keeping an opponent off balance. Senior quarterback Keenan Reynolds leads a traditionally strong rushing attack that has chewed up 340 yards per game, and the defense has played well despite starting only four seniors.
Last week, Coach Brian Kelly saw Clemson load up to stop his powerful running game and force Notre Dame’s relatively inexperienced quarterback, DeShone Kizer, to beat them through the air. The Irish finally adjusted, but it proved to be too late as a furious fourth quarter rally fell a yard short. This week, Navy may not be strong enough to make Notre Dame’s offense one-dimensional, but they will do their best to confuse Kizer with pre-snap shifts, blitzes and stunts. The Mids do have enough firepower to pull off another monumental upset in this series if the Irish continue to commit turnovers and are not emotionally ready for a 60-minute battle.
NOTRE DAME’S OFFENSE vs. NAVY’S DEFENSE
The Irish need to establish Will Fuller as a deep threat and get the running game untracked after both were largely neutralized last week. C.J. Prosise carried a heavy workload against Clemson and may be banged up a bit, so Kelly must find opportunities to work Josh Adams and Dexter Williams into the rotation. Along the offensive line, Quenton Nelson should be available at left guard despite an ankle injury, and the right side of the line simply needs to improve after a lackluster performance in Death Valley.
Navy’s 3-4 defense is among its best and most athletic in recent seasons. Linebackers Micah Thomas and Daniel Gonzales are accomplished players at 240+ pounds, while senior defensive end Will Anthony is a disruptive player. Nose tackle Bernard Sarra is a legitimate 300 pounder who will be a handful in the middle despite playing with a cast on his forearm. This group has surrendered fewer than 150 rushing yards per game and just one rushing touchdown, which is impressive at any level and certainly noteworthy for a service academy that must typically overcome an opponent’s size advantage.
Navy was hit with a devastating loss at the rover position last week, when Kwazel Bertrand broke his ankle. Relatively inexperienced backup Daiquan Thomasson will get the start for the Mids. Free safety Lorentez Barbour now becomes the leader of the secondary, which has also performed well from a statistical standpoint (186 passing yards allowed per game). Cornerback Quincy Adams is the team’s best cover man.
Earlier this week, Niumatalolo praised his defense while being careful to build up his opponent. “This is our best defense that we’ve had, and we’ll go in there and take a shot at them,” he said. “Like I said, they’re really good, always have been. Coach [Brian] Kelly, I’ve always admired the way he calls plays. If he sees something, he’s going to exploit it. He’s got a great feel for the game, so we’ve got to be able to adjust. We’ve got some ideas on what to do, but he’s going to adjust really quickly to us.”
NAVY’S OFFENSE vs. NOTRE DAME’S DEFENSE
Once again, the Midshipmen will rely on the wizardry of Reynolds to keep the Irish off balance. The senior already has nine rushing touchdowns this season and needs only five more to break the all-time FBS career record of 76. The skill position players surrounding Reynolds this year were backups in 2014, but the new starters have compensated quite well for those graduation losses.
First down plays will be critical in that gains of five or more yards will enable Navy to run its offense without undue risks. Reynolds has thrown only 28 passes in four games but has earned 19 yards per reception. Navy has not had to throw the ball under duress this season, and the task for Notre Dame will be to force them into that very position.
Fullback Chris Swain and backup Quentin Ezell are extremely productive, averaging five yards per carry. Slotback DeBrandon Sanders is only 5’7”, but he has gained over ten yards each time he takes a pitch from Reynolds. The reason behind their success is a veteran offensive line, with four seniors and sophomore right tackle Robert Lindsey.
The Irish secondary must account for 6’4” wide receiver Jamir Tillman, who will be the primary target of Reynolds when he drops back to pass. The Mids have also been successful throwing to slotbacks Sanders and Dishan Romine on the wheel route, where they have racked up sizeable gains.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Navy’s specialists are also quite competent. Kicker Austin Grebe is perfect on field goals this season while punter Alex Barta averages close to 44 yards while allowing only one return. Sanders and Romine handle most of the kickoff and punt return chores and are both elusive and dangerous.
