C.J. Prosise ran for 129 yards and three touchdowns, while DeShone Kizer passed for 281 yards as Notre Dame handed Navy its first loss of the season by 41-24 on Saturday. The Midshipmen hung with the Irish throughout the first half, but a fumble on the second half kickoff led to a touchdown by Prosise and Notre Dame never looked back. Freshman Justin Yoon contributed two field goals and a perfect afternoon in the kicking department as Notre Dame moved to 5-1 on the season. The Irish defense tightened up after being gashed a few times before intermission by the Navy triple option.
The day started poorly for Notre Dame as a quick three and out by the offense was followed by a 51-yard romp by Keenan Reynolds on Navy’s first play. The Mids scored two plays later for a quick 7-0 lead. The Irish answered later in the quarter and appeared to take command in the second period when Jaylon Smith recovered a fumble at the Navy seven yard line. Prosise scored on the next play to make it 14-7. The situation continued to deteriorate for Navy when Reynolds was injured on the ensuing possession. Kizer then directed the Irish on an 84-yard march as Chris Brown caught a 29-yard pass and Kizer hit Will Fuller for a 30-yard touchdown after miraculously escaping pressure in the pocket.
Trailing 21-7, backup quarterback Tago Smith rallied the Midshipmen. His 22-yard run on a third down play set up a 45-yard scoring burst up the middle by reserve fullback Quentin Ezell to cut Notre Dame’s advantage to 21-14 with five minutes left in the half. Kizer then committed the lone Irish turnover of the day when he telegraphed a sideline pass that was intercepted by Brendon Clements in Notre Dame territory. Ezell again dashed off-tackle through the porous Irish defense for the tying score with only 24 seconds remaining.
While most viewers headed for the refrigerator, Kizer kept playing. His pass to Torii Hunter put Yoon in range for a 52-yard field goal attempt, and he drilled it as time ran out for a 24-21 halftime advantage. Prosise scored twice in the third quarter to extend the margin to 38-21, and Navy could manage to score on one of two field goal attempts in the second half despite Reynolds’ return to action. Yoon closed the scoring with a seconf three-pointer of his own, and the last ten minutes were void of drama. Elijah Shumate had a nice diving interception for Notre Dame just before the hosts ran out the clock.
Despite the early frustration on defense caused by blown assignments and missed tackles, the Irish recovered to play well in the second half and won the turnover battle by 3-1. Notre Dame dominated the statistics with 27 first downs to 16 for the Mids and 451 total yards to Navy’s 335, most of which were earned in the first half. Kizer was 22 of 30 for his 281 yards and one touchdown, while Reynolds and Smith were a combined three of six for 22 yards and an interception. Let’s review the pregame questions for additional insights.
Will Notre Dame be able to protect the football after a bad case of fumble-itis last week? Yes, as it was Navy which uncharacteristically gave up the football at very inopportune times.
Can Prosise break off runs of 10-20 yards? Definitely. Prosise smoked the Mids with a 22-yard scoring run and later dragged a group of tacklers into the end zone to complete an 11-yard touchdown rumble.
Will the Irish defense maintain discipline against the option as they did against Georgia Tech? Not at first, but the Notre Dame front seven took control in the second half.
Can Notre Dame’s secondary avoid getting burned by trickery or the long play-action pass? The Irish were solid on the back end, although Navy’s quarterbacks had little or no time to look downfield when they fell behind on the scoreboard.
Will the Irish special teams contribute to the cause in a meaningful way? Yoon’s clutch three pointer before halftime stopped Navy’s momentum, and his overall performance was a great sign for the team’s future.
Can the Notre Dame defense win the battle on first down? Navy gained more than five yards per attempt on first down on five of eight series to start the game, but finished only nine of 22 in this category by my count.
As Coach Brian Kelly stated before the game, the Irish have no margin for error going forward if they hope to have a playoff-worthy resume. Next week’s matchup with the disappointing but dangerous USC Trojans will be a severe test, and Notre Dame has plenty of motivation after being humiliated last season in the Coliseum. Fortunately, they appeared to escape the Midshipmen without losing additional players to serious injury, although linebacker Greer Martini did not return after being shaken up in the second half.
irishhawk50 says:
The game played out about as expected but the Irish were sloppy in the first half with a lot of missed and poor tackling. KIzer continues to impress but I was not happy with them keeping Prosise in the game late in the fourth quarter and up by three scores. Hopefully all the injuries were minor and ND will be at full strength for USC. Need a fast start to keep USC demoralized. Go Irish!
