Navyβs Head Coach Brian Newberry is 28-17 in his fourth season in Annapolis. Newberry lost several veterans from his successful teams of the past two years. Navyβs losing record this season indicates a rebuilding effort is in progress. The Midshipmen have returning lettermen along both lines but the skill positions have many new faces. Navyβs high precision offense has struggled to find a rhythm on offense so far this season. They have fumbled the ball 15 times and recovered eight.
Notre Dame Head Coach Marcus Freeman has a different set of problems. His highly talented and experienced team was chronically one step behind BYU in its last outing. The Irish played poorly on both sides of the ball and left Utah with their confidence shaken.
Injuries continue to plague Notre Dame. Star linebacker Kyngstonn Viliamu-Asa is dealing with a thumb injury that flared up against BYU. He will miss Saturdayβs contest. Cornerback DJ McKinney remains out until sometime in December, assuming Notre Dame is still playing then. Fellow corner Mark Zachary will sit as he recovers from a concussion.
Safety Brauntae Johnsonβs broken foot has been slow to heal. There is no established target date for his return. Defensive lineman Loghan Thomas has a shoulder injury and will not play this week. Finally, tight end Cooper Flanaganβs hamstring strain will sideline him this week as well.
Navy has reported no injuries to its starters.
NOTRE DAMEβS OFFENSE vs. NAVYβS DEFENSE
Navy has not yet played a Power Four team. Their defense has surrendered 29 points per game despite impressive statistics against the run. The down linemen in Navyβs 3-4 alignment, Griffen Willis and Xavyer Arrington, are tough if somewhat undersized. Lack of a consistent pass rush was a weakness early in the season. More recently, end Aiden Lyczek and outside linebacker Nolan McCamy have shown improvement.
Interior linebackers MarcAnthony Parker and Coleman Cauley are impressive athletes. Parker is a physical player and an effective blitzer. Cauley leads the Midshipmen in tackles. They are primarily responsible for Navyβs strong rush defense. Still, it is doubtful that this front seven can hold up against the Irish ground attack. Coach Marcus Freeman did not take anything for granted when assessing the Navy defense, though. βDefensively, they’re as aggressive and exotic as we’ll see”, he said. “They do a heck of a job stopping the run. We gotta make sure we have a good plan to protect our quarterback and try to attack some things that we see on film. And so it’d be a great opportunity to get back on the field and face another opponent.β
In the secondary, safety Giuseppe Sessi is strong against the run and a sure tackler. Senior Ira Onija is the teamβs best cover corner. This group has been porous overall, however, due to the combination of poor pressure and coverage breakdowns. Notre Dame fans can expect an efficient performance from CJ Carr when the Irish elect to pass.
Notre Dameβs offense is more likely to be stopped by its own mistakes than by Navyβs defense. The Irish can score nearly at will if they are motivated and play a clean game. Navy has forced only four turnovers in seven games. The talent disparity is too great for them to hold the Irish much below 50 points. The final point total will depend on how long Coach Freeman leaves his starters in the game.
NAVYβS OFFENSE vs. NOTRE DAMEβS DEFENSE
Navyβs offensive line returned virtually intact this season. As one might expect, this unit blocks well for the run but is porous when protecting the passer. This is likely a function of practice time dedicated to this element of the attack. When successful, the Midshipmen throw the ball fewer than ten times per game. Center Cam Nichols and right tackle Malcolm Johnson are the unitβs best overall performers.

Jackson Gutierrez is the primary quarterback in their option attack. He is the leading rusher by a wide margin and a 50% passer. Navy also utilizes backup quarterback Braxton Woodson in a variety of situations. At times, both he and Gutierrez are on the field together. Woodson started last seasonβs game against the Irish when the legendary Blake Horvath was injured.
A shifty pair of slot backs adds a speed dimension to the option offense. Charles Robinson and Michael Barrow are dangerous outside runners and are the teamβs leading pass receivers. Notre Dame must account for them on every play. Surprisingly, the fullback does not play a large role in Newberryβs version of the option. Vic Listorti has averaged only six carries per game. He is used primarily as a blocker and in short yardage situations.
