Not Again

This week’s column was ready to post when news of Zach Auguste’s suspension broke. So much for a positive tone.

The first report that included comment from Notre Dame was Angelo DeCarlo’s, posted on WNDU.com at 10:30 AM on Wednesday. The spokesman said that the length of the suspension had not been determined yet and that Notre Dame Head Coach Mike Brey would address the situation after the game against Georgia Tech.

There will be plenty of time to assess the situation, evaluate Notre Dame’s support system for athletes, and offer opinions about what, if anything, should be changed. In the meantime there is a basketball issue. The Irish have a game at Georgia Tech Wednesday evening, the same Georgia Tech that took them to two overtime sessions 11 days earlier, the same Georgia Tech that had a 46-31 rebounding advantage over the Irish, the same Georgia Tech that puts three bulky 6’8” guys on the floor most of the time compared to Notre Dame’s four guards and Auguste.

Will this be a brief suspension or a long one? If it’s the latter, it’s time for Martinas Geben to be a hero in the Tory Jackson mold.

Jackson was Kyle McAlarney’s backup at point guard when he was a freshman in 2006. He was a regular in the playing rotation who, while not ready to be the main man at the point, was progressing nicely when McAlarney was suspended as 2006 rolled into 2007. Thrust into the starting role, Jackson had one game against Stony Brook to get himself ready for a Big East schedule that began with Louisville, Georgetown, and West Virginia.

Jackson scored 3 points against Stony Brook and had 5 turnovers. It was a shaky start, but he rose to the occasion. He scored 14 points and had 4 assists with 4 turnovers in a 78-62 win over Louisville. He did not play well in a road loss to Georgetown; but he followed with a solid effort, 6 assists and only 2 turnovers, in a victory at the expense of WVU.

Jackson got nothing but better from there. He finished the conference schedule with a 9.4 points scoring average and a 2.1 assist/turnover ratio, and the Irish finished fourth in the Big East with an 11-5 record.

Can and will Geben respond similarly? It isn’t a fair expectation, but he has a lot going for him. I believe he already is a better post defender and a better screener than Auguste is; but Auguste is the better scorer, especially rolling to the basket after setting a screen, and a better rebounder (measured per minute). The most important improvement Geben must make is to stop rushing easy shots, a common malaise for a freshman who hasn’t caught up to the speed of college competition. The easiest way to to that is, as a wise friend of mine likes to say, to dunk the damned ball.

Geben’s progress is now the story of the season. He doesn’t have to be great, just solid, for the Irish to continue their success. Remember how good Tory Jackson wasn’t immediately but became as the season advanced. Geben is talented enough to make the same kind of progress no matter how raw he seems against Georgia Tech on Wednesday and Miami on Saturday.

Really?

My kids learned at very early ages that when they go to a game with their dad, we won’t be leaving early. We will never be the fools who missed Jerian Grant’s 2013 closing minutes explosion to force what turned out to be a five overtime Irish victory in an attempt to beat traffic. Remarkable finishes don’t happen often, but that’s all the more reason to avoid missing them by leaving before a game is over.

That’s why my daughter was so surprised when, with 10 minutes left in last season’s Notre Dame loss to Virginia, I looked at her and said, “Let’s go, Amy. I don’t need to watch this (poop) any more.”

Her reaction was one word. “Really?”

The Irish were not competitive against Virginia a year ago, and it wasn’t just the Cavaliers’ margin of victory. Demetrius Jackson remembered it like this. “Mainly they kicked our butts. They beat us on the glass, we had turnovers, and we couldn’t really guard them.”

Notre Dame was an incompetent basketball team that day. Notre Dame was intimidated. Notre Dame was unwatchable.

Win or lose vs. Virginia, how Notre Dame competed was the most important measure of Saturday’s game. In that regard, the Irish acquitted themselves well; but there remains an intimidation factor to overcome.

ND made only 10 of its 35 two point shots, a woeful 28.6%. Many of those missed shots were layups that were rushed in anticipation of defenders that weren’t there. Virginia is a great defensive team, so strong defensively that opponents expect them to contest every shot whether they actually do contest them or not.

