Irish Smother Punchless BC

Notre Dame blitzed Boston College with 21 points in the first quarter and coasted to a 31-13 victory on Saturday night. The Irish defense stonewalled BC’s anemic rushing attack and forced its two inexperienced quarterbacks to the air. The results were predictable, and Notre Dame was able to add points whenever it appeared the hosts might regain momentum.

Armando Allen’s 30-yard burst on the opening possession set up an option keeper by Dayne Crist for the first score less than two minutes into the contest. Eagle quarterback Chase Rettig struggled to move his team early in the game, and the Irish passed their way into scoring territory minutes later. Crist capped a 59-yard drive by hitting Kyle Rudolph for two yards and a 14-0 lead.

Boston College continued to go three and out as linebacker Carlo Calabrese stuffed running back Montel Harris and his teammates defended the short, tentative passes thrown by Rettig. Meanwhile, Crist found Michael Floyd twice to bring the Irish into the red zone, and later hit a wide open Theo Riddick for a 20-yard score for a 21-0 lead at the 2:19 mark.

On the verge of a suffering a rout in its own stadium, the Eagle defense tightened up and Rettig became a bit more comfortable in the pocket.  A perfectly executed stop and go route by Bobby Swigert fooled cornerback Gary Gray, and Rettig hit him in stride for a 58-yard touchdown pass to make it 21-7 at the end of the first quarter.

The tide seemed to turn for Boston College as Notre Dame fumbled on two of its next three possessions. Rettig led the Eagles to a field goal after the first fumble near midfield, but he suffered a leg injury on a scramble and left the game. His replacement, Mike Marscovetra, could not capitalize on the second fumble deep in Irish territory, but Nate Freese converted another field goal to make it 21-13 with 6:26 left in the half.

Notre Dame fought back on the strength of a Bennett Jackson kick return that was capped by a personal foul on BC. Starting the ensuing drive in Eagle territory, Allen took a shovel pass 24 yards before the drive stalled in the red zone. David Ruffer continued his perfect field goal kicking with a 25-yarder and the Irish moved ahead by 24-13 at intermission.

Marscovetra struggled to mount a threat in the second half as his receivers dropped passes or simply could not get open. Harris could not provide relief through the running game, and the Irish defense sat back and forced punt after punt. Midway through the third period, Notre Dame’s offense put together the only solid drive by either team in the second half. The Irish mixed a series of short passes and productive runs to drive 76 yards for the clinching score, a two-yard burst by Allen with just under 20 minutes left in the game.

Neither team accomplished much after it became obvious that the outcome was decided. Robert Blanton and Harrison Smith recorded fourth quarter interceptions for Notre Dame as Marscovetra filled the air with often errant passes, and the Irish cleared the bench. Freshman linebacker Prince Shembo delivered two sacks for Notre Dame and sophomore tackle Tyler Stockton contributed one.

The offensive performance by Notre Dame was not artistic by any means, and BC’s defense did adjust after the first period blitzkrieg to slow down the Irish attack. The injury to Rettig effectively ended any hope the Eagles had of making a game of it. Still, Notre Dame threw 45 passes and ran only 30 times, which is difficult to understand for a team that burst ahead by three touchdowns in the first 13 minutes. The Irish gained only 128 net yards rushing, but the inept Eagles managed only five.

Let’s review the questions that largely determined the outcome:

Will the Eagle defensive line win the battle up front and force the Irish away from the running game? No. Although Notre Dame did not run a lot, Allen was effective with 90 yards on 19 carries and the offensive line held its own.

Can the Irish force Rettig to make mistakes and play like a freshman? Yes, but he was plagued by a set of slow receivers with bad hands, and had to leave the game just as it appeared he might get untracked. Marscovetra was unable to generate any productive drives.

Will Notre Dame show improvement on special teams, particularly in the return game? Yes. Bennett Jackson contributed a couple of impressive kickoff returns that led to 10 Irish points.

Can the Irish cornerbacks effectively cover BC’s tall receivers? Yes. Even when it appeared they were open, the BC receivers could not hang onto the ball.

