Ultimate Road Test for Irish

Notre Dame and Brian Kelly will have another opportunity on Saturday night to defeat an elite team when they travel to SEC Country to face the Georgia Bulldogs. The Fighting Irish are heavy underdogs in this contest even though they battled the Dawgs to the wire in a 20-19 loss just two seasons ago. Kirby Smart, who is 35-10 in his fourth season in Athens, has recruited a wealth of talent and is poised to make another playoff run.

The last two Georgia seasons have ended in heartbreaking losses to Alabama, first in the national title game and last December in the conference championship. Notre Dame is well aware that a victory could be a springboard to another undefeated regular season and potentially a second consecutive playoff berth. The game will be televised by CBS beginning at 8:00 PM Eastern time.

Fromm maintains a clean uniform

The Dawgs have looked the part so far this season after destroying three opponents, including conference mate Vanderbilt, by an average of 42 points. Quarterback Jake Fromm has completed 75% of his passes without an interception, and D’Andre Swift leads a powerful rushing attack that averages 7.6 yards per attempt.

The Irish offense has yet to hit on all cylinders despite a 2-0 start. Even the most ardent fans have acknowledged concerns regarding an inconsistent rushing attack and the lack of an intermediate or deep passing game. Both defenses have performed well to date, although Notre Dame has started slowly in both outings and has been gashed for a few big plays before righting the ship. A dominant pass rush has also failed to materialize as expected.

Georgia is dealing with injuries at wide receiver and in the defensive backfield, but the roster is so deep that quality replacements are at the ready. The offensive line is among the biggest and best in the nation, and the potential absence of right tackle Isaiah Wilson will quickly be filled by Cade Mays or Jamaree Salyer. The Irish remain depleted at the offensive skill positions, but hope to have tight end Cole Kmet and tailback Jahmir Smith back this week. Receiver Michael Young and running back Jafar Armstrong remain sidelined.

NOTRE DAME’S OFFENSE vs. GEORGIA’S DEFENSE

The Dawgs are well aware of Ian Book’s ability to turn a broken or well-defended play into positive yardage. Two countermeasures to look for are pressure up the middle and use of a spy on Book to contain his scrambles. Sophomore linebacker Azaaz Ojulari is a candidate for this role. The pass rush strategy will test Irish center Jarrett Patterson, who struggled a bit in the first two games.

Notre Dame must again have a credible running game to stay out of third and long passing situations. Georgia’s 3-4 alignment features a deep rotation up front led by tackle Tyler Clark, a three-year starter. The linebackers are big and fast athletes, with Monty Rice leading the way. The Dawgs also employ a hybrid type rover in defensive back Mark Webb, who may be the team’s best defender.

Notre Dame’s Offensive Line

A breakdown of Notre Dame’s running game lethargy to date shows that missed blocks and poor execution have caused numerous plays to fail. The tight ends in particular have scored poorly in terms of making blocks, while the linemen have been slightly better. Still, it only takes one poor effort to ruin a play. The other side of the equation is the run-blocking scheme itself, which has always been problematic against fast, physical defenses that quickly cover ground from sideline to sideline. The Irish rarely run Power-I, misdirection or isolation plays that might be more effective against this group.

When Book has time to throw, his receivers will work against a secondary that may be without cornerbacks Tyson Campbell and D.J. McDaniel. Talented underclassmen such as freshman Tyrique Stevenson, a five-star recruit, are ready to step in. Safety J.R. Reed is the seasoned veteran along the back end. For Notre Dame, Chase Claypool has been the mainstay at one wideout position, but others emerged against New Mexico last week to provide Book with more weapons. Senior Javon McKinley, whose vast potential has been unrealized throughout his career, finally broke out with two impressive touchdown receptions. Newcomer Braden Lenzy also flashed outstanding speed and playmaking ability in his first college level action. The expected return of Kmet to the lineup would also add a reliable option to the Irish attack.

GEORGIA’S OFFENSE vs. NOTRE DAME’S DEFENSE

The Irish have struggled to stop the run this season, especially in the early going. Smart commented on the fact that the Irish have yielded 230 rushing yards per game, but was careful not to criticize his opponent. ”Stats are overrated”, he said.  “I thought, especially the first game, there were some very different type runs.  I don’t know if they hadn’t seen those before, or if they’d been exposed to those.  You’re talking about a guy in (Louisville RB) Jawon Pass, who I recruited, as an elite athlete and a really good runner.  We’re different than that, so it’s a different kind of run-game type stuff.  I think people just look at rushing stats and they don’t look behind it.  There’s a lot more to the story sometimes than what meets the eye.”