The Irish actually defeated the Virginia defense regularly. They executed well enough to earn layups but didn’t have the confidence to recognize that they had done so. In the words of Patrick Connaughton, they did not make winning plays.

“I think we did a majority of things right, but we didn’t do enough things right,” Connaughton said. “I liked the offensive rebounds, and we won the rebounding margin overall. Those are things we have been working on and want to build on.

“They made the winning plays,” he said. “We have to execute a little bit better.”

V.J. Beachem said, “We know we can fix those things. Just to learn from this game, to move forward, I think that’s what is important for us.”

Irish fans should hope for another shot at Virginia in the ACC Tournament. Notre Dame has come a long way from “Really?” but still has to develop the confidence to make the winning plays no matter who the opponent is. They need a second Virginia measuring stick before the postseason starts.

Tom Hawkins

Notre Dame will honor Tom Hawkins with induction into the Ring of Honor at halftime of Saturday’s game vs. Miami. Few deserve it more.

A 6’5” forward who played at Notre Dame from 1956 to 1959. He was the only African American member of the basketball team at the time as well as in his entire graduating class.

“If being black was a problem to other people, it was their problem,” Hawkins told UND.com when he was selected to Notre Dame’s All-Century Team in 2004. “I had an education to get, I had basketball to play, and I enjoyed myself. I enjoyed the city of South Bend and I became a two-year All-American there.”

Indeed, Hawkins was on the AP’s All-American third team as a junior and second team as a senior. The Minneapolis Lakers selected him in the first round of the 1959 NBA draft, and he had a 10-year career that included two stints with the Lakers surrounding four years playing for the Cincinnati Royals. When his playing days were over, Hawkins became a broadcaster, a baseball executive, and finally an author.

My first memories of Hawkins came from his broadcasting work. Likable, insightful, and a good story teller, Hawk’s tales of playing with teammates like Jerry West, Elgin Baylor, and Oscar Robertson gave rare insights into life in the NBA.

To this day, Hawkins holds Notre Dame records for rebounds in a season (499) and for a career (1,318 in three seasons), records that have stood for 55 years. Luke Harangody probably is the best rebounder in most Notre Dame fans’ memories, but Harangody’s four year rebounding total fell 96 short of Hawk’s three year total.

Hawkins averaged 16.7 boards per game for his college career, a record at the time that fell to second behind Walt Sahm’s 16.9 in the early 1960s.

There are a few seats left for Saturday’s game. If you can, get yourself to Purcell Pavillion to honor one of Notre Dame’s all-time greats.

7 thoughts on “Not Again

  1. Ed Graham '83 says:

    Kevin:

    Just a brief note on Tom Hawkins. I had the dubious distinction of having a seat in the Coliseum this past November for the “beat down” that USC gave ND. It was extremely disappointing to see the lack of spirit and competitiveness generally exhibited on the field that day. The only redeeming moments of the first time experience at the Coliseum were provided by Tommy Hawkins as I had the unique pleasure of sitting next to him. In the course of the afternoon, we struck up a conversation. I marveled at the stories of old, including Tommy’s personal athletic accomplishments both at Notre Dame and in professional basketball. I learned about the unusual path he took to Notre Dame, and I spoke to him of my admiration for his color commentary with Haray Kalas on Notre Dame broadcasts.

    But the single most important memory of my contact with him will be the unquestionable appreciation he holds for his Notre Dame experience. His story-telling was captivating, and detailed, as he spoke about the unrivaled environment created in the Old Fieldhouse and the “spirit” of the Notre Dame student body that supported those Notre Dame basketball teams.

    It was a difficult experience to watch the play on the field that day, but it was well worth the price of the ticket just to be in his company. As a true testament to the loyalty of this Notre Dame man, my wife and I left the Coliseum that day as the 3rd Quarter ended like many other Notre Dame fans. Not Tommy………no, he remained in the same seat with an undivided loyalty to his beloved Notre Dame. I left Tommy’s presence at that time, but not without offering my remarks about my admiration for his loyalty to Old Notre Dame. He is a most deserving recipient of this distinctive honor! I hope the response on Saturday will be loud and raucous much like the experiences he described in the Fieldhouse as a player!

