Irish Rally Falls Short

Notre Dame stood its ground in the first half, was staggered by Georgia counter punches in the third period, but rallied behind quarterback Ian Book to put a scare into the Bulldogs before losing by 23-17 at Sanford Stadium.

The Irish outplayed the hosts in the first 30 minutes, taking a 10-7 lead into the locker room by recovering a fumbled punt deep in Georgia territory and turning it into a short touchdown pass from Book to Cole Kmet.

Swift gained 98 yards on 18 carries

The Dawgs asserted themselves with a dominant third quarter. Jake Fromm and D’Andre Swift guided the Georgia offense to a touchdown and three Rodrigo Blankenship field goals after intermission, and the Bulldog defense held Notre Dame to 19 third quarter yards.

Blankenship’s final three pointer gave his team a 23-10 lead with just under seven minutes remaining in the game, but Book and the Irish would not quit. Book scrambled for clutch yards, hit Kmet for 31 yards, and then found Chase Claypool in the end zone to cut the margin to 23-17 with 3:12 left.

Notre Dame’s defense appeared to be running on fumes in the late going, but they rose up to stop Georgia and get the ball back in good field position with exactly two minutes on the clock. The Dawgs did not fold, however, and a fourth down pass by Book under heavy pressure fell incomplete to end it.

The Irish had difficulty all night in coping with the hostile crowd. They were flagged five times for false starts and once for a defensive offside. Book also had to burn two second half timeouts that would have come in handy on the final drive.

A weak running game also proved to be decisive. Notre Dame gained only 46 yards rushing and the Dawgs forced Book to attempt 47 passes. Two second half interceptions by Georgia came at inopportune moments and set up two field goals that equated to the winning margin.

Let’s review the answers to our pregame questions:

Will the Irish break their habit of slow, shaky starts in big contests? Yes and no. The Irish overcame many of their maddening mental errors to build an early lead and kept Georgia off the field for most of the first half.

Can Book’s receivers get open against the Dawg’s depleted secondary? Kmet returned to the lineup and it was obvious that Georgia was not ready for him. Claypool competed hard and acquitted himself well, while Chris Finke struggled mightily to make a play.

Will Notre Dame’s defensive line hold up against the physicality of Georgia’s massive front? The Irish looked good in the first half when they were fresh, but missed tackles later in game were the result of Georgia’s relentless pounding.

Can the Irish generate a semblance of a running game beyond scrambles by Book? In a word, no. Tony Jones played hard but lacked the speed and wiggle to break free.

Will the Notre Dame linebackers be able to keep Swift from running downhill? There were moments when they seemed to wilt, but this group fought gamely until the final whistle and earned a measure of respect.

Will Book have more time to throw than he did against Clemson? A bit more, yes. The Dawgs rushed him into desperation passes in the last drive, though.

Can the much-hyped Irish pass rushers finally assert themselves? Not really. Fromm kept his jersey clean, and the Irish could not quite get to him even when they blitzed.

Which coaching staff will make the most effective in-game adjustments? Brian Kelly’s plan worked at the outset, but Georgia’s Kirby Smart shut down Notre Dame in the second half while the Dawgs pulled away.

The loss will hurt for a while, especially in light of the many unforced errors by the offensive line. Kelly’s teams simply do not appear to be poised in such frantic environments, but this group still found a way to compete. The silver lining is that most pundits and pollsters must now admit that Notre Dame belonged on this stage with one of the nation’s elite teams.

Tell John what you think in the comments below

42 thoughts on “Irish Rally Falls Short

  1. The first timeout in the first half was symptomatic. The Irish are energetic and optimistic about getting those two yards. Georgia is a bit frantic, seemed a bit off balance. Coach calls time out to deliberate.
    Great players don’t need to be overmanaged. They know something about football themselves or they wouldn’t be in this kind of game.

  2. The Lads did as well as Kelly’s philosophy would allow on offense. We will never beat a good team with Kelly. Missing Hieststand too hurts. Lea’s D played well until the offensive defects wore them out. It’s not a question of talent— the Irish can play with the vaunted SEC, it’s coaching.

  3. I predicted a blowout and I was completely wrong I’m glad to say.

    They fought until the very end but they were defeated by a (slightly) superior team.

  4. Another clear data point: on a neutral field the Irish drives wouldn’t have been abbreviated by off-sided-generated crowd noise. The outcome would’ve been considerably different if those drives stayed alive. Georgia’s a good football team but will definitely lose two games this year in the SEC; those losses will occur at away games. Future opponents this year will minimize Swift, a great player without whom Georgia is a just a good team.