Which team will be more efficient on third down and in the red zone? Notre Dame scored four of five touchdowns once it reached the Eagle 20. BC’s only excursion into this territory followed a fumble recovery, and they settled for a field goal.

Will Crist be allowed to run the ball? He ran the ball in untouched for Notre Dame’s first score, and that was enough to establish the threat for the rest of the game.

Can the Irish get past the “almost” stage and put together a complete, winning performance? This one was almost painful to watch after the first quarter, but the Eagles’ offensive ineptitude prevented any excitement from creeping back into the telecast.

The Irish will return home against Pitt while hoping to even their record at 3-3 and continue to improve. October’s schedule appears to be winnable, and anything short of a 6-3 record by Halloween will be viewed as a disappointment. While the offense misfires at times and sends Brian Kelly into short bursts of Irish rage, the defense made strides this week and will search to develop additional depth as the season’s wear and tear becomes a factor. Overall, however, a team that was starved for a win can finally look forward with renewed hope for this season and beyond.

Categories

52 thoughts on “Irish Smother Punchless BC

  1. Yes, there is hope. But, it WAS painful to watch, after the first quarter. And the ESPN coverage made it more painful. My take: nice to win, but . . . this still isn’t Notre Dame football. Even the Fight Song sounds hollow to me. All that aside, Brian Kelly’s sweatshirt was my favorite, so far this season. He will sell more ND apparel than Charlie. Can’t wait for his Pitt outfit!

    • PJ (Michigan) says:

      Maybe you didn’t like the ESPN coverage, but I liked McDonough & Millen a helluva lot more than Hammond and Mayock. It was a great relief not to listen to the clowns from NBC.

  2. Mps stop your whining. We went on the road and totally crushed a rival team that hates us and has beat us 6 of the last 7 times. That’s not painful to watch. Another last moment loss would’ve been all too painful to watch. The offense had their moments and the D played great. Stuff it Kirk Herbstreet! Someone should tell him how slow Ohio State’s D looked out there against unranked scrubs Illinois, nowhere near the talent level of Stanford o the other top 25 teams we’ve played.

  3. I am convinced that our real problem is a lack of consistency in execution on offense. Our run blocking is not consistent enough to run the ball 50% of the time w/out running a true zone-read at least 10 times a game. Our QB does not make quick, correct reads often enough in our passing game. The only consistent aspect of the offense is Armando Allen playing with intensity and passion on every single play. He gets every inch he can on every play. If every offensive player played like that on every play, we would be getting somewhere. I don’t see this fixing itself completely over the course of the season. I’ll take the win and realize that there are going to be a lot of games this season that will look (and feel) like this one. We are going to click and put up points quickly and then bog down for whole sections of the game. This won’t change until more players play with the intensity, passion, and consistency of Armando Allen.

  4. db (los angeles) says:

    Good point about Herbie… It is hard to say this but I hope DR carves up his beloved OSU for 600 yards!

  5. A win is a win, but it was a bit painful. The announcers sucked last night, the refs sucked for a change the other way and BC is not only a bad team, but they have no talent. The Irish are loaded with talent, we just need to put it together.
    I hate Ohio St, but if they played ND, they would drop 50 on the Irish in a heartbeat. We are about a year from being in the top 20 again. Recruiting looks strong so far, but ND needs to run off every game until USC, who lost last night and hasnt looked that great all year. With a lot of momentum and better coaching, the Irish can beat USC

  6. Good win in a game that we should have won. That’s about all I can say. It was nice to see some flow in the offense, albeit for only a quarter. I will say that some of around ND are starting to notice Kelly’s tirades on the sidelines with his players. I hope that’s simply out of frustration with the early season disappointments and in a sign of how he will handle himself in the long-run. There’s really not a lot of room for that on the sidelines with the camera’s on these young kids. I’m looking forward to the Pitt game, hopefully we can carry the BC momentum into next Saturday.

    • I have absolutely zero problem with him yelling at players. A lot of coaches do that, and when you have a team coming off five soft years with a staff that was more concerned about NFL prep than college wins, they need more than a little foot-in-the-ass.