  2. Robert Butler says:

    Kevin, what has happened to the ND support system for athletes? This stuff happens waytoo much. ND has a very good bb team. This stuff can’t keep happening. Are the rules at ND way to strict. This just doesn’t happen at other schools. There wouldn’t even be a report of problems at many other schools.

    • Kevin O'Neill says:

      It actually does happen at other schools. Examples:

      – Before the season started, the NCAA determined that UCLA freshman Jonah Bolden was a partial qualifier and therefore ineligible to play this season. UCLA had expected the highly rated forward to be in the playing rotation this season.

      – Just a few weeks ago, UCLA sophomore forward Wanaah Bail was ruled academically ineligible. He will miss the remainder of the season. In a related story, Bail’s parents will be flogged for naming him “Wannah.”

      – Florida State played Notre Dame without its leading scorer, junior guard Aaron Thomas, who had just been declared out for the remainder of the season because of grades.

      – SMU starter Markus Kennedy was ineligible for the first semester because of academics.

      – St. John’s forward Keith Thomas, an incoming transfer from Westchester Community College, has been academically ineligible for the 2014-15 season. Lavin gave him a scholarship despite an ongoing transcript scandal at Westchester.

      – Two weeks later at St. John’s, 7-foot center Adonis De La Rosa, was declared ineligible because of suspicious test scores. De La Rosa was initially cleared by the NCAA, but his status changed following a review of his SAT scores.

      – Georgetown had to play the second half of last season without center Josh Smith because of grades.

      – Western Carolina senior guard James Sinclair was just ruled academically ineligible and was slated to miss the remainder of the season. Then WCU reinstated him two days later. Supposedly they counted an “F” twice. Much better now.

      – Michigan’s Mitch McGary tested positive for marijuana. Rather than face a suspension, he declared for the NBA draft leaving Michigan without a good big man this season. McGary has spent most of this season in the NBDL.

      This is Google search pages 1 and 2. There is plenty more where these came from. It’s surprising how many schools have to deal with academic issues… or maybe it isn’t.

  3. The timing on Auguste’s suspension is puzzling … Seems late to be announcing this if the issue was from last semester. Don’t grades come out prior to Christmas? I suppose if a student was granted an incomplete and was given time to complete an assignment over the break and then didn’t meet the requirement that a delayed suspension would make sense.
    Nevertheless, the ND B-ball smoke and mirror show is well underway again with last night’s game proving once again that Coach B and staff are still spectacularly creative (ala ‘the Burn’ when Hansbrough played) at finding ways to compete and win.

  4. I agree that other schools have had similar issues but clearly there has been a bit of an epidemic at ND over the past three years. I don’t think we should look the other way but I also think the school should take a good look at what is going on and consider what their fault in the situation is. Is there enough support for the athletes? Something is wrong

  5. I’m sorry. No real fan leave a game with 10 minutes left just because his team is not playing well on that particular day. That’s just weak. I don’t care how you attempt to rationalize it, that’s the very definition of a fair weather fan. That’s not a compliment.

  6. Were you at the 5OT game? I was there with my 11 year old daughter. My kids also know that we stay until the Alma mater song is played. I did, however, have that feeling after Louisville made a basket with 45 seconds to go that we could not win. I was just staying because I want to support the team win or lose. Right after that Louisville basket probably 1-2 thousand people left. You are right those games do not happen often but that will probably go down as the best athletic game I have watched (part of that experience is that it is a memory I will share with my daughter forever. It was almost two hours of pure excitement. Whenever I mention it to her, it puts a smile on her face. Given that experience it might even rank higher than the 1988 ND vs Miami football game (my freshman year). It was also interesting to see the difference in coaching between Mike Brey (supporting and cheering his team) and Pitino (berating his team even as they would come down the floor for the winning shot at the end of each overtime.

    To the topic at hand: On one hand it would be nice that these things did not happen and hopefully the student athletes are getting plenty of support. Each athlete still has to do the work. We all have made and will continue to make mistakes. Getting through Notre Dame was hard enough and I did not have to dedicate time to a sport, band or ROTC.