  5. Notre Dame continues to have no down field passing game against highly ranked teams. Adjustments were easy for Georgia last night. Bring up the safeties and jump the underneath routes. They were never worried about our offense beating them over the top.

  6. Excellent, dispassionate summary of the game without the hysterics that usually grip most of us after these performances. Thanks.

  7. ND has the talent to play with anyone. I’m tired of just playing with everyone – at some point we need to beat one of the top teams.

    The rest of our schedule does not look too imposing. Michigan is overyped as usual. Virginia struggled with Old Dominion, Stanford hasn’t looked great, and USC is down to their (approximately) 17th string quarterback ND was very focused for UGa and played hard the entire game. Can ND avoid a letdown against lesser teams throughout the rest of the year? We’ll see.

  8. Nice summary.
    Notre Dame has an SEC quality defense. Were our run game better we would be a top 4 team. My Georgia fan friends have nothing but respect for our level of play — dont want no rematch.
    Win out go Irish!

  9. Don’t sell USC short. USC found a fabulous QB sitting way down the bench. He looks like a natural. The perimeter players on both sides of the ball are fast, big, and nasty. USC will challenge the Irish.

    • Agree that SC will be tough. Don’t injure their quarterback; their “next man in” just plays better. Go Irish!

  10. Thank God we had General Eisenhower as the Supreme Commander of Operation Overlord instead of Brian Kelly. ND will never beat a top SEC team with General Kelly. These teams will always outcoach Kelly. Since ND will never fire Kelly, they just need to quit scheduling Clemson, Georgia, Alabama and probably LSU.

  11. Not much to add, somewhere someone pointed out the poor clock management at the end of the first half that might have allowed a couple more plays rather than a field goal.

    The play calling with not much downfield even though the offensive line gave Book plenty of protection in the third quarter. It seemed a hurry up offense might have helped.

    I said before the game Georgia had not been tested by creampuffs. I agree with poster that they will lose 2 games in SEC play.

    No matter what ND is clearly on an upward trend. Go Irish!

  12. James Dejanovich says:

    Kelly is a big part of the problem when this team looses to highly ranked teams. Line play on both sides of the ball needs better coaching. Opposing quarterbacks have too much time to find receivers and running backs are able to make too many big plays.

  13. I read this column and blogs a lot but have never posted a comment.
    As I reflect on this game, I have wondered if the two “fake injury” situations were just that.

    Also without looking at stats, I wondered where Trimble was during the game. I expected him to be a factor.

    • Cole Kmet’s return to the lineup pushed Tremble back to the bench. Kmet is the starter and a much better blocker. ND ran a few double tight end sets with Kmet and Brock Wright. Wright caught a TD pass that was negated because Georgia had called timeout just before the snap. Later in the series Kmet snagged a TD pass that was actually intended for Tony Jones.

      Not sure about the injuries as to whether they were legitimate or not, but both players returned to action rather quickly. Edit: I’ve been assured by people in the know that these injuries were not faked.

  14. ND had every chance to win the game, but typical of Kelly and all the other coaches since 1994 (Hotlz went nuts with Powlus), ND has not had the mental toughness to get the big win. I said to myself in the first half, “Georgia is very beatable,” but ND couldn’t capitalize on their momentum and came out flat in the third quarter.

    The loss goes to the O Line; they had chances to spring big plays on screen plays, but the soft offensive linemen couldn’t even touch a linebacker, Kelly called out one of them who was the closest of the three who olayed the linebacker in the 2nd quarter, and on the last drive on 2nd down the center couldn’t even find his assignment and the RB got tackled for no loss by the LB and they couldn’t block the rest of the drive.

    So, the O Line is soft, can’t run-block or even make up for it by executing finesse screen blocks, (the sad thing is a few of those guys will be 1st round draft picks); the D is actually pretty tough, but won’t win you games (UGA doesn’t have a very versatile offense); and the passing routes don’t give enough quick check down options, you always see guys running with their backs to the QB as he gets pressured with no slants or easier routes over the middle. To top it off, after marching down the field on the prior drive, getting a 3 ‘n out, a shanked put and the ball at the 50 with plenty of time and UGA on its heels, the O-line and back can’t protect a mobile QB and you can’t will yourself to a win that choke artists UGA really wanted to give you.

    Clearly, Kelly’s players don’t have the confidence or the spirit to win big games, he doesn’t motivate them and probably messes with their heads so they don’t trust their instincts or feel like competing. Maybe they win out, but will get crushed by BAMA, Clemson or OSU.

  15. The lack of a solid rush attack was clearly the difference in the game. If they had that, they could beat Georgia and be a serious contender. Without a rushing game, they are just too one dimensional, which puts too much pressure on Book.

