Notre Dame overcame a sluggish first half and dominated after intermission in a 35-13 victory on Saturday. Despite Navy’s early success, the Irish nudged ahead by 14-13 just before halftime. The second half went according to script but the Irish paid a heavy price for the victory. Upon review of the takeaways from Notre Dame’s performance, serious injuries overshadowed the play on the field. Key defenders Drayk Bowen and Francis Brewu went down and did not return.
Despite the personnel losses, the Notre Dame defense rallied in the second half. Navy managed only one first down and no points over the final 30 minutes. Meanwhile, CJ Carr led the Irish to touchdowns on three straight series coming out of the locker room. His 31-yard scoring strike to Jerome Bettis to open the fourth quarter capped a 28-0 run. This touchdown proved to be the game’s final points. Notre Dame failed to add to its total despite two long drives later in the period.
A nightmare scenario developed following the opening kickoff. Quarterback Jackson Gutierrez engineered long scoring marches in each of Navy’s three first half possessions. Fortunately for the Irish, two of these drives ended in field goals. Still, a Gutierrez scoring run gave the Middies a 13-7 lead just two minutes before halftime. Navy had dominated time of possession by 23-5 minutes to that point. Notre Dame’s defense appeared confused and players were consistently out of position.
Momentum shifted back to the Irish in the ensuing series. Nolan James capped a 57-second drive to retake the lead with a 52-yard run to paydirt. Navy could not answer and the half ended.

Notre Dame assumed control by taking the kickoff and executing a textbook six-minute drive. Jonaz Walton’s short run made it 21-13, and the Irish defense followed with a three and out. Carr and Bettis put on an aerial show and James returned to add a 22-yard touchdown run. Nervous Irish fans finally took a breath.
The Midshipmen recorded their lone first down of the half before Notre Dame forced another punt. Carr found Bettis again on a hook and go route for an easy 31-yard score. Bettis did not play in the first half but led the team with six receptions for 78 yards. Carr finished with 19 completions on 29 attempts for 210 yards and two scores. James led the ground attack with 107 yards as the team rushed for 204.
Notre Dame’s defense was outplayed for 30 minutes but were aggressive and assignment solid over the final 30. Obviously, they cannot afford a slow start next week. Let’s review the answers to our pregame questions.
- Which team will be more successful on third or fourth down? Neither team was particularly effective Notre Dame was three of eight on third down while Navy was four of 12. Both teams were two of three on fourth down.
- Will Carr be poised and on target? CJ had a nice run of completions in the second half. He still appears uncomfortable when pressured and throws into tight coverage without setting his feet properly. A few throws were nearly intercepted.
- Can Notre Dame’s defense create turnovers and negative plays? There were no takeaways other than a turnover on downs in the third quarter.
- Will the patchwork Irish defense be gashed for explosive plays? EMTs were working overtime to stop the bleeding in the early going. Fortunately, the stitches held in the second half.
- Can the Irish special teams dominate the Midshipmen? These units had very little impact today. Notre Dame should have kicked a field goal midway through the final period. Instead, they failed on a low percentage fourth down pass.
- Which offense will be more efficient in the red zone? Navy scored points on each of its opportunities, all coming in the first half. Notre Dame was two of three. Its final drive of the game ended with the clock expiring.
- Can Jonaz Walton gain over 100 yards? Walton had 51 but at least he was utilized enough to break a sweat. James was the star of today’s game. He exhibited an effective combination of speed and elusiveness against the overmatched Midshipmen.
- Which Irish reserves will impress with strong performances? Bettis was terrific and End Rodney Dunham continues to impress on defense.
It was a costly victory in that Bowen broke his ankle. He is probably done for the season. Brewu was hurt in the first quarter and the early reports are not encouraging. Wide receiver Micah Gilbert also limped off the field, although Bettis took advantage of his sudden opportunity. Other unknowns for next week include injured defenders Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa and Brauntae Johnson.