          • I triple that amen. I love a coach who is passionate and intense. Hopefully it will rub off on these kids. I am sensing it already is. Watching Crist on the sidelines talking to his coach, it is clear that there is a good rapport between the two.

          • They need yelled at. they should have put up 60-70 on these guys. BC was the worst team i have seen in college this year.

      • I don’t often agree with El Kabong but this is SPOT ON. This team spent the last 8yrs being soft. I’m tired of soft, with a coach with his arm around his players shoulders after a poorly executed play. I’m glad to see him all over his players.

        The goal here is for Kelly to have players more concerned about not doing their job than they are about the 80,000 cheering masses in the LA Coliseum. IF YOU CAN’T HANDLE BEING YELLED AT, YOU SHOULDN’T BE PLAYING IN FRONT OF 3MILLION PEOPLE ON NATIONAL TV.

        Its also time for us to stop the 2nd qtr letdowns. Step on opponents’ throats when we have the chance.

      • Kelly let’s them know when they screw up, but also let’s them know when they get it right. Turk got a “that’s the way” butt-slap the next series after getting chewed out for the shank. I am happy to see some passion and engangement out of our HC, especially after the last three guys.

      • Any reason they don’t put a small carbon fiber screen on his headset mic so you can’t see him swearing? It’s hard not to read lips. Of course, eSPN took every opportunity to show it.

    • It’s big-time college football. If the “young kids” want to join chess club or whatever, they can expect to avoid the “tirades.” But, in college football — heck in 5th grade football — coaches scream at players. Now, there are appropriate ways to scream — vulgarities, racist/sexist remarks and the like aren’t necessary or tolerable — but the screaming itself is fine. This is a game of motivation as much as it is a game of talent. Sure, Boise has good players but they also have a coach who can motivate the devil out of his kids. And, they win. Kelly has to find the right balance to motivate his kids.

      I guess what I am trying to say is this: I have NO PROBLEM with a coach who screams at his players.

    • I disagree completely, I love the tirades, it brings intensity to the players. When I played football, our coaches gave use negative feedback right away when deserved, and positive feedback when deserved. This has been lacking at Notre Dame for many years. Kelley is a great coach! Go Irish…..

  7. All things are true. It was at times painful to watch, but certainly worse outcomes are imaginable. It’s a good win, but BC was awful. We’ve beaten the two mediocre teams on the schedule, but not the ranked teams. This is not Notre Dame football, but there is hope.

  8. Solid win have to agree with some of you guys after the 1st qtr it was a slow moving game , but a win is a win esp when its against BC at chestnut hill hope they can get more consistant cannot remember the last time they played a whole 60 min game this team showed some last night. I hope they can keep improving and just grind till things click another under achiving team this weekend in pitt lets see who wants to turn there season around more big game BEAT PITT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  9. Kevin: If you don’t think there is room for the coach yelling at players on the sideline you may want to rewind some tapes from the Holtz era. Or maybe take a look at the Stanford sidelines last week. Both coaches and teams are examples of hard nosed, tough, winners. I think it’s refreshing that Kelly is demanding 100% out of these guys from start to finish whether they are up by 18 or not. How else is he going to change the under-performing culture leftover from previous years? I predict the ‘tirades’ will lessen when the team starts to perform consistently at a high level. Kelly is under enough pressure to succeed without this politically correct element being thrown in. It is football after all.

    • Good luck to the game of football if it’s considered PC to not yell at players on the sidelines. I for one don’t view it that way. These boys need Kelly to not only ride them during practice but in the heat of battle as well.

  10. Nothing special but a win is a win, and against BC on the road makes it a little nicer. ND was clearly superior, but they could have/should have scored 2 more TDs.

    Three or four shots of Kelly yelling at someone is enough, thanks.