  16. in 1966 my dad took the game of the game century. I was 10 years old. I remember the barefoot kicker from Mich State. Next Week my dad will be at the Virginia game. ( maybe his last game). My first T shirt was an ND T shirt actually I am wearing one now. Ok so to the point.. GET RID OF KELLY..he never has won a big game,,NEVER!!!!!!!! ( don’t give me the Oklahoma BS) ND has all the talent in the world. Lets get real…Kelly doesn’t have it. He would probably do ok at ASU…NOTRE DAME needs a winner.

  17. I was never a big Kelly fan, but give him his due. He has resurrected a mediocre Notre Dame program to a point where it is a top 10 program. Even Parseghian and Lou Holtz didn’t go undefeated every year. I know the buck stops with him, but I put this loss on Chip Long’s play calling.

    I hear the chorus of he can’t win the big road games, but remember Charlie Weiss bragging when he came on board that the Irish would no longer lose to the likes of the Pttsburgh’s and the Purdue’s? How did that work out?

    Kelly has returned Notre Dame to relevance which is where it hasn’t been for over 20 years.

    • Not a Kelly fan, never will be, but totally agree with this post

      D played great

      Disappointing we don’t have a running game.

  18. Hey!!! Kelly’s the scapegoat. Jesus!!!! ND fans are living in yesteryear. Unjustified hubris. It’s a new era fellas( notice I didn’t mention women because the wouldn’t justify this machismo banter.) Parity, admittance standards, diminished cachet, lots of reasons. The forty year pitch doesn’t work because if an athlete is not a good student he goes to Bama, Georgia, Clemson, LSU, Florida State whatever, to get to the Big Dance. We are a very good team. It’s a competitive environment. It’s not ’93,’88,’66,’46, or even ’26 for Christ’s sake. Not making excuses. Fact of the matter .Our recruiting is improving, have faith you wayward Catholics.By the way, who replaces Kelly? Who wants the new millenium Notre Dame job with all the scrutiny? I’m open. I love Notre Dame. Go Irish. Win out.!!

    • A dead cat could win ten games with this roster and schedule. It’s the tough games that always end in defeat. Kelly’s Mickey Mouse offensive system will forever keep us from becoming an elite program.

    • My cat would do the job for much less than Kelly is getting, but she’s still alive at the moment. There are plenty of quality coaches out there and ND has a number of advantages that other schools do not. Current coaches at Florida, Wisconsin, Oklahoma, Purdue, Louisville, Colorado and other schools should be interviewed, among many others. There are also a few major program coordinators who may be candidates, including Clark Lea. Whomever is AD after Slimy Jack can pick the best one. Kelly’s act is tired and his ceiling has been established. If he were hit by a bus tomorrow, he would have to be replaced. It’s time for the process of vetting potential candidates to begin.

      • Agree with your assessment that Kelly’s ceiling has been reached. Georgia adjusted to ND’s first half success in 3rd quarter and ND failed to respond. Game, set, match.

      • John, I understand the frustration. Coaching wasn’t very good last night. Too many penalties and terrible time management. Clearly, though we were one dimensional and that’s not the coaches fault per say. They have receivers making incredible big catches and we have Chris Finke not securing the catch and causing a big momentum shift in the 3rd. Again we lost on the big stage so I am as frustrated as anyone on here. Here is my take on changing the coach.

        There are a select few who could handle all that goes with ND job and would take on the challenges that come with the academics ,weather/geography and pressure to win titles and most importantly achieve greater results then Kelly. I would say of the actual men who would take the job, Chris Petersen would be my first choice. Paul Chryst would probably be a close second and that might be about it. Lincoln Riley and Urban Meyer aren’t coming folks. Coaches like Dan Mullen would never handle all that goes with ND nor have any desire to leave the south which is clearly the hotbed of talent and gives you a huge effort in recruiting. And if you think anyone could win with 10 with this roster, take a look at FSU. As much talent and are starring at back to back horrible seasons without Jimbo. Just saying, need to keep this all in perspective.

        • You never know who might be interested in the job unless you reach out to them. One positive thing Kelly has done is put the program in a stronger position now than where he found it. Therefore, the level of candidates who may not have been interested in the job ten years ago will see a more attractive situation today. Besides, the ND administration has systematically dampened the expectations around football such that a new coach will not feel pressure to win titles. I know Kelly feels no such pressure to keep his job now.

          • I completely agree about having those back channel discussions to gauge interest. Kelly has gotten the program much closer to elite so to your point maybe I’m misreading the coaching interest. I’m open to it but somewhat skeptical we get someone who elevates us further. Does anyone around the program regard Chip Long as a possible successor? I know it went poorly with Davie but that feels like ages ago.