Bright spots included trouble-free snaps from center and a balanced attack. The running game had more variety and crisper execution. Carr connected on throws over the middle and there were no exasperating fade passes. As noted previously, however, a few of Carr’s throws were nearly intercepted. Most questions regarding this team’s resilience were answered satisfactorily.
On the bad side, a three and out series in the first half consisted of three incomplete passes. This gave the Denbrock haters an acute case of apoplexy. One obvious corollary on defense was the apparent lack of preparedness that took too long to correct. The anti-Ash contingent nearly broke the Internet during this stretch. None of this amounts to a hill of beans in the total scheme of things.
What does matter are the injuries that occurred today. They will impact next week’s showdown against the Miami Hurricanes. Bowen’s loss is significant and Brewu has been the team’s best defensive tackle. These losses and the status of other walking wounded is the team’s greatest concern. As a result, there is plenty of doubt for the Irish faithful to wrestle with this week. That wasn’t the plan but it is where we are right now.
PJ says:
Debt payed. Be done with this series, no good comes out of it, just injuries.
Jake in Cali says:
JVAN,
This series of games against Navy must stop immediately! Play them once a decade. Period!
We gain nothing from this..
Note Dame embarrassed themselves today.
Shameful first half performance by Chris Ash and his confused defense..Unacceptable .
I think MF comments at halftime said it all.
The 40 million + roster was a joke today.
We got dominated today..I don’t care what the scoreboard said.
The bye week did nothing for us creatively.
Disappointed in Cali.
LetsGoND says:
Ash needs to be let go.
I’m finally starting to think Denbrock was carried by Love, Price, and Leonard. (But it is more complicated than that; Carr is proving to be quite limited. Player development on offense is bottle-necked somewhere. If Denbrock has good developed players on hand– he does okay.)
The position coaches might be suspect as well– the receivers coach is claiming players need to prove they can be “trusted”. Sounds scared to me. Using fear as replacement of skill as a coach.
Not good.
Jim Keenan says:
Navy kept ND afloat financially when the student body was off to WWII – about 12,000 naval officers were trained at ND. ND had approached Army with a similar proposition but was turned down. If not for Navy there very well might not be an ND today. Father Hesburgh told Navy that as thanks for their help ND would play Navy every year. It’s a debt of honor and this 1973 ND grad is proud of my school.
Nick Morgan says:
100% ND has nothing to gain by playing Navy. I respect those Academy guys so much, but the cut blocks happen every year and someone always gets hurt. I agree, debt has been paid, time to end it. Go Navy beat the crap out of our enemies, not our 3 starters on Defense. I’m 43 years old and have seen Navy V ND many times in person, I’m just tired of this diving at our dudes ankles and knees, and I get it they don’t have the size, they are doing what they have to, trying to keep it competitive. Over it!!!!
Bryan P Ward says:
Yes every time. Crackback university! Stop the series.Now Notre Dame!
irishhawk50 says:
The fact that the Irish defense was not prepared for Navy raises serious questions about Ash. They had two weeks to prepare for this offense. The second half was better but it should not have gotten that far. The superior talent of Notre Dame made the difference, not the coaching.
The game against Miami is crucial as both SMU and Wisconsin lost today. Strength of schedule took another hit. A loss to Miami at home may cost the Irish a playoff spot.
gmac says:
What makes you think Ash spent the last two weeks preparing for this game? He spent enough time to contain them in the first half and leaven them broken after his half-time adjusttments.
He was, we all hope, spending time on an offense that is not well below ND in talent, not consistent and predictable in its play calling. He did enough work to get the job done (nicely) yesterday. He may even have enough players left to handle Miami.
irishhawk50 says:
Half time adjustments to a team with maybe 3 or 4 different plays and 2 wins? Seriously?
ND fan in the South says:
I have to agree that Ash was looking ahead to Miami that runs a balanced attack with an emphasis on passing all over the field, unlike Navy. Our defense is more designed to pressure the passing QB and defend against wide out receivers. Why spend a lot of time and resources on a Navy team we are bound to dominate? Let’s see how our defense, with 5 starters out, defends against the Hurricanes.
gmac says:
You seriously think Ash spent the last too weeks “preparing for Navy?”