  11. I think the jury is still out on this year’s team. I was not impressed with this win against a pitiful BC team. There were a lot of BC open receivers who either dropped the ball or had bad throws their way. A good BC quarterback and the game would have looked much different, but I agree a win is a win. I thought at the beginning of the season an 8-4 season would be progress and would be quite pleased with that and a trip to a mid-bowl (and a victory over USC!)

  12. What’s with the concern about BK losing his temper? I’ve noticed a lot of the BCS coaches fly off the handle. I recall many moments with Lou jumping up in the face of a chastened player.

    • Good point. More than one person – including Kelly – has stated that his intention is to make the point NOW and then move on, and also to instill toughness. I concede the point.

      If you don’t want to get yelled at on national TV don’t screw up. Seems fair enough.

  13. Man, some of you people are morons and you know who you are. We needed a win and got a win. End of freaking discussion. I will leave to the “meanie” Brian Kelly to work on the mistakes this week. All you folks out there bashing this team in victory have high expectations, should not the head coach have high expectations too. Does he really have to hold these kids hands after they f@#%k up. When Sam Young said a couple of years ago that he felt Syracuse just wanted it more and there was no public tongue lashing by the head coach in response, I knew the Irish were in deep deep trouble. Kelly will not accept mediocrity…. Thank Crist!!!

  14. i can’t believe kelly refused to abandon the no huddle late in the game with a big lead on the road. you’re not accomplishing anything but tiring out your defense because your offense can’t execute and you’re only taking 30-45 seconds off the clock each possession. very sad that he can’t adjust in-game and put his team in the best position to close out a win

    • Albert

      A win’s a win. But, a thrashing? It’s satisfying. As far as I’m concerned Kelly going no-huddle was fine. I like to see as many plays on offense as possible. Clearly the offense — from Crist down — needs work with the rhythm and timing. Getting more plays on offense is a good thing.

      This team definitely “closed out” the win — even with the no-huddle.

    • On the contrary, I think his decision to keep the foot on the gas makes very good sense, for more than one reason.

      First, this team is transitioning from a pro-style offense to a spread. One of the biggest advantages of Kelly’s spread version is that it moves very fast between plays, tiring out the defense and preventing defensive personnel substitutions. This transition is, clearly, nowhere near complete: the Irish take way more time between plays than Cincinnati did, and it’s plain that only part of the playbook is installed. Thus, every drive is precious time that increases the team’s experience and practice with this new system.

      Second, continuing to use the playbook late in the game while cycling in many young backups is a powerful way to get experience and develop much needed depth.

      Finally, weren’t many of us constantly bashing Weis for shutting down his offense as soon as he got a decent lead, only have the other team come back? I favor a coach with a lead putting in the back-ups and continuing to play the full book: it keeps teams focused and builds depth.

  15. I love Kelly’s Irish temper! It’s a refeshing change after the emotionless dud that was Charlie for five years. It used to be hillarious, seeing tiny Lou Holtz grab the face mask and yell in the face of a giant Lineman who was five times his size, who just got flagged for holding. Passion = results!

    • Right! I think Kelly is showing shades of sweet Lou on the sidelines and that’s freakin awesome…people are getting way to soft out there. Plus Matt “D BAG” Millen and ESPN forced that issue all night making a bigger deal than it is. Grab a face mask if you have too these kids still need a little fire set underneath them. GO IRISH

  16. I love the Kelly’s passion and it is just what this team has been lacking for the past decade. I also love our ILBs. Teo and Calabrese are beast.

  17. Before you knock ND look at the last min. of play in the great SE conference between LSU and Tenn. and you will love ND coach.

  18. I do not understand why ABC continues to pick up ND games. It is obvious to me that the only reason must be to see them lose, because when things started to go bad, suddenly Millen and Donough got excited when BC started coming back, but thank God it was short lived. As soon as it became apparent that ND was going to win it, suddenly we were talking about Herzlik, and showing extended shots of the crowd instead of leaving cameras aimed at the field, or showing extended shots of the coaches, or showing how the hockey rink adjoins the football stadium, or missing plays on the field, who gives a #$@%. COVER THE GD GAME. It was really annoying to have to sit and listen to these two morons do this broadcast. I am so glad ND pulled it off, so we didn’t have to listen to them gloat over a BC win.