  19. The kids played hard and didn’t quit and they should be commended but the penalties, mental errors and turnovers at inopportune times have been the hallmarks of Brian Kelly’s teams at ND. ND decided to take the third quarter off and still came close to pulling it out. IMO, this game showed that ND still lacks a few difference makers on offense, primarily a stud running back with speed and power to make something out of nothing such that Clemson and top tier SEC teams always have and stud defensive lineman. RB recruiting has been pretty pitiful the last three years.

    After ten years of Kelly we’re celebrating that ND didn’t get blown out by a top five team and only lost by six which is kind of sad when you think about it. Success is now defined not by national championships and regular wins against top ten teams but by close losses to them.

  20. What a joke. You hold yourself up as the best in college football and then fake injuries. Bush league. No wonder you can’t win any games – your coach and players look for the easy way out. All of you who want to play Georgia again, bring it on. Another game, Georgia would win by 20. Neutral field? Hell, you can’t even get 50% of your fans to your field. Sum it up – Notre Dame is yesterday. No relevance to today. Enjoy your ghosts.

    • WOW… we have a visitor to the site. Welcome, Bo!

      Don’t worry, Georgia will find some way to choke, AGAIN, they always do. As for Fromm… he’s your primary choke artist as evidenced by last season’s SEC Championship *AND* 2017 National title games.

      Have a nice season!

      Oh, and please be sure whine again in December about having a shot at the CFP with *TWO* losses. I loved the entertainment. By the way, Clemson owns the SEC! Your Bullpups wouldn’t have had a hope or prayer against them.

      • Georgia’s beaten your ragtag group of castoff players what, three out of three times? Your coaches are so smart they weren’t expecting a loud stadium? Keep thinking you’re all that. You’re yesterday. And that’s the best you’ll ever be…

        • Georgia’s last title was nearly 40 years ago. LMAO!!! Yeah, Keep thinking you’re all that!! How many times does Alabama need to pound that into your head in the SEC title game. It’s getting to be like the definition of insainty.

          UGa (before SEC CG): “We are in the SEC Championship game!!! YEAH!!”

          UGa (Two weeks later): “Alabama kicked our asses kicked again. *sigh*”

          Hey, ND had it one time since 2012. UGa has had it, what, 4-5 times since then? Yeah, you’re all that! LMAO

          Hell, y’all had a 13-0 lead going into halftime of the 2017 title game… only to lose 26-23 while allowing a FRESHMAN QB replace Jalen Hurts and kick your asses in the second half!! LMAO!!!

          Your puppies will blow it again, just give them time. But, keep on thinking you’re all that! I enjoy the parody and entertainment of it all, pal.

        • Not to mention, Tagovailoa was replaced by Jalen Hurts…. the guy you stopped in the previous year’s title game. Couldn’t stop him in the SEC CG, though, could ya? He led Alabama to TWO scores to end your hopes at another playoff!!! LMAO!!! But, UGa is all that, right? Keep on dreaming, Bob!! Why don’t you join Herschel Walker back in yesteryear!!! At least ND has had one title and 2-3 other chances since 1981!!! LMAO!!!!

    • Mike Golic said on his radio show that when he played for Philadelphia Eagles they had a set rotation of defensive players who would take turn faking injuries when they needed a blow. Same reason NHL goalies experience a lot of their equipment problems (and have to come to the bench) after their team just iced the puck and can’t replace players. Same thing at play, gain the advantage. Very common. Just part of the game or in the case of hockey the match, of which it’s rather obvious you’ve played neither.

  21. The crowd noise was fully anticipated. Kelly failed to have them prepared. For one thing snap the ball quicker. Forcing linemen to wait for all that motion. U can’t win big games making all those mistakes . In addition to penalties, snap ball when not ready , using up your timeouts. Kelly record in big games speaks for itself. He has good points but his QBs have never progressed to true stardome.

  22. There is no shame at all in losing to a quarterback as good as Jake Fromm. He needs to be in the Heisman conversation.

    That being said, we will never win a championship as long as our line is that unprepared. It’s not a question of talent; we have a bunch of highly-rated offensive linemen with a lot of raw talent. It’s also not an issue with scheme; Chip Long is doing a great job making adjustments to put his team in a position to succeed. This is a failure in player development. They aren’t strong enough or skilled enough to get the job done. We need another Harry Hiestand.

    Finally, I (along with just about everyone else) owes Clark Lea and the entire linebacking corps an apology; they’re a lot better than we gave them credit for. That was an incredible job against one of the best rushing offenses in the game.

    • Agree that Clark Lea did a great job with the defense. It turned out they were the strong suit, not the offense. Not so sold on Chip Long. Worried Clark Lea may be gone after this season if his success continues.