Tyler Newsome and Justin Yoon continue to man the punting and kicking chores for Notre Dame, and both will pray for a dry field on Saturday with unremarkable winds. Yoon and his holder (usually Kizer) appear to have conquered the mechanical issues that resulted in a couple of missed kicks earlier this season, and Newsome has been solid. C.J. Sanders gave the team a boost with a punt return for a touchdown two weeks ago, although he fumbled the second half kickoff against Clemson that led to a Tiger score in a two point loss.
SUMMARY
Navy is a quality opponent and any notion that the Irish will dominate them as they did UMass should immediately be dispelled. The Midshipmen have forced nine turnovers and committed only one, and commit very few penalties. In short, Notre Dame must work hard to beat them as they do not have any glaring weaknesses. The Irish certainly will provide a much tougher test than Navy has faced this season, but the Mids will not be intimidated given their recent history of competitiveness in this series.
Notre Dame’s offense must be ready to dictate tempo and strategy rather than take three quarters to wake up and make adjustments. Kelly must assume that teams have scouted the Irish by this point in the season and strive to break tendencies in play calling and personnel alignment. Defensively, they must defend the fullback dive and quarterback keeper, which account for 80% of Navy’s running plays. Forcing the Midshipmen wide will work to Notre Dame’s advantage if they can corral Sanders on the perimeter, but a lack of gap discipline and crisp tackling will put the outcome in jeopardy.
Here are a few questions that will shed light on the outcome:
Will Notre Dame be able to protect the football after a bad case of fumble-itis last week?
Can Prosise break off runs of 10-20 yards?
Will the Irish defense maintain discipline against the option as they did against Georgia Tech?
Can Notre Dame’s secondary avoid getting burned by trickery or the long play-action pass?
Will the Irish special teams contribute to the cause in a meaningful way?
Can the Notre Dame defense win the battle on first down?
PREDICTION
The Irish should be upset about last week’s defeat and can channel that anger into a strong and more focused effort from the opening kickoff on Saturday. On the other hand, the first loss of the 2014 season sent the team into a horrific tailspin, so it is very difficult to predict Notre Dame’s state of readiness for this week’s contest. One thing you can count on is that Navy will be absolutely ready to give a maximum effort and fight until the final whistle. The Irish have too much speed and talent on paper, but the game may be uncomfortably close well into the second half. Fortunately, the game time forecast calls for clear skies and mild temperatures.
NOTRE DAME 38 NAVY 28
Jake in California says:
If Notre Dame doesn’t show up early, the Mids will make us look foolish.. I don’t care about
the Georgia Tech game — this Navy team plays with absolute precision and they expect to win
this game.. Watch Coach Ken on the sidelines, he’s a masterful motivator…
Navy will be a hand full on Saturday.. As always, ND will keep Navy in the game until late in
the fourth quarter.. I do believe our talent will just get us by!
ND 31
Navy 30
Austinirish says:
I’ll be disappointed if it’s that close or if they score 28. No, I don’t expect UMass, but how about 40-17.
gspach says:
This game will be very telling…last year Navy dropped 39 on us. We all know how the rest of that season went – blunder after blunder, riddled with turnovers, and losses to teams that had no business beating us (Lville, NW)
I am expecting something more along the lines of what you proposed. 40-17 sounds about what it should be. Go Irish
Matt says:
On track, not untracked. Good article.
Mike Coffey says:
Actually, “untracked” is often used in that context. I agree “on track” makes more sense, but the usage is supposed to imply they’re getting off the bad track.
Matt says:
Doesn’t mean it’s right. We shouldn’t concede improper use of words or grammar — like taking a new tact vs taking a new tack. The fact that many people use the former doesn’t mean it is correct…
Yes, I’m a pedant.
Mike Coffey says:
That’s my point, it’s not improper. The usage means the subject is on the wrong track and needs to get off of that track — untracked. Getting something on track implies the thing is not on a track at all.
Tom says:
Sanders’s fumble let to a Clemson TD, not a field goal.
Jake from Ohio (not State Farm) says:
Turnovers and dropped passes are the key. Last week’s debacle doesn’t happen if the Irish execute in those two facets. The offensive line also should be looking to redeem themselves after an embarrassing run blocking effort against Clemson. I agree with Jake in Cali, Navy always plays us tough (unless we’re in Ireland) and it will be likely be a close game for a while. I think ND releases some frustration from the realization that they lost to a Clemson team that was not as good as we made them look.
