I’m reasonably certain Mike Royko never said, “Some things you wonder, some things you think, and some things you just know.” On the other hand, I know I said on Rock’s House I would have a measure of this team by Halloween, once the fluffier first half of the season was over and the meatier second half was underway. Linus sits in the pumpkin patch, so here I am to make good.
I know this is the most fun I’ve had watching ND play football since 1993. When the team is performing well as the result of solid play as opposed to smoke and mirrors, it’s a great time for all.
Some friends think this season is a lot like 2012, but that’s not so. The 2012 team’s defense, while strong, was built around one guy, so when an across-the-board-talented team came along at the end of the season who could neutralize that one guy, the D couldn’t stop them. The offense, while “run-oriented”, still was too passive and gave in too many times to cute-by-half tendencies. The result was a lot of close games and the impression those guys weren’t as good as their record.
This 2017 defense is more talented throughout the depth chart and doesn’t present immediate weaknesses you know a team will try to exploit. All the units are playing hard instead of thinking hard, which makes them look more aggressive and helps the offense out. Meanwhile, the offense truly is run-first and is absolutely destroying opponents. Throw in the improvements in strength and conditioning, which has the team playing just as hard with three minutes left in the game as they do three minutes into one, and it makes you wonder if this team is better than its (very good) record.
I know that 77-yard run by Josh Adams Saturday will get him at least an invitation to the Downtown Athletic Club this December. I think if Brandon Wimbush can find the open receivers a second sooner than he is, not only will he be invited next year, he’ll bring the hardware home.
Some folks out there think the results so far this season indicate Brian Kelly is due some sort of apology from fans who were critical of him the past seven years. One thing I know for sure: Those folks are full of shit.
I think Brian Kelly deserves credit for a change in mindset this season. Even with all the changes made in the offseason, and while I thought ND had the talent to contend, I remained pessimistic because I wondered if Kelly could go against type and instinct and truly allow an assistant coach to take responsibility for the offense. Lo and behold, that seems to be exactly what he’s done. I didn’t think he could, but he did, so full consideration and kudos to him.
But let’s also remember how these changes came about. The underperforming coaches Mike Elko and Matt Balis replaced were kept LONG after their sell-by dates. It’s not like Brian Van Gorder had a stroke walking onto the field in Austin last year and suddenly lost the ability to call defenses — his shortcomings were evident in 2014, let alone 2016. And depending on who you believe, Kelly didn’t want to make those changes, but had his hand forced by people up the food chain. Good hires were made, no doubt about it … but let’s not pretend they were the latest in a string of them. They’re the obvious outliers in the last eight seasons.
This team is succeeding because it is doing the things I and those of my philosophical school have been asking Brian Kelly for: a team based on physicality that establishes its will at the line of scrimmage on both sides of the ball that uses a punishing ground attack on offense to soften up opponents. That approach caters to the kind of players Notre Dame recruits easily, has led to on-field success before, and we’re seeing it do the same in 2017.
Whining for apologies from the “meanie crowd” is like me wondering if the “harrumph, fullbacks” squad is going to admit they’ve been wrong about how ND can succeed for the last umpteen years. Answer: I really don’t give a damn because I’m having too much fun. As a friend of mine said, anyone watching this season thinking about settling Internet scores is living a miserable and annoying life. If and when ND men’s basketball makes the Final Four in the next couple years, I will burn exactly zero calories wondering what all the people who wanted Brey fired in the 2000’s are thinking.
So don’t wonder if I suddenly like Brian Kelly — I don’t. Wonder instead why you care if I do.
pobrien says:
Great post – full agreement.
The change is drastic. Did Brian Kelly go to a Nick Saban seminar offseason? All the talk of “dominating your opponent” instead of “taking what the defense gives you.” And lo and behold they are backing it up.
Seriously what happened to BK? Did he finally realize he had a problem and reach out for help? “Hi, I’m Brian and I’m a spreadaholic.”
topgome says:
The most nauseating phrase and mindset over the past twenty years, “we’ll take what the defense gives us”. It took Chip Long to purge the program of that bullshit and substitute, “we’ll take whatever we goddam please”. Kelly reminds me of the Japanese POW commander in ‘Bridge Over the River Kwai’ who finally admits he can’t get the bridge built and sits at the planning meetings with that vacant stare on his face while the British explain how the project will get done. This is finally ND football again. I’m almost in tears watching them play.
Terry McManus says:
Comparing Brian Kelly to Alec Guiness.
Interesting
Avon Domer says:
Quite frankly, I don’t have the time, energy or interest to look back at the Davey, Willingham, Weis and numerous Kelly seasons that went poorly and wonder what might’ve been. I’m too busy watching in awe as this Notre Dame team discovered it’s own identity this season in playing incredibly brutal and physically dominant football against everyone except an outstanding Georgia team, a loss that no one should feel ashamed of. Someone once said it’s never too late to do the right thing and Coach Kelly performed exceedingly well during the most recent off season in assembling a new coaching staff that has worked wonders in reverting the culture of Notre Dame football back to what we’ve all been waiting to see. Here’s hoping that coordinators Long and Elko, and director of football performance Balis don’t receive good enough offers that would entice them to leave in the off season, and that the Irish keep this momentum for many years to come.
Jerrod says:
Well said Avon Domer. This team is elite, unlike the 2012 team which an unbiased viewer would correctly say was good but lucky. Enjoy this boys and girls, this is what we’ve been waiting for.
Chuckie says:
Coach Kelly reinvented his coaching after perceiving a clear and imminent danger to his job. And the results prove this. All the more power to him. And may he NOT repeat the traits that brought that danger upon himself.
Kevin Welsh says:
When 3rd and 4 is a running down when the wind turns cold, you know Notre Dame is in the national conversation. I went back and watched the 1989 comeback against USC the other night. You are absolutely correct about 2012. We didn’t have the ground game needed to compete with the likes of Alabama. As far as the Kelly thing, I won’t offer an opinion. Nobody cares about mine anyway, ambivalent as I am. I’ll let the people who are paid to make those decisions, Father Jenkins and Jack Swarbrick, make those calls. Non-combatants such as ourselves tend to be overly critical when we’re down and inflated when we are realizing success. I’m thinking there won’t be too many alumni ads in the Observer this December calling for the head coach and AD’s head. “Victory has a thousand fathers, but defeat is an orphan.” John Fitzgerald Kennedy
Eddieo6 says:
I love watching this team pound the ball and wear down the opposition as they score points seemingly whenever they feel like. For the first time in forever I look forward to the defense taking the field. This unit plays hard, fast and with great confidence and swagger. GO IRISH!
Geoffrey says:
Now that BK has finally learned on the job how to best be the HC of the Irish, I hope he stays and continues to grow. We have suffered while he took several years to find his feet. Let that suffering not be in vain.
HudsonValleyIrish says:
“As a friend of mine said, anyone watching this season thinking about settling Internet scores is living a miserable and annoying life.”
:spends the preceding lines calling people “full of shit” asking for an online apology, amongst other swipes at internet Kelly supporters.:
The central premise of this piece is all about “online score settling”. Your friend, if he’s honest, probably thinks you live a “miserable and annoying life”. Hysterical. And hypocritical.
a68domer says:
Apparently BK entered himself into a football rehab 12-step program. The first thing new members are told, “You only have to change one thing – EVERYTHING!”
GO IRISH!! beat demon deacons
Ted P says:
A bit off-topic, but…
Can anyone explain why Alabama is ranked #1 in the polls? Who have they beaten? It seems pretty late in the season for them to be basking in the glow of last year.
Thanks.