The Middies have multiple options at wide receiver and tight end. Wideouts Luke Hutchinson and Truman Brasfield are legitimate deep threats. Tight ends Jake Norris and Jordan Collins can also catch balls downfield. It will be interesting to see how aggressive the Irish are on third down. Sacks have been a major issue for Navy. I will be watching Boubacar Traore to see how he responds after being ejected at BYU. Traore is also a Massachusetts native and grew up in the greater Boston area.

SPECIAL TEAMS
Notre Dame has a clear advantage in this department as Navy is well below average. The Irish coaches can be aggressive here in going after punts and setting up returns. Kicking and punting has been stable for Notre Dame in recent games, while the Middies have struggled.
Navy kicker Nolan Bartley is a freshman. He has converted four of seven field goal attempts with a long of 34 yards. Punter Jacob Carlson averages 43 yards but several of his punts have resulted in long returns.
SUMMARY
Navy has improved in recent weeks, particularly on offense. They can score points against Notre Dame if its defense is not prepared and motivated. Several Irish reserves will assume more significant roles in this game and will be tested. Fumbles have been an ongoing issue for the Midshipmen. Obviously, they must avoid mistakes if they are to be competitive in this contest.
Notre Dame wants to secure the victory and get its key players off the field quickly. The offense should meet little resistance. On the other hand, Navyβs option attack may pose problems for the battered Irish defense. Expect the Middies to throw the kitchen sink at Notre Dame with trick plays and misdirection.
Here are a few questions that will shed light on the outcome:
- Which team will be more successful on third or fourth down?
- Will Carr be poised and on target?
- Can Notre Dameβs defense create turnovers and negative plays?
- Will the patchwork Irish defense be gashed for explosive plays?
- Can the Irish special teams dominate the Midshipmen?
- Which offense will be more efficient in the red zone?
- Can Jonaz Walton gain over 100 yards?
- Which Irish reserves will impress with strong performances?
PREDICTION
Notre Dameβs primary objective for playing this game is to improve its execution on offense. There is little benefit to the defense since the option based attack is dissimilar to other opponents. Even though Navy will not help them prepare for Miami, the Irish do not want to be embarrassed. From the playersβ perspective, Saturday represents an opportunity for those who do not play often to showcase their skills. I doubt the Irish coaches will reveal any new or creative schemes given the talent disparity.
NOTRE DAME 45 NAVY 13
Tell John what you think in the comments below
John Amberg says:
I’m going with 55-10 Irish. ND will take out its BYU frustrations on Navy.
Ndvette says:
I agree with you that we will probably not see any new wrinkles in our offence but why the hell not? It seems like a perfect opportunity to introduce some new and or exotic plays even if we don’t plan on using them in any other game. Give our opponents something to worry about. I’m sure with the athletic differential we can afford to waste a few. I have been breaking down every offence play we have had and it is worse looking at it in a spreadsheet. Talk about vanilla, in the Wisconsin game we had 66 offence plays and Carr was in Shotgun on 65 of them. One under center play. We ran with 1 back on 63 plays and 0 backs on 1. A tight end that blocks well is a valuable player but how about we try passing to them a little more. I love Navy, their heart and spirit but always fear injuries from chop-blocks. With their woes, and our embarrassment at losing to a spunky UCF team I fully expect a blowout even with backups. 56-10
John Vannie says:
Just a quick clarification. Chop blocks are illegal. Navy is known for using cut blocks, which are legal and slightly less dangerous. Your overall point stands.
Will says:
NDVette, there is a theory in offensive football that consistency and repetition creates perfection. You have to admit that ND’s lack of turnovers (only 2 in 7 games) may be one of the results from playing a consistent and methodical offense. I’m old enough to remember the Vince Lombardi Packers, a team that ran maybe 5 or 6 different plays consistently. No one could stop them. I think that is Denbrock’s and Freeman’s approach, and from watching the latest ND press conferences I don’t see that changing for the rest of the season. They basically give Carr 2 or 3 different plays to run on any given down and then they give him the freedom to call the play that he thinks will work based on the defensive formation. Denbrock’s approach is to get a favorable match-up. He’s not interested in outsmarting the other team with misdirection and razzle dazzle. This approach works best when you have an elite defense. When you cut down on offensive mistakes and turnovers and do not give the defense a short field to defend, you can pretty much assume the other team is not going to score a lot of points.