Brian says:
This offensive line just continues to go backwards. The amount of stupid penalties continue and being unable to control a 3 man Navy front that is outweighed by 50 pounds is ridiculous! Then our front 7 on D gets gashed for 318 yards rushing! Glad Navy doesn’t throw the ball or else ND would be looking at a loss today. Why BK and BVG cannot coach these guys up better for this game just stumps me. Kizer, Procise, and Fuller are the only reason ND wins this game. They made something out of a whole lot of nothing provided by the o-line. Glad CJ can run through tackles on the 1st level because there was nothing there for him to run through. If USC learns how to run the option by next we they will pound ND! Ridiculous how the ND o-line was pushed around today!
Aaron says:
Brian……I agree with you totally about this Offensive Line….right now they are our Achilles Heel. Mental errors is absolutely killing are Offense!!!!! You are suppose to improve as the season goes on….not Regress!!!!!!
Having said that bring on the Condoms!!!!!!
Mike says:
Lol
John Ross says:
Brian- ??? Didn’t CJ rush for over +120 yards and 3 TD’s? Yet, you claim the OL line was “pushed around”?
My beef was that ND didn’t run more, because they could have run for 2x if Kelly was really focused on the
running game.
Brian says:
As stated in the Good/Bad/Ugly write up – Interior running struggles. Notre Dame attacked the perimeter yesterday, with C.J. Prosise getting to the edges via the quick pass or outside handoffs. But the Irish seemed to struggle running north and south, disappointing against a defense like Navy’s.
Alex Bars started for the first time, as Quenton Nelson’s ankle wasn’t ready to be tested. Nick Martin will need to get healthy after a tweaked ankle. But against USC, the Irish will need to be able to move the point of attack, something they didn’t necessarily do consistently against the Midshipmen.
austinirish says:
I’ll let readers decide whether my 40-17 prediction is better than Vannie’s 38-28 against a result of 41-24. But in any event. thankfully 40-17 was NOT “wishful and foolish thinking.”
John Vannie says:
Don’t quit your day job.
Brian says:
You were both pretty close
NDBonecrusher says:
With all due respect-lighten up, Francis. 460 yards of offense and Kizer could have knit a sweater back there in the pocket. They did not abandon the run-they intentionally and successfully dominated with the pass.
Agree that Prosise and Kizer ought to have been rested at the end.
Bury USC.
flirish says:
a win is s win and the irish finally figured things out. With that said for all those people last week who thought Kelly was such a great coach–what about this week?? The signature Kelly slow start to games was evident again. The horrific and pathetic special teams play has to be the absolute worst in D I football. We can’t return a kick to the 25 on the vast majority of kick offs and we can’t cover a kick. ^ years into the tenure of this coach and special teams are as bad as ever. Against navy ok–but in big games this will cost us the game. what about the play calling again. never established the run game. we came out passing and ignored cJ and the run game for most of the first half. What is going on here. Give navy credit for their effort but really–is this team playing to its potential?? i put a lot of these issues on an underachieving coaching staff
ccb says:
I was at the game. Worrisome 1st half = which I predicted. But, final score a whole lot better than
I thought it would be (I said 42-38, Irish)
Again, though Irish flat for 1st 30 minutes on D.
Need to play a full 60 to beat a desperate USC team and a very desperate Sark who wants to keep his
job.
Irish 35, USC 31
Scott says:
Well, looks like Sark won’t have to worry about his job any longer.
Jphlips says:
Key to why opponents are so successful against our defense is why VanGorder teaches
To tackle the stomach and not the legs. If you tackle the opponent 3 downs, you don’t
Need to try to rip the ball out. You get it back on the punt. Play the basic fundamentals.
The good news is the VanGorder defense did not try to injure each other on kindergarten
High Fives. Go Irish.
Gene Steinke says:
Hey Mr. know it all, Kelly!
Try something different. Waiting to make adjustments at halftime instead of having your kids prepared BEFORE the game starts will give you a much better chance to win.
Start like this against USC and others and you will end the season at 9-3 or 8-4 (again).
These kids deserve to have their coaches work as hard as they do! Earn your money!