    THANK GOD there is only one more night game on ABC left. I hope they at least have someone better than those two jokers do the next game against SC.

    Glad the irish won, I just wonder sometimes, if Crist has a clue what is really going on down on the field. He looks really good one minute, then all of a sudden it is like he doesn’t know what he is supposed to be doing. As far as Hughes goes, I think he and Floyd seem to be on Kelly’s list of Prima Donas or something. I think Hughes only got 2 or 3 carries and he wasn’t in the game after he dropped that 1st pass. Don’t understand why they don’t try to get Floyd a little more involved. He was so good last year. This offense is a little baffling at times that is for sure.

  19. “This was not an ND win?” What? We’re 2-3, and we are who we are. No doubt Crist is still settling into our offense, and no doubt we weren’t the dominant through four quarters. But at this stage in a new quarterback’s development, a win, on the road, at night, against an annual out-to-get-you foe, is worthy of positive commentary. Hopefully we can continue the trend at home against Pitt.

  20. Patience! Patience! I am from Florida and watched Urban Meyer’s offense be very inconsistent his first two seasons, some games great, some games very mediocre. They won a national championship, but only because of the defense in year 2. It took 3 years and his style of QB to get his offense moving in the right direction. Oregon’s former coach Belotti just said this year that he expected the ND offense to struggle because it takes 2 full seasons to get mentally & physically ready to run a spread offense, he should know. We have a young QB starting his first full season (remember Clausen’s Sophomore year, very inconsistent) at the same time an offense learning a new system. It will just take time to get this spread offense installed. Unfortunately, it means we have to lean on the defense to be more consistent.

  21. Kevin – are you really complaining about Kelly yelling at players? Or are you just pointing it out?

    Personally, I love it. And I have not seen it since Holtz. I’m sorry, but I sat through the Davie/Willingham/Weis era where they did not show that passion on the sidelines. And to me, it is refreshing.

    If a kid getting a $50,000+ a year education – FOR FREE – cannot handle being yelled at . . . well, I’m sure the cheerleading squad has open tryouts.

    • Actually I think I was the guy who first brought up the issue of Kelly yelling at the players on October 3, 2010 @ 5 p.m., and I stated that showing it 3 or 4 times was enough. It seemed to engender (big words day here in Maine) a lot of response and I conceded the point long ago.

      This was a good victory – one more building block, and the fact that it was on the road against a hated foe who hates us right back and has beaten us more than we have beaten them in the last few years makes it that much better.

      Beat Pitt!

  22. I have no problem with BK yelling at the players, but I’d much rather see him yell at theO-linemen and tight ends (who continue to fail to protect Dayne) and the starting D-linemen (who continue to fail to get near, let alone punish, the opposing team’s QB), rather than our punter and kicker.

    • Robert – I’ve seen him yell at any guy making a bonehead mistake. Whether that is the kicker putting it out of bounds on the 3rd Quarter kick off, Stewart with a blown assignment, Crist throwing into triple coverage or anyone else.

  23. It was a sloppy game and Notre Dame obviously needs to play better for longer periods of time to compete against top teams… but… the key to me is Coach Kelly knows that. He knows exactly where his team is right now and where it needs to go. Notre Dame hired the right coach – this team will get there. Hopefully we will see continued progress next week against Pitt… and… hopefully a win !

  24. I love seeing Kelly get fired up on the sidelines. I thought his comments this week were dead on. This team has definitely lacked a sense of physical and especially mental toughness (99% of succeeding on the field with this much talent and an intricate spread offense, is in the mind). Have we forgot after losing to a wretched Syracuse team with a back up QB a couple years ago on senior day Sam Young said he thought Syracuse just wanted it more. If that’s not a cry for help I don’t know what is. At least under Kelly no players will have that excuse again!

  25. I have no issue with Kelly (or any coach) getting intense with players. You can yell and scream all you want, as long as you’re TEACHING and COACHING when you do it. I don’t think Kelly’s berating or abusing these guys…I think he’s just (loudly) letting them know when something is unacceptable. Kudos to him.