Swift runs behind a formidable wall

Georgia’s massive front line boasts left tackle Andrew Thomas and left guard Solomon Kindley, who pave the way for Swift to average nearly ten yards per carry. Notre Dame’s interior defense and smallish linebackers will be sorely tested to keep the contest from becoming a pancake fest.

Quarterback Jake Fromm has been quietly efficient this season. The burden of carrying the offense does not fall entirely on his shoulders, and this lack of pressure has freed him to perform extremely well. The receiving corps is well-stocked despite the loss of Tyler Simmons, Kearis Jackson and possibly Demetrius Robertson. Freshmen George Pickens and Dominick Blaylock have picked up the slack and currently lead the team in receptions.

The Dawgs have yielded only one sack to date, and Notre Dame will need to be more successful if they hope to slow down this offense. Last year, tackle Jerry Tillery was a disruptive force who not only wreaked havoc in the middle of the pocket, but also helped to create opportunities for ends Khalid Kareem and Julian Okwara. This season, Tillery is in the NFL and both Kareem and Okwara have gone silent.

SPECIAL TEAMS

Georgia boasts highly skilled specialists and a wealth of speed to stock the coverage and return teams. Punter Jake Camarda has averaged 50 yards thus far, while veteran kicker Rodrigo Blankenship has hit all five field goal attempts and has excellent range. Simmons has been effective as the punt return man, but Blaylock may take his spot if Simmons’ shoulder injury keeps him on the bench. Reserve tailbacks Brian Herrien and James Cook handle the kickoff returns for the Dawgs.

Notre Dame’s Jonathan Doerer kicked his first and only field goal of the year last week, but it was a confidence building moment that he can draw upon in a hostile environment on Saturday. Punter Jay Bramblett hasn’t drawn much notice yet, which likely means he’s doing a fine job. The Irish coverage teams have been competent while the return teams have not shown much intensity. Georgia has the capacity to measurably alter field position in this phase of the game, so Notre Dame will have to be focused.

SUMMARY

Ian Book under extreme pressure

The Irish defense must be able to hold up for four quarters against a bigger, talented, and balanced Bulldog offense. It will be incumbent upon the Notre Dame offense to maintain drives and hold its own in time of possession. This will be difficult if Book has to throw the ball 40+ times, especially if he is made to feel uncomfortable in the pocket.

Georgia is not invincible, however, and the Irish have sufficient talent to create successful plays against them. The level of execution by the visitors must improve from the previous two weeks, as every mistake made on Saturday could be very costly. The best recipe for victory on the defensive side includes stopping the run sufficiently to force Fromm and his young receivers to outperform the talented Irish secondary.

Here are a few questions that will help determine the outcome:

Will the Irish break their habit of slow, shaky starts in big contests?

Can Book’s receivers get open against the Dawg’s depleted secondary?

Will Notre Dame’s defensive line hold up against the physicality of Georgia’s massive front?

Can the Irish generate a semblance of a running game beyond scrambles by Book?

Will the Notre Dame linebackers be able to keep Swift from running downhill?

Will Book have more time to throw than he did against Clemson?

Can the much-hyped Irish pass rushers finally assert themselves?

Which coaching staff will make the most effective in-game adjustments?

PREDICTION

Notre Dame must battle the Georgia heat, a hostile crowd, as well as a physical, deep and talented opponent. Their track record in similar matchups over the past two decades suggests this is a bridge too far, and it’s likely that the best Irish fans can hope for is a competitive showing. Another early meltdown (Miami 2017 comes to mind) where turnovers and a loss of poise ignite an embarrassing blowout could drop the program out of the playoff conversation for a long while. This year’s Irish are acutely aware of their media detractors this week, and should come out with a chip on their shoulders. While the defense should be able to keep matters respectable, the evidence to date suggests the offense won’t score enough points to win. Look for the Dawgs to pull away in the second half.

GEORGIA 31  NOTRE DAME 13

What do you think? Let us know in the comments below.

16 thoughts on “Ultimate Road Test for Irish

  1. I think our defensive line isn’t given quite enough credit, and I do think they’ll register a sack or two. I also think Georgia is going to be tested in the passing game, on both sides of the ball, and I foresee ND more likely being on the positive side of the turnover margin than the negative. This game will lend itself to short, efficient, high-percentage passing routes, which Ian excels at (at least last year), so I think we’ll be able to make some headway in that regard.