John Vannie says:
All true, but Denbrockβs offense doesnβt work as well when the other team has good players and there are no mismatches to exploit. Thatβs where his lack of creativity bites all of us in the ass.
Will says:
John, I totally agree. You are correct that against elite players instead of a mismatch you’re going to end up with a fifty/fifty play at best. But there’s another problem: teams are learning that they can bait, deceive, and rattle Carr before the snap and lure him into a play that won’t work. Carr has all the tools to be an elite quarterback, but you can’t expect him to be a dual threat quarterback/offensive coordinator on every down. Freeman is putting too much on his shoulders. By the way, I basically agree with your preview. Navy’s offense lately has been productive and even explosive at times. Will Ash be caught with his pants down again? You are also correct that the Navy defense is porous. However, their banzai swarming approach can at times be confusing for a qb. Remember the 2022 game in Baltimore when Navy dominated the second half and only lost the game by a 35 to 32 score? Tommy Rees, the OC, was completely confused by the banzai approach and ND ended up with about 50 net yards in the second half. So…I’m one of the few people who believe this game has value for the Irish. Navy will show Carr some exotic looks. Let’s see how he reacts. I also feel ND will come out flat for about 7 different reasons and that Navy will come out sky. high. A dog fight might be the result with ND winning 33 to 17. For some reason I can’t get 2022 out of my mind. Sincerely hope I’m wrong.
mike '73 says:
Yep, and one of these days we’ll actually compete one of those plays that nobody else in all of FB uses, the highly esteemed, and even once in a great blue moon completed, deep sideline fade route, run by a 5′ nothing WR against a 6′ plus DB!! Yep, just keep running those until we complete one, and then we’ll be on the verge of the highly sought NC!!! Good ol’ Mike Denbrock, where oh where would we be without that offensive CFB genius?!!
Almost forgot: one additional question – will Jonaz Walton actually carry the ball on a running play tomorrow nite? Again this season??
Jake in Cali says:
Will,
Denbrock got away with that approach at LSU because he had Malik Nabors, Brian Thomas, Jr and Kyren Lacy….not to mention Mason Thomas and a Heisman winner at QB..
He got lucky with all of that talent and they bailed him out of his poor play calling!!
Will says:
Jake, why do you always blame Denbrock? Freeman hired him and Freeman has given him free rein. Freeman has said over and over again that he does not want ND to beat ND. This means he wants an offensive system that is methodical and consistent in order to cut down on mistakes and turnovers. Freeman has also said that he likes having an offensive coordinator (Carr) on the field. This is, therefore, a Carr centric offense, which is another reason why they want a methodical system that puts a premium on protecting the quarterback. That aspect of the offense has also been effective as ND has only given up 1 sack in 7 games. Jake, that’s Freeman’s thinking…I’m not defending it; I just trying to understand it.
Jake in Cali says:
Will, fair question..
You can have a system that protects Carr, and yet, not have it be so vanilla and stale.
At the end of the day, Denbrock is a highly paid OC– and the development of Carr ultimately rests on his shoulders, and not Freeman..
Also, Denbrock has totally mismanaged the run game. I think we as a board, all agree on that!
Denbrock also favors his scheme instead of the personell he has at his disposal…Total mismanagement of uthe WR room… Bad X&O’s…
I’m sorry but ALL of this falls on his watch.
Stagnant play calling!
Predictable schemes
Red zone problems!
I could go on all night..
Busta Hurricane says:
The 3 week prep for Miami is in week 2. ND 56 Navy 14.
β€οΈ#501988βοΈππͺπ» says:
THANK YOU NAVY!
FOREVER GRATEFUL!
βπΊπΈπ¦ π½ππͺπ»