ND 35 Navy 21
Steve says:
The majority of Navy’s victories are against bad to mediocre teams. They don’t play an SEC schedule or even an ACC schedule. Expect the Irish to show up. The talent level difference will be very noticeable. Case in point, Navy has left Duke off their schedule as the Blue Devils have been getting better and consistently beating Navy. Most of Navy’s success has come via their ability to cherry pick their schedule with weak opponents and play mediocre teams in Bowl games. I am not impressed. Oh, yes they did play Ohio State last year and were beaten soundly in the second half when OSU started to awaken from their temporary stupor.
gspach says:
also – one correction to the article. Sanders’ fumble on the kickoff led to a Clemson TD to make it 21-3. not a FG
Ghost of Joe Moore says:
Most forget we lost our starting QB and running back. 40-17 is wishful and foolish thinking. Much like USC – you can generally throw out the records when these two teams meet. ND should hope only for a win and to come out of this game healthy. The absolute lack of mental preparation exhibited by the Irish last week should underscore that point. GO Irish –
Boomer80 says:
40-17 is right. The “hold me I’m Irish” crowd can tremble over this one and give Navy points. This ain’t Death Valley.
ccb says:
ND: 42 Navy 38
Navy will be leading late 4th qtr. before ND pulls it out.
Too bad re the loss to Clemson. Otherwise, ND might go 12-0 w/ Stanford being only team which should
have realistic chance against our talent. I still don’t expect B. Kelly to ever make playoffs during his tenure here.
He’s a cut or 2 above mediocrity – wins enough to keep his job as long he wants it.
Chuckie says:
Notre Dame should not play Navy football.
JT says:
I expect Navy to have the blueprint from the Clemson game on how to stop the Irish offense.
8 defenders in the box with linebackers run blitzing the gaps to disrupt Irish blocking schemes. Pretty tough to run against that strategy. So don’t try.
From the outset. Spread Navy out, Have receivers, TEs and RBs run short crossing routes. Use superior speed to maximize yards after catch. Keep doing it until the LBs and safeties start backing up to try and take away the short passing game.
Then kill them with CJ in the running game.
Watch the LBs if they are attacking the line of scrimmage at the snap …. throw behind them.
On defense… play disciplined assignment football but play fast just like against Ga Tech. Make the QB uncomfortable. Disrupt….
Fitz says:
Irish by 11…38-27. We dominate but get lazy and give up some late scores. But I will just be happy with a W this week. Yes, an absence of injuries would be nice but not highly likely with those “cut blocks” and the head hunter type physicality they play with. The score could be closer but personally I’m hoping to avoid one of those heart stoppers of recent years. If the offense just executes and scores big there is no way Navy can keep up with us. That’s been the traditional way to beat Navy in recent decades. The chance to score 40+, 50+ is there. But I think the Mids run the option better than Georgia Tech. In fact I have no doubt they do. So that defense that almost saved our butts and kept us in last weeks game, need to show up again big time and make this game just a fun afternoon in the sunshine. Go Irish!
Fitz says:
PS- Great recent point from JT! Spread Navy out. Go uptempo. Let the pass produce some massive draw runs. Every receiver and TE and even RB should have multiple catches. Back to your roots Kelly!
irishhawk50 says:
I look forward to this game as a gauge of the character of this team. I see USC lost to Washington last night. The Irish must finish out strong with convincing wins if they hope to make the playoffs. They don’t really have too many top opponents left. No excuses! Go Irish!
Rob says:
Watching the video of the tackle and fumble clearly is an example of how not to tackle. Dropping your head and leading with the crown of your helmet will lead to head and neck injury. The Clemson player is lucky he did not severly injure himself. If Sanders had lowered his shoulder and took the blow to his head the Clemson player would have been ejected for targeting.
GOND88 says:
Probably Irish 42-31. I still expect ND to be lethargic as they always seem to be. ND needs to play smash mouth football and re-establish the running game and keep Navy’s offense off the field.
NDBonecrusher says:
Don’t see a meltdown like 2014 post-FSU. Boys will be focused and pissed off. ND win by a couple touches is not naive. Agree wholeheartedly with above–use pass to set up run and go uptempo. Air superiority is the key to victory. Avoid injuries, get Wimbush in there. Will not predict a score, but ND wins by 3 TDs.
Also for Vannie-it was a painfully short Bucktober. Again. Give ’em hell, Chicago Cubs!