Thomas Gillen says:
Maybe the opposing coaches will send us their game plan do we can prepare in advance for them. Nd hasn’t won a championship in 27 years, this is the best shape the program has been in since and you folks think it should be flawless. Guess what, there isn’t a flawless program out there. We won the game, be happy and let the team grow and move on to next week.
Mike Coffey says:
But can it be in better shape?
Scott says:
If you think Alabama’s run of 3 National Championships in five seasons wasn’t something close to damn near flawless, you’re sorely mistaken. Personally, I like the direction of the program now as opposed to how far it had gone down after Lou left (namely during Ty Willingham’s lazy tenure). Could things be better than they are now? Yes, I think they could.
Fitz says:
A toast- may the Irish never lose to Navy in any of our lifetimes again! Cheers! Go Irish beat USC
Dan H. says:
Looked like a little bit of Clemson hangover – first half. But came on strong in the 2nd. Agree that the O-line is not the dominant force as projected – lots of individual talent, but not so much as a group.(what ever happened to synergy?) Hiestand must be losing a lot of sleep this season. IRISH need to take a lesson from Wash – against Southern Cal hit Kessler in the mouth whether he has the ball or not! GO IRISH!!
Tom says:
Geez, playing Navy is like getting a root canal. Glad that is over.
Tom D. says:
Plus side: we won, did not come down to a nail biter, no major injuries. Negative side: O line vastly overrated, defense falls asleep and gets gashed by big plays by anybody; even beating USC doesn’t help much with their shoddy performances; Trojans the same guys who clubbed us by 35 last fall (would have been worse had the USC coach not called off the dogs. Postscript: I think Kelly is a solid coach but not admitting it was wrong to go for two at 21-9 in the third quarter at Clemson is nothing more than stubbornness.
Jake in California says:
The O-line looked terrible at times.. Another slow start and Navy made us look foolish
as I predicted for two quarters.
Six years in and I still can’t believe Kelly can’t get his team to start strong!! It boggles the mind.
But I’m thrilled with the win and now I can relax because the option teams are behind us..lol
I think we will be ready against SC after last years debacle..
flirish says:
I hope we are ready for UsC and as a loyal fan i am always hopeful but for the statements that we are in better shape than we have been for years–that simply isn’t good enough. No one expects perfection but lets face it –there has been no improvement in poor special teams play for 6 years. this is 1/3 of the game. We leave this on the field every game. In big games this is a reason for a loss. Yes we are better off but come on—tons of room for improvement without unrealistic expectations in pass defense, offensive consistency and game plan.
Dick says:
Let’s face it. We are a second half team. Which means we are not out of any game. This is much better than the past teams under past coaches that ran out of gas in the second half.
Dick says:
Recruiting has been good over the past few years. The bench is so much stronger. As a result, injuries to key players have not killed us. For those that think BK should go, in my view, he is building for the long term and the program is going in the right direction.
NWIfan says:
That says as much about the state of the program as anything. Despite the injuries and departures, they are 12th nationally running the ball. 10th overall on offense. This despite backups in the backfield and Fuller is only true playmaker at WR.
Terry says:
I agree with a lot of people on the general ethos that this team demonstrates: 1) starts slowly, 2) offensive line could be more aggressive, and focused to reduce the penalties, 3) coaches seem to not be able to organize and motivate team enough, 4) more talent and depth across the board to handle mid-tier teams like Navy and Purdue, 5) offense too predictable, can’t keep opposing Ds on their toes enough with a run-pass and short and long passing mix, 6) defense lacking physicality and discipline to tackle well and read defenses and know assignments, 7) doesn’t step up against teams with superior talent.
Letting UMass and Navy hang around the entire first half is inexcusable for a team that wants to compete for a national championship. The team lacks the leadership and confidence that the coaching staff must instill. I think we have the speed and athleticism on both sides of the ball, but the strength and tenacity is lacking when you compare them to BAMA and FSU. I said that Golson would do better at FSU because he has a more physical team with a better running game and D; not that the ND backs lack speed but they will not run through or over people to get that 2 yards you need on a 3rd and 2, and the line is not a top 5 line that you need to win it all. I think the team keeps too many of the plays near the line of scrimmage and doesn’t go deep enough to stretch and open up defenses, but I don’t think BK trusts his QB enough. It’s a pity because Cincy’s redshirt freshman backup is doing really well and makes very difficult long passes. I think it goes back to instilling confidence in players.