    However, in the end, fundamentals will win out. They will run the ball successfully, and we won’t. I really hope the linebackers are ready to step up today, I hope Asmar Bilal’s progress last week was a turning of a corner for him, I hope Alohi Gilman is our X factor on defense, I hope Georgia’s entire offensive line comes down with food poisoning…but in the end, fundamentals win almost every game. I think we’ll cover, but this won’t matter to haters like Feinbaum who will just say that shows Georgia isn’t all that good after all, because ND is always overrated.

    GA 41, ND 30

  2. A quite defensible analysis and prediction.

    GA expectations are sky high this year. The honeymoon is almost over for Kirby Smart. Anything less than an SEC championship and NC run, and fans will summon the spectre of Mark Richt. They are deeper and more talented than we are at every position.

    Our best offensive talent for this year’s squad has been either dismissed from school or is injured. Our defense appears not nearly as stout in the middle as last year’s.

    Even a close loss by ND would be a major surprise.

  3. Notre Dame does not have the muscle in the trenches to compete with Georgia for
    four quarters..

    Our OLINE was not able to push around an undersized New Mexico D… And this is
    the week that our Defense will be fully exposed for not having Tillery, Tranquil, and Coney
    around any more.. Georgia is loaded in the trenches on both sides of the ball..

    Book will not be able to use his feet to get him out of trouble on Saturday.. And he’s still
    not ready for primetime!! No lanes available for our RB’s to fun through..

    And we will lose (once again) the battle of the Special Teams. HOPE I’M WRONG..

    Georgia 45
    Notre Dame 10

    • Notre Dame’s relevancy, already shaky, will essentially disappear from the football scene should your prediction hold true.Those of us who grew up watching Parseghian and Holtz used to savor moments like this. Not true anymore. As Doctor Seuss once said, “sometimes you never know the value of a moment . . . until it becomes a memory”!

      I’m sorry Moose, but I believe the road around the stadium should be renamed Memory Lane.

  4. Georgia is the Fredo of the SEC. When push comes to shove, they’ll collapse. Their game manager qb will deliver an early pick six and late interception.

    Notre Dame 24. Georgia 19

  5. The Irish haven’t matched up against the elite SEC and Clemson. I really feel we are in the next tier just below that. Sometimes being just good enough to get blown out to the top few teams feels worse then being mediocre. It’s really not of course and the program depth has come along way but we are all captive to the moment and this world of “hot takes”. Unlike the Bama debacle and Clemson game last year, there is literally no national pundit giving them a chance.

    The time has come for ND to pull the upset and I think this is the right program to do it against. Georgia has struggled winning in these spots and are likely to feel the wait of the world if ND hangs in early. Just a hunch the boys start quickly, get a few turnovers and actually get a replay review in their favor. Irish stun the world 23-20. By midnight, Georgia is overrated will be the national takeaway.

  6. Big moment, on the road, at night, in prime time vs SEC power (supposed). Great atmosphere for a big time college football game between 2 top 10 teams. All sounds good. Botton line these are games ND does not win anymore especially under this coach. And if ND gives up rushing yards like they have the first 2 games this game might get ugly. There are no moral victories with a close loss. The only way to change the perception of the program is to go into Georgia and win. Do not see it happening.
    Georgia- 38
    ND-14

  7. You can count on one thing under BK in big games…totally unprepared, with no plan b, c or d. Georgia will have studied the last 9 seasons of Kelly disasters and go for the jugular right out of the gate. I fully expect this to be worse than the Miami game. This game will showcase ND’s lack of an elite quarterback lo these many decades. Georgia 45 ND 10.

  8. Let’s face it. Facing top ten teams on the road has never been Kelly’s strong suit. The team almost always seems out of sorts, intimidated and unprepared. Maybe we’ll be pleasantly surprised but the odds based on the previous nine years and Kelly’s deplorable record against the top 10 says we won’t be.

    I’m hoping for the best but expecting the worst. Georgia 38 ND 17

    Georgia could rip off some big runs against the porous front seven.

  9. ND hasn’t really shown me much so far this year, but Georgia, for all its hype, has also only played creampuffs. I don’t believe Georgia is unbeatable. Despite all the bookmakers they still have to play the game. Go Irish!

  10. ND plays lights out defense in 1st half. Georgia makes a run in 2nd half. But, still ND delivers the beatdown.
    ND 42
    GA 31
    No way Georgia comes closer than 10 points in this game.

  11. When is the last time ND beat a top 5 opponent on the road?

    Kelly is NOT a big time big GAME coach.

    Georgia 42-10.

  12. The last time Georgia played a real opponent they were down 28-7 with 5 minutes remaining in last years sugar bowl against Texas. Does everyone think Texas is that much bette than Notre Dame? Georgia is not invincible. If we play a clean game it should be close