I suspect he was more focused on a team in Florida that has talent on par with what he has to work with (or what’s left of it) and runs plays that are dynamic and creative–not on a team with a consistent offensive approach that puts the ball in the air less than 10x/game and averages less than 17yds/half when it risks such madness.
After looking at the worst of what they capable, he took away what little success they had (yes, I know, 13 points–but it FELT much, much worse) and obliterated their offense in the second half, consistently giving Carr & Co. possessions to work with.
If you MUST scream for his head, please wait for a week to do so.
Irishwest says:
Your points about the Ash haters was spot on. His trend of making halftime adjustments continued. Now to find the healthy bodies for Miami.
One Historian says:
I wasn’t able to see the game but from what JV says I get the distinct impression that we are hurting coming into next weekend. Miami will probably be favored, given the numerous injuries we have, which makes sense, not to mention the fact that Miami is currently ranked #1.
Right now – We STILL don’t know how good this team is, we STILL don’t know how deep the bench is.
I repeat – we STILL don’t know how good THIS team is.
Has the time come for a game for the ages?
Wish I could be there.
joe barrett says:
Thank God ND turned it around in the 2nd half!! Just happy they won the game and now they can focus on Miami!! John, do you think that Walton should start the game or better coming off the bench? Go Irish beat Hurricanes!!!!!!!
John Vannie says:
I’m okay with the RB rotation today with James starting and Walton getting a good share of the work as the primary backup. Williams came in when the game was already decided.
Will says:
This game went pretty much as I expected. I predicted 33-17 on the assumption that ND would come out flat and that Navy would make it a dog fight. I actually feel pretty good about this game. Last week Navy gained 550 yards; this week they only gained 246, and they were totally shut down in the second half. The Irish offense was efficient. There were no sacks and no turnovers. I think Freeman is very happy to get this game over with. The option offense is a nuisance to deal with in the middle of the season before a big game. I also think he has this team exactly where he wants it. The Miami game will be the biggest home game for ND since the 1988 Miami game. I can’t wait!
The Obvious says:
It was the Fighting Zombies in the 1st Half of this Halloween game. Nice job! No damn excuses for next week. None. Win the damn game.
Mark says:
Am i remembering correctly that one of Al Golden’s strengths was his ability to make D adjustments on the fly rather than waiting until halftime, which seems to be Ash’s MO? That’s a very dangerous way to live, especially against strong offensive opponents (eg Miami).
LetsGoND says:
Exactly– I don’t see Ash as being sustainable. We are slowly degrading on the defensive side. Poor game-day preparation; poor game-day adaptations.
ccb says:
Hopefully, history isn;t repeating itself. We are 2 seasons removed from ND appearing in the NC game and losing. in 2012 we lost the NC under BK. After 2012, ND began a downhill slide.
In 2013, we suffered a pivotal loss the 1st week in November to FSU.
In 2014, 2 years after the Alabama beatdown, I was in Arizona for ND vs ASU the 1st week in Novembe with an ND team w/ only 1 loss. ASU Blew out the Iristh in what was the start of a 4 game losing streak.
If MF wants to avoid the same fate as BK, ND better win next week.
A blowout loss to Miami, could trigger another slide. This team has knocked down many tomato cans since the 1 point loss to Tex A & M.
We’ll find out if BYU was simply an outlier. Is ND for real or was 2024 a one hit wonder like 2012?
Jerrod says:
FSU loss was 2014. Also the 2012 team was much more “smoke and mirrors” than the 2024 squad.
Theoodore Kazmar says:
ND is an early 3.5 to 6.5 favorite. If you can, take a loan out on your house and put the money on Miami, you will become rich.