    And there have been some comments about former coaches not being fired up enough, and how that was such a problem. Weis was lumped in with Willingham and Davie in a couple of posts. Toward the end of Weis’s tenure, even the last couple of years I’ll admit, that was true. But you can’t say Weis wasn’t animated and fired up early on. Take a look at the MSU/ND game a few years back when Quinn and the Irish came back in a monsoon, you’ll see Weis before he was a beaten and broken coach being vocal, animated, and a hell of a lot of fun to watch.

  26. We at BC would love to have a Brian Kelly. ND has the right coach now, and will continue to improve. BC is in major coaching disarray, and unfortunately has not bottomed out yet.

    I hope our poor performance didn’t take away from your victory. Our OC Tranquill needed to be fired yesterday. If he had any class, he’d retire immediately (for the 3rd or 4th time).

  27. I agree with the yelling. I like it, but it is nice to see he does not yell all the time. He picks his moments where he feels the conversation deserves a little more volume or inflection. He also takes the time (as a previous poster pointed out) to praise his players when they do well, as he did with Turk. He will discuss things in a calm manner when they warrent also. I think as time goes on, we will see less and less of this team getting yelled at during games, and we will see the team grow.

    Go Irish!

  28. The pros:

    1.) Offensively, we ran the ball against a team that stops the run. BC averages just 81 rushing yards allowed per game. We threw the ball against a team that can stop the pass. BC allows about 230 yards per game but also has 6 INTs on the season.

    2.) Defensively, we stopped a running game in its tracks. While this is hardly saying much — BC had no real running game going into this contest — it is still an improvement over how we played Michigan and Michigan State and Stanford.

    3.) For the first time since the 1990s, we won a game in Boston.

    Cons:
    1.) We don’t take care of the ball very well
    2.) We still struggle on offense. Crist looked confused on several occasions and the backs could have wracked up more yardage.

    On the whole, though, we have a lot to be proud of — and we won this game.

    Now it’s Pittsburgh, and let’s blow them out, too.

  29. Rich in Indy says:

    October 3, 2010 at 10:17 am
    Ignor the W’s and notice the little things. . . (1) plays are being sent in much quicker than the offensive guru (Charlie Weiss) used to send them in. . .the no huddle offence. (2) We are capable of putting up points (not quite there yet in order to compete in the big league) (3) Kickoffs are deep and sometimes in the end zone. (4) We have a field goal kicker for a change! (5) We have a punter! (6) Defense is maturing each game (minus a couple of big plays each game) (7) We have a spread offence. (8) Christ is developing (only his 4th start). (9) Running backs are beginning to find holes and fight for yardage (got to hold onto the ball tho) (10) Ver few penalties. . .maybe only one against BC? The IRISH are getting better each game. Brian Kelly developes players. Can’t wait to see what he can do with his own recruits the next few years.

    • “Can’t wait to see what he can do with his own recruits the next few years.”

      You got that right – we’ve got room for 2 or 3 more, let’s get some DBs.

      I never said Kelly shouldn’t yell, all I said was seeing it 3 or 4 times was enough.

  30. We didn’t get to watch the game in Denver because ABC and the ESPN channels chose to air other games, so I can only base my observations on what’s been written so far. I’m all for the coach getting in the player’s face mask immediately after the player mentally FUBARS a play or commits a stupid penalty that douses a drive or gives the opponent a new set of downs. Lou did it and it produced results. If a player can’t take it, then he should leave the team. On the flip side, a good coach also praises players immediately following a great play. Lou did it, and I’ve seen BK do it as well. Consistency is the key because players can pick up on a coach’s inconsistencies. My expectations for the remainder of this season this season are not high, but I’m hopeful. Most of all, I’m looking for CONTINUED improvement in the team’s discipline and execution in all three phases of the game as the season continues. A victory over USC on the road would be a great thing to build on for next season, especially for recruiting on the West Coast. GO IRISH! BEAT PITT!!!!