Kevin Welsh says:
It’s 4.5 and I will give those points all week
❤️#501988☘️🏈💪🏻 says:
VERY ALARMING ALL AROUND TO SAY THE LEAST!
HONESTLY MARCUS HAS LOST CONTROL OF THIS TEAM, HIS COACHES, AND THE CONFIDENCE OF THE FOLLOWING!
IF YOU BELIEVE OTHERWISE YOU ARE A FOOL!!!!
84david says:
Lil nit Vannie:
Your writeup says Navy scored TDs on all three
red zone trips. Not possible with 13 pts. One TD,
2 FG, on 3 red zone trips is correct.
John Vannie says:
Thanks. I meant to say points but I was probably thinking ahead to Miami.
bocceman2 says:
Wish we had Minchy. College football today requires a mobile QB. CJ an’t it. In fact, you’re seeing it more in pro football that a mobile QB is becoming more and more common. Our offense is boring and offensive.
Mike says:
Original, daring analysis of the post-Johnny Unitas NFL. Carr won’t make it there, and he should be kicked out of the Irish game plan right now to let his replacement run wild against Miami.
ND fan in the South says:
You cannot be serious. Miami’s pass defense by it’s secondary is ranked 87th nationally. CJ’s pass efficiency is ranked top 5. This may be Miami’s only weakness, and it was exposed against North Carolina in a big way, and against Wake Forest as well. CJ will eat up their secondary….And you will have a chance to humble yourself in next week’s Vannie column.
LetsGoND says:
Well… I hope you’re right. But DC Ash, and Carr are not showing up in big games.
Mike says:
The reference to Johnny Unitas . . . the aggressive suggestion about kicking Carr off the team
. . . cannot be serious. In fact, IMO Carr is the best NFL prospect of quarterbacks going in the 2027 draft. But I hope he isn’t the first picked, and goes later somewhere good (hello L A Rams).
Atlantadomer says:
Watched a lot of the Miami Carolina game.
Bobby Petrino now has given both teams the blueprints for exploiting the opposing defense. Let’s see which coordinator will pay attention. ND TEs need to get involved more.
Marty says:
Finally, Premer and Larsen get valuable playing time. Carr will need the tight end target next week. Can’t for the life of me understand why we don’t attack on defense until the 2nd half. Frustrating. My other observation was the uncharacteristic undisciplined play of Navy. There should have been more than one personal fould called (I.e. the push from behind of James on his td run in the end zone for one) Lost respect for Navy over those incidents.
Ndvette says:
I watched us play Navy last year and I thought the reaction to the ball was the best since Holtz. Fast, Decisive, Violent and effective. Yesterday, was pitiful, I can only believe that with a 2-5 record Ash assumed a win and concentrated on Miami. That lack of forethought might have contributed to the injuries. The hardest thing to wrap my head around was I was a believer. I honestly thought we had a top 3 offence and top 3 defense at worst what the hell happened. Regardless of the quality of the opponent our team looked the part, capable of beating any team in the top 25. J.V. if you can even partly explain what happened to the dynamics of this team please tell me. We went from a likely Heisman winner QB, an elite defense and improving offence with a wealth of talent at RBs, receivers and then poof. Now I’m looking at the players faces showing confusion and frustration. faces, tell me this is an aberration that will disappear when we face Miami. Any team can fall behind expectations, look at Ohio and Indiana, BYU and Miami this week. But two in a row!! In your opinion is there any hope we can be a team that “Leaves No Doubt”? Thanks for the breakdown.
John Vannie says:
Aside from the injuries, the biggest reckoning for me has been the lack of pash rush when ND plays a good team. Ash was able to rush four and get pressure against the early schedule. When he elected to blitz, there was little risk that the opponent would hurt them with big plays. The opposite is true when we play teams with better athletes and quarterbacks who can run. It started at North Carolina.
Guys like Traore and Young are no longer winning in pash rush. Ash is reluctant to blitz and get burned. This has exposed the linebackers and secondary, particularly in zone coverage.
As for the offense, opponents have now studied several weeks of film. Our tendencies and Denbrock’s schemes are on full display. ND telegraphs a lot of plays just by the formation. DC’s have seen Carr’s checks at the line and can predict where the ball is going. Denbrock has not fully adjusted although he did show a few good things against Navy. Will they translate to Miami? We will see, but more and better creativity is needed.
David Reuter "73 says:
Thank you for all of your write ups And this excellent response to a question.
IrishKMAC says:
I’m not sure i’ve seen it mentioned, but does anyone else notice that CJ stares down his receuver?
Ndvette says:
IrishKMAC, I have mentioned it at least 4 times on these boards, likening his stare downs to Archie Manning. Both QB’s have a tendency to stare down their receivers, and I believe it has not only caused and will lead to additional interceptions but just as important, it telegraphs his intentions and any defender worth his salt is already on his way to knock the ball down. Miami has had 16 interceptions over 16 games. If we don’t use misdirection, authentic looking play action pass and he stairs down the receiver we lose big. My only hope for him is there are instances where great QBs suffered from that problem, Peyton Manning, he said he fixed it with film study, Josh Allen at Wyoming, all the scouting reports noted he locked on his first target until he learned to manipulate safety’s and work through progressions, Jalen Hurts, was very hesitant to come off his first look and while slow to correct it he has improved. But can Carr do it in a week? I doubt it.
Allan Horney says:
Under…for what its worth:
Both ND and Miami have played UNC in North Carolina. UNC had 407 total yds last night against Miami. 341 passing; 8-11 on 3rd down; 27 first downs. .Against ND, UNC has 285 total offense(compared to 407); 208 passing; 5-10 on 3rd down; and 16 first downs (27 last night).
Probably means nothing, but it’s pretty clear that Miami tends to give up plenty of points. They also GET plenty of points.
ND must play serious defense. If so, they can win. They also must play the whole game. No down time.
I reject any suggestion that CJ Carr is a top tier guy. He;s good, but he is also far too inconsistent. .
Jake in Cali says:
Allen, I agree with your thoughts on Carr. Also, I think he needs to come back next year and work on his inconsistencies..
I don’t think he’s NFL ready yet…He’ll get crushed on a bad team..
Drasail2 says:
JV
Nice write up. To be contrarian which coach/team swap-out would we rather be right now? Utah, Chesney? Holz (with Powlus) lost to BYU.
MF needs to get this squad AMPed for Sat…like in the reveal video when the team learned MF was Kelly’s replacement. The Canes are COMING.
Everything I have seen this season is promising, I think they know their strengths internally. But the plan has to be energy.
Go Irish!
Real Irish Fan #55 says:
Finally an Irish Fan not badmouthing our team!
Thank you Drasail2!!
When we curb stomp the canes, these Bandwagoners will be back singing the praises of this team.
Just watch!
Kevin J says:
I keep hearing from a very select few that the “majority” of ND fans want to keep the Navy series. Yet, on several ND threads, the thought is 10 to 1 against keeping it. These select few also say it would be a dishonor. I’m sorry, but after nearly 100 years ND has lived up to her honor. ND should honor Navy when it seems every year 1-3 players go down for the season? Maybe some young man loses the opportunity of a lifetime because of Navy’s dirty play? Sorry, time to put this series to rest. None of the other 100 universities that benefited from Navy’s use back in the 40’s has Navy on their schedule.
Vernon J says:
Right. To Hell with Navy.
Until Saturday, I was OK with the annual meeting.
Navy’s multiple cheap shots Saturday changed that.
If an ND player had shoved a Navy player to the ground from behind 3 yards deep in the end zone after TD run, not only would a penalty have been called, they would have reviewed it for targeting as well.
Muck the Fidshipmen.
Daniel K. says:
Why didn’t they attempt that field goal midway through? The defense rallied impressively after the losses of Bowen and Brewu to keep Navy scoreless in the second half despite no turnovers earlier in the game leaving fans to question the overall